Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Finding centre from inside a big hollow cylinder

Posts

Finding centre from inside a big hollow cylinder

#1

Finding centre from inside a big hollow cylinder

GolfSteve in Calgary

Let�s pretend you�re turning a hollow form 6000 mm (19.6 feet) in diameter. There�s an axial rod running through the centre of the vessel, held on the centreline with a guide, but you managed to bend the guide. You�re standing inside the vessel and the bottom third of the vessel is full of dirt, so you can�t reference the bottom of the vessel.

How to you find the exact centre so you can realign a new axial guide? Your toolkit consists of one Chinese wrench, one Chinese hammer, a cell phone, a Beall tilt box (thanks Lee Valley) and maybe a piece of string with a bunch of knots tied in it.

The cylinder and axial guide:


When the machine was built they had a bunch of fancy alignment lasers and doo-dads and lots of guys with big brains running around. Once the ends of the cylinders were installed you can�t reference stationary points outside the machine anymore and all the smart guys left.

I�m throwing this out there mostly for laughs and hoping for a simple solution from folks used to finding centres. I�m sitting in the mud in China with a broken machine and need to figure out how to get the bent guide for the axial rod aligned perfectly on centre to less than ~3-5 mm tolerance. The machine weighs 2800 tonnes, rotates at 4 rpm, and operates at 500 to 740�C (950 to 1400�F).

Cheers,

Steven

(living �The Chemical Workers Song� by Great Big Sea)

ps. After screwing around trying to measure centre when there�s nothing to reference to, I�ll probably weld a stand onto the cylinder with a target on it. I�ll mount a spring loaded pencil onto the bent stationary axial guide, then turn the machine several revolutions, drawing a circle onto the target. If this works then I�ll know how much, and in which direction, to move one end of the axial guide. The other end of the axial guide is more difficult and I haven�t figgered that one yet.

My tools, a Chinese hammer:


And a Chinese wrench:


Re: Finding centre from inside a big hollow cylinder

#2

Re: Finding centre from inside a big hollow cylind

Stuart Johnson

On paper this seems to work.

1. Cut two bars exactly the same length that are one foot less than the diameter. Length doesn't matter as long as they are shorter than the diameter.

2. Place one perfectly level across the bottom.

3. Place the other level and in line across the top.

4. Hang a plumb bob from the exact center of the top bar

5. One half the length of the distance between the bars on the plumb bob should be the center.

I think this will give you an exact center as accurate as you are able to measure.

Re: Finding centre from inside a big hollow cylinder

#3

Not an answer, but a question ...

Fred Bearman

Out of curiosity, is this a tunnel-boring machine?

Thanks.

Re: Finding centre from inside a big hollow cylinder

#4

A thought

Al Goldstein

Hard to give an exact answer without knowing all details about your huge machine. Your suggested method of finding one axial point should work.

I would assume that your method of using the machine to trace a circle would find one point on the central axis at the back end of the machine. If so, then once you have found this back center mount a piece of cardboard (or whatever you have) there with a small hole placed exactly on the center. Mount another piece of cardboard near the front end. Then aim a laser pointer through this hole. The path of the laser spot on the front end piece of cardboard again will be a circle. Keep readjusting the position of the laser pointer until the laser spot on the front end cardboard traces a very small circle (or none at all). Then you will have two points of the exact cylinder axis separated by almost the length of the cylinder.

Hope this works or leads you to a better method of finding the needed second point.

Re: Finding centre from inside a big hollow cylinder

#5

Just curious

Carole Valentine

What company do you work for and what the heck are they boring for? I Know it's none of my business, but since you posted, my curiosity got the best of me. :D

Re: Finding centre from inside a big hollow cylinder

#6

Re: Not an answer, but a question ...

GolfSteve in Calgary

It's a machine to produce non-conventional oil from oil shale. Oil shale is mined, then heated to 500 deg C. At 500 deg C, a portion of the shale is converted to oil and then recovered.

Each machine has the capability of producing 2,500 to 5,000 bbl/d depending on the grade of the oil shale ore. Larger machines not yet built can produce up to 10,000 bbl/d.

We found a self-levelling laser today. That will be useful. We were also informed that the center tolerance is less than 1 mm, which makes things tougher.

Re: Finding centre from inside a big hollow cylinder

#8

Re: Finding centre from inside a big hollow cylind

Guy Bratt

I'll be no help with your aligment issues, but I'd like to order a set of wrenches :D I've attended a number of safety classes and many times we've seen tools, rigging and PPE fashioned exactly the same way from that part of the world. To be fair some very interesting creations from the good old USA also. >(

Re: Finding centre from inside a big hollow cylinder

#9

Leo Cuellar

Re: Finding centre from inside a big hollow cylind

Leo Cuellar

Perhaps, if you have bamboo available you could also use that pencil and make a measuring stick half the diameter to scribe arcs to find center at the other end?

Re: Finding centre from inside a big hollow cylinder

#10

3 Strings 

charlie belden


Re: Finding centre from inside a big hollow cylinder

#11

Re: Not an answer, but a question ...

Fred Bearman

Thank you for your very interesting answer - this seems quite fascinating to me, and I will look into this further. Best of luck with your current problem.

Re: Finding centre from inside a big hollow cylinder

#12

Re: Finding centre from inside a big hollow cylind

Bruce Pratt

Assuming you have some 2x4's or equivalent, construct an equilateral triangle with the sides equal to the radius of the tunnel. Placing one side of the triangle as a chord of the tunnel. the opposite corner of the triangle will be at the center of the tunnel. If it is not exact, rotate the triangle around the circumference of the tunnel, and the inner corner of the triangle will at least scribe out a much smaller circle, from which it will be easier to find the center. Unlike Charlie, I can't figure out how to post a picture. If you have an email, I can send a diagram.

--------

Bruce Pratt

Re: Finding centre from inside a big hollow cylinder

#13

Steven Antonucci

The most awesome story I've ever read

steven antonucci

I need a Chinese hammer and wrench.

Awesome.

Steve

P.S. I have no idea how to fix your problem.

Re: Finding centre from inside a big hollow cylinder

#14

Thanks Charlie

GolfSteve in Calgary

You've given me some ideas to consider.

You want a job in China? :-)

Re: Finding centre from inside a big hollow cylinder

#15

Bruce Pratt's Isocoles Triangle Center Finder

charlie belden


Re: Finding centre from inside a big hollow cylinder

#16

Re: Bruce Pratt's Isocoles Triangle Center Finder

GolfSteve in Calgary

Thanks Bruce and Charlie. We've installed a VHS(*) camera and the laser crosshair pointer on a stationary part of the machine. The laser pointer was targeted onto the rotating, but misaligned part. We filmed the path of the rotating parts passing the stationary crosshair, which allowed us to take runout measurements.

(*) yes, an actual VHS tape camera in working condition. We also have a steam engine operating on the train tracks nearby, and donkey carts in the street :-)

:-0