Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Skew sharpening

Posts

Skew sharpening

#1

Skew sharpening

Martin from Texas

Long time lurker, rare poster.

Once upon a time I took a weekend skew class from Alan Lacer. I got away from turning for a few years, and I am trying to find the time to ease my way back into it.

I recall Alan preferred a slight curve to his skews. I can't remember why.

It seems to me that the curve "might" help prevent catches, but I am guessing.

I do know that it is harder to sharpen the curve. I think a straight skew might be easier to sharpen, especially if one were to follow the grinder with water stones.

I would appreciate your comments regarding:

1) Why the curve? What does it do for you as you turn?

2) Is straight ok as well? Is it just personal preference?

I am planning to re-learn the skew, so I can make a shaker chair or two.

Any advice would be appreciated.

Thanks,

Martin

Re: Skew sharpening

#2

Re: Skew sharpening

Doc Green

Martin, if you use a skew for a planing cut on a piece that is 5 or 6" inches in diameter, the curve will cause the heel and the toe to be farther from the wood while you are cutting with the lower middle of the cutting edge. This makes it a lot more forgiving.

If you place a straight skew against a large diameter piece, you will see that the heel and toe are very close to the wood. A slight bobble is all it takes in this case to have either the heel or toe dig in, ...and away you go.

For spindles 3" or smaller diameter, it doesn't make a lot of difference if the skew you are using is an inch or larger in width.

One example where a skew might be used on such a large piece is if you are trying to get a clean cut on a vase or hollow form where the wood is spalted, degraded, or just plain gnarly.

If you don't anticipate using the skew on large-diameter pieces, you can go with a straight edge and have the advantage of easier sharpening.

Good Luck, ~Doc

Re: Skew sharpening

#3

Re: Skew sharpening

John Lucas

I'm not a curved skew fan. Like you I find the straight skew easier to sharpen and don't really see the advantage of the curved edge. Personally I think the idea that it catches less is myth. I have turned 6" diameter spindles using my 1 1/4" skew. Maybe the toe is closer to the wood but you shouldn't be cutting beyond the halfway point on the blade or any skew will try to rock itself into the wood. It's a leverage thing at that point. If your getting catches due to the long point then you are doing something wrong.

I do have a really big skew. I think it's about 3" wide. I bought it for large turnings thinking it would be less likely to catch. Don't know why I did that because I don't get catches with the small one. Anyway, it is very hard to control because it takes such a huge bite. consequently it wants to self feed and sort of forces the cut to migrate toward the catchy tip.

Nick Cook and Alan Lacer wrote an article in American Woodturner a few years back and they both argued the advantages of straight vs curves skews. Both are expert professional turners I believe the conclusion was a draw. So I'm not trying to dispute what Doc (another expert turner) is saying. I'm just saying that we see things differently in the way we use a skew.

I do see one advantage of a curve skew, at least sort of. When you use it sideways to make a parting sort of cut the curved edge skew leads with the center of the curved edge. This makes it rock less during the cut. But that assumes that you hold the skew at a slight angle so it does lead with the curve.

Re: Skew sharpening

#4

It depends on what you're used to

David Walser

Martin,

The straight v. curved skew debate has raged for as long as I can remember (which goes all the way back to 2003, when I started to turn). There are good arguments on both sides of the question, but, in the end, it comes down to personal preference. The skew I learned with had a straight edge. While I've used a curved skew and gave it a serious try, I've gone back to a straight edge. I just feel more comfortable with it in my hand -- because it's what I learned with and what I'm used to using. It's also slightly easier to sharpen.

So, my advice: If you're comfortable with a curved skew, go with that. If not, go with a straight edge.

Good luck with your chairs.

Re: Skew sharpening

#5

Thanks everyone!

Martin from Texas