Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Did you know about this?

Posts

Did you know about this?

#1

Did you know about this?

mjonesrdg

Did you know about this?

I�ve come to realize in recent months, that re-hydration of dried and warped wood turnings is not a common practice in our community of turners. Have you ever done this?

The concept is simple: When green wood dries, (de-hydrates) cells collapse, the host work piece shrinks and then, �warps�. The shrinkage, typically being unevenly distributed, often results in oval-shaped bowls, lopsided vases, tipped goblets, etc., and often then, considered to be a �failure� and/or not worth trying to save.

For all of the various methods that have been utilized, taught, and written about regarding the control this natural tendency of wood to warp, little has been offered for methods to save the work from the kindling pile when even our best laid plans and practices present unpredicted and unwanted results. It often takes much longer to redeem a wayward bowl than to simply turn another one.

Now, dry wood, when re-hydrated, will swell those collapsed cells, add lost bulk to shrunken areas, and at least to some degree, return to it�s original, pre-dehydrated size and shape. So, as whacked-out as it may sound, sinking warped work into a tub of water and leaving it immersed for a week or so, can give the turner a whole new set of options.

When a piece has warped beyond the limits of returning it to the lathe, having this re-hydration method will again give the turner the option to chuck it back up�turn it thin, add a rim, band or collar or, (insert here your creative ideas). Additionally, cracks can swell shut with re-hydration and can then be glued instead of stitched, filled, or repaired with biscuits.

If you haven�t done this, and should you be inclined to try this road to �bowl redemption�, know that �results may vary� and that your experience and results shared here could lead to an amassed pool of very helpful information. Re-hydration of the turned piece may evolve into design and technique planning with a world of potential.

What experience have you had with re-hydrating wood?

Mike Jones�in Redding, California

Re: Did you know about this?

#2

Re: Did you know about this?

Fred Holder

Some years ago, Wally Dickerman posted an answer to restoring cracked bowls and I used it effectively on several bowls. The key is to not soak it it water, but soak it in a solution of 50 percent water and 50 percent white glue. I don't remember how long Wally said to soak it, but the most impressive piece that I tried this on was a 15 inch salad bowl that was rough turned and put on the shelf. I was making it for a friend as a house warming gift. I pulled it out to final turn it and found there was a massive crack from the rim to almost the foot. The crack was about 3/8 inch wide at the rim. I let it soak for about two days and pulled it out. The crack had not closed up. I was discussed and threw it outside on a pile of lumber to dry out for burning in the fireplace.

Several days later, I happened to check the bowl and found the crack had completely closed up. I took it back inside to dry out and final turn it. That was several years ago and she is still using that bowl with only a fine hairline mark where the crack was. I said to myself, Wally's idea was good and I've used it several other times since.

I hope this helps someone.

Re: Did you know about this?

#3

Re: Did you know about this?

robo hippy

Hmmm. I like mine to warp as much as possible. Fine Woodworking did an interesting thing about this. They took 3 pieces of kiln dried wood. One was bolted to steel on one side basically free standing. One was bolted in between two pieces of steel and bolted to one side only. One was in between two pieces of steel, and bolted on both sides. They were rehydrated, and allowed to dry again. The first piece expanded, and returned to its original size. The second piece could not expand, but shrunk more as it dried. The third piece split as it dried. This could be why wood hammer handles keep needing to be tightened up after each change from wet to dry season, no matter how many times you tighten it up.

robo hippy

Re: Did you know about this?

#4

Re: Did you know about this?

George Van Beynen

We had a hot water pipe break in the winter years back when we were on vacation. 106,000 gallons later we returned and the hardwood floors had swelled from the steam of hot water against the cold air. When the structure was repaqired the floors had wide spaces between the hardwood strips. The insurance adjuster called it compression set, the strips would remain narrow and the floor had to be replaced.

Re: Did you know about this?

#5

Lyle Jamieson

Why?? long

Lyle Jamieson

The drying process will make wood move in a very predictable direction. Side grain will shrink in on itself and end grain will not shrink. What happens to a tree with the pith left in it?? The wood shrinks inward toward the pith and it will crack because it has no place to go. Using half the tree with the pith removed will cut the shrinking stresses in half.

I turn everything green and take it down to the final wall thickness and cherish the fact that it will have a character all its own in the drying process. Most of my pieces have natural edges and/or voids so the distortion from round is not distracting. I rarely have any of my work crack. The trick is to make them with a uniform wall thickness. Turning it thin will help it dry out faster but if you want a thick wall thickness just slow the drying down and it will not crack. The key is uniformity so the wood dries and moves all at the same rate. If you want to end up with round turnings you must double turn.

Now to your immersion concept. I hate to burst your bubble...but!! Lets think this through for a moment. The wood turned object has shrunk, warped, and possibly cracked. It is smaller then when we turned it green. We are to put it in water and swell the fibers again back to the original size. Yes, that would work...but why go through the trouble?? Now you are right back where you started. What have you gained?? If there were cracks they are still cracks, but just closed up so they are not as noticeable, but there are still cracks. Do you glue the cracks up?? Then what happens when the piece dries out again?? The cracks might or might not open up again. If the original crack glued shut survives the shrinking the second time around a crack will likely form in a different place. The drying stresses are still there, right?? What about inserting a creative element to a re-hydrated piece. Ok, I glue a dried rim on a wet bowl?? What happens when the bowl dries and moves?? The rim, band, or collar does not need drying?? They separate or crack in the stresses. Not a likely success story.

So what is going to be accomplished by re-hydration?? The piece must dry a second time. You will have the same result you did the first time, a shrunken, warped, probably cracked piece. You have two options. If you want it round, double turn. If you want to turn green to finish, live with and love the resulting movement. Here is where grain orientation and wood varieties must be understood. Some woods are more friendly and forgiving in the drying process. Some will drive you crazy. It can be very frustrating to turn with Madrone or red oak where the same piece turned from elm would survive much more abuse. Some woods have larger shrink rates, some woods are more elastic and move without cracking as much as others.

The only way the re-hydration theory will work is if you can fill the wood pores with something that will not dry out, but stays in the microscopic cells so the cells don�t shrink as the water exits. I think Fred's/Wally's glue and water formula might be enough to help the wood fibers stay full of something and reduce the shrink rate enough to make a difference in the finished shape.

Anybody remember PEG?? That's what PolyEtheline Glycol did. Replace the water with a chemical. But the chemical was ugly and plasticized the wood so the finish, in my opinion, was not very attractive.

Re: Did you know about this?

#6

Re: Green vs. Wet wood  ???

Doc Green

I would like for someone to explain, on the cellular level, the difference between green wood and wood that has been dried and then soaked.

Specifically, when you soak a piece of dried wood, do the cells get filled again with what sometimes is referred to as "bound water," and if they do get filled, is the water "bound" again? I know (I think) that a piece of wet wood will dry a lot quicker than a piece of green wood.

Can anyone speak with some authority on this? Haven't been able to sleep for two days worrying about it.

~Doc

Re: Did you know about this?

#7

Re: Green vs. Wet wood  ???

Jorge Castaneda

Doc,

I am not an authority, but I think the bound water is bound irregardless, what comes and goes is the "free water"

I had two different pieces, one a walnut bowl that developed a crack 2'' deep from the rim and open about 1/4" at the widest, the other a natural edge in cherry.

Both were left alone and one day looking for a blank to work, noticed the walnut bowl had closed the crack, it took me a long time to locate it and applied some glue, finished turning it and the repair was invisible, the bowl was sold locally, just in case, and have not heard anything. (4 years).

The natural edge in cherry is still around, a 1/2" gap is now 1/16" and got the feeling it will never close completely so is a candidate to stitches with silver wire.

Re: Did you know about this?

#8

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Green vs. Wet wood  ???

Lyle Jamieson

Im no scientist, Im just repeating what I've learned from others in the turning world. John Jordon has talked about the importance of understanding this for decades. You are right to separate bound and unbound water. Bound water is in the cell structure and the last to release moisture in the drying process. Unbound water is the "maple syrup" that flows from roots to the leaves and feeds the tree. Unbound water is what makes the wet line on your ceiling when you turn freshly cut green wood. In the drying process they both will dry (or rehydrate), the difference is a matter of time involved. Bound water moves slow and unbound water moves fast.

With that understood, the shrinking and warping occurs mostly with the loss of bound water. The free, unbound water loss will not cause much, if any movement of the wood.

Here is where uniform wall thickness comes into play. The bound water in the thick bottom of a bowl will take longer to dry out then the bound water in the thin rim of the bowl. This imbalance/diseqilibrium causes the stress that will result in cracking. The vessel will arm-wrestle itself until it cracks. When a vessel has a uniform wall thickness the bound water will dry out evenly with less stress. It will still shrink and warp, just not as likely to crack.

Re: Did you know about this?

#9

Re: Green vs. Wet wood  ???

John Jordan

Lyle has made it pretty plain, and simple. There's really not much more to it from just a turner's perspective. Years ago I re-hydrated some kind of volatile wood, seems like maybe black gum burl or something, anyway it really wrinkled and moved. I dropped it into a bucket for some period of time, can't really remember how much, but it was perfectly round again. I don't remember why I did it, and I can't see much use in doing it now, but there may well be some creative uses I'm too dense to see right now. But its not going to heal anything, and I don't know how it might work with various woods.

If you do it, do it in a logical step by step method so the results are fairly certain and predictable. I would be mildly curious about it. :)

John