Green End Grain Hollow Form
Stuart Johnson
When turning an end grain hollow form from green wood is it usually dried and then re-turned like a bowl? Granted I should have asked my question before turning down to 1/4" walls.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Green End Grain Hollow Form
Stuart Johnson
When turning an end grain hollow form from green wood is it usually dried and then re-turned like a bowl? Granted I should have asked my question before turning down to 1/4" walls.
I would say no
steven antonucci
I hollow them, sand to 220, and then bag them for a week or two.
Finish sanding when they are dry. By hand. (I have a pile of that kind of work waiting for me...)
S
Re: I would say Yes
Joe Meirhaeghe
About all I turn is end grain vessels, anywhere from 3" to 30" tall. I always do a rough turning on green wood vessels to a thickness of between 3/8" to a 1/2" thick regardless of height. Air dry them then return them to around 3/16" thick depending on the piece, sometimes I'll go thinner.
Re: I always turn Green to finish thickness
Lyle Jamieson
Let it dry on the faceplate just long enough to sand. Remove from faceplate and reverse turn the bottom off with friction drive and tailstock. At this point you can leave a small tenon in the bottom to let the entire piece dry for a while and put it back on the lathe to sand the bottom. It might wobble a bit, so you need to slow the lathe speed down to sand. The out of roundness will not affect the shape much unless you leave the pith in. I never leave the pith in.
I Do Both, But You're Committed Now
Brad Vietje
Stuart,
Both ways are entirely reasonable, depending on the desired result -- round or slightly oval. For once-turned pieces, the final shape depends heavily on the species and the orientation in the log. If you have a piece with one side close to the pith, and the opposite side close to the bark, you can end up with a tighter curve toward the pith, and a markedly odd-shaped piece. Some species with greater shrinkage, like Apple, Lilac, or Beech will really go out of round.
However, at this point you're committed to finishing it like it is. If you wanted to re-mount it and round it up later, you'd have to leave it a little thicker -- like 3/8 to 7/16 -- depending on the above factors.
You can turn 'em right on the pith to get a nearly perfect round shape, but you will need to get them quite thin, and you will lose some. It's basically breaking all the usual rules, but with some species and great care, it can work, especially if you drill out the pith, and plug it later. With Walnut, Ash and other "big pith" species, I've had good results without drilling, just by turning the whole vessel -- especially the base --rather thin, and reinforcing with thin CA around the pith.
For now, sand it and finish it as desired, and try a twice-turned HF the next time 
Safe spinning,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT
Re: Green End Grain Hollow Form
Stuart Johnson
I pretty well figured I needed to go ahead and turn this one to finished size. I want to add a collar and possibly a finial but got to worrying about warping unless it was re-turned. In this case leaving a small tenon and truing up the opening might be the best.
Re: Green End Grain Hollow Form
Dick Wilson
Stuart, I normally turn end grain hollow forms green. I hollow out to final wall thickness - usually 1/4". At that wall thickness after hollowing centrifugal force get rid of most of the moisture. Sanding heats up the wood and turns a lot of the remaining moisture to steam. I will start the finish process right away. Will it stay perfectly round......no. I have had very few pieces check on me and when I do it is because I wasn't very careful in making sure I had a uniform wall thickness.
Generally
George Guadiane
I turn to finish, BUT, a couple of larger things have been too much (for me) to finish in a day so I have gone back and returned those, inside and out with great success.