Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

I'm fuming! (ammonia fuming that is)

Posts

I'm fuming! (ammonia fuming that is)

#1

Steve Kubien

I'm fuming!  (ammonia fuming that is)

Steve Kubien

I have finally got off my butt and I'm trying to fume a few pieces.

I bought grocery-store ammonia and I don't know the strength of it (jug doesn't say). Right now I have a honey locust bowl and it's been in the fumes for about 12 hours. There's been almost no change in the wood. How long ought I leave the piece?

I know not all species will take to fuming but I seem to recall others have used locust (though it may have been black locust). I'm am looking for general guidelines here.

Thanks!

Steve

Re: I'm fuming! (ammonia fuming that is)

#2

JL

Re: I'm fuming!  (ammonia fuming that is)

JL

The more fumes the better. I prefer "blueprint ammonia" - which is stronger. Household runs about 8-10% - blueprint ammonia runs about 24%.

Anyway - roughly 4-6 hours for good development with blueprint ammonia and white oak. About four times as long for household ammonia and white oak.

I don't know about honey locust - as I've never tried it.

Re: I'm fuming! (ammonia fuming that is)

#3

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: I'm fuming!  (ammonia fuming that is)

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Steve, I posted here a few months ago the results of a fuming experiment with several species of wood. The samples were fumed three days with household ammonia. In all cases, the fuming darkened the wood appreciably and in most cases attractively (depending on your taste). You may be able to find that post with a search.

Dennis

Re: I'm fuming! (ammonia fuming that is)

#4

Rob Wallace

Re: I'm fuming!  (ammonia fuming that is)

Rob Wallace

Steve:

Throw a piece of cherry in the ammonia fumes with your locust piece - keep another chunk of cherry (cut from the same board) away from the ammonia fumes to serve as a control/color change test. Cherry will darken upon fuming, but the rate of color change will depend on "strength" (concentration) of the ammonia vapor, temperature, and individual wood species/pieces.

I have used household strength ammonia to darken some sycamore to accentuate the ray fleck and on cherry a number of times. It can take at least a day or two, sometimes longer. Switching to lab-grade concentrated ammonium hydroxide (very nasty stuff!), I was able to do the fuming overnight or in one day on some occasions. The lower concentration stuff will take longer. Be very careful of working with ammonia (especially high concentration stuff) is a WELL ventilated place - getting a good belt of ammonia fumes down the lungs can be a very dangerous thing.

Also - you may want to try to buy the unscented ammonia - one of my bowls smelled of lilac or some other such fragrance for MONTHS after the fuming. To me this is a detracting feature, but who knows if people would buy bowls/vessels more readily if they were scented???

Good luck,

Rob

Re: I'm fuming! (ammonia fuming that is)

#5

Re: I'm fuming!  (ammonia fuming that is)

john lucas

Steve I can understand fuming Oak and cherry and the like but Honey Locust is so beautiful I'm not sure why you would want to do that. Not chastising you, it's your wood and you can burn it, paint it, or cover it with mud if you want. I'm just wondering your logic on this wood.

Re: I'm fuming! (ammonia fuming that is)

#6

Steve Kubien

Thanks folks

Steve Kubien

Since I am using household ammonia, I am obviously expecting too much too fast. I'm not going to switch to the stinger stuff because, really, why would I want another chemical lying around? Nope, time is one my side so I will be patient.

Dennis, I will look for your post. Cheers.

Steve

Re: I'm fuming! (ammonia fuming that is)

#7

Steve Kubien

Re: I'm fuming!  (ammonia fuming that is)

Steve Kubien

No sweat John. Truly, I'm not sure why this piece, while turning it, was screaming to be fumed. OMG! The wood "spoke" to me! I must be an artiste now...or inhaling too many fumes. :)

As I said above, I saw someone had fumed black locust and I LOVED the effect. I am hoping for great contrast between the heart and sapwood (there's a fair bit of heartwood in this piece).

We'll see if it's a winner or not. I am thinking of Tung oil or Watco when it's done.

Do I need to let the piece de-gas before finishing? How long? Until it no longer smells of ammonia, plus a couple of days for good measure?

Re: I'm fuming! (ammonia fuming that is)

#8

Woods with low tannic acid *LINK*

Craig Daymon

If you want to try fuming and feel that a low tannic acid wood is what you want to fume, you can find tannic acid, I believe in a dry, powdered form, in the grocery store in with the canning products. Mix some up with distilled water and paint it on the piece before fuming.

I've fumed white oak, red oak and American chestnut with great success using household ammonia. (Same stuff you bought at the grocery store.) Yes, it will take longer than blueprint ammonia, but it is SO VERY MUCH safer. I firmly believe one very important factor is using an air tight container. I have a large, 40 gallon Igloo cooler that works great for most turned pieces.

As an example of what can be achieve with household ammonia and the proper container, I remember watching David Marks build a piece of Mission furniture out of white oak and fume it with blueprint ammonia in a framed box he tented with plastic sheeting. After, I think, 8 hours of fuming (done outside), his results were far less impressive than a white oak candlestick I fumed for about 12 hours. I believe this is because of the difference in the air tightness of our fuming containers as 8 hours is a LONG time to expose a piece using blueprint ammonia.

The candlestick is in the Shop Shots, number 348. I've posted a direct link below. Keep in mind, as stated in the description, that there was actually a much greater difference in person between the unfumed piece and the candlestick than what is shown in the picture.

If you can get results like that with household ammonia, why take the risk of using blueprint ammonia, which is very dangerous.


Fumed white oak candlestick, Shop Shot 348

Re: I'm fuming! (ammonia fuming that is)

#9

Cool- looking forward to seeing it.

John Lucas

Can you do a before and after photo of the fuming. I had never thought that the fuming might only affect some colors in the wood. I've only fumed oak and of course it affects the whole piece of wood.

Re: I'm fuming! (ammonia fuming that is)

#10

Steve Kubien

Re: Cool- looking forward to seeing it.

Steve Kubien

Sorry John, no before pics. That would have required forethought and planning.

Re: I'm fuming! (ammonia fuming that is)

#11

Steve Kubien

Re: Woods with low tannic acid

Steve Kubien

Thanks Craig. After I looked at the piece this morning, I topped up the ammonia ( for no good reason) and sealed it back up. It's not air-tight but I wouldn't to be trapped inside. It will have been in the fumes for 36 hours by the time I take a peek tomorrow.

Re: I'm fuming! (ammonia fuming that is)

#12

Re: Woods with low tannic acid

Craig Daymon

It's not going to look like you want coming out of the box. My experience is that the pieces come out looking sort of dull gray. Let it air out several days to off-gas the ammonia and then apply some finish. That's when you'll see the real color.

Re: I'm fuming! (ammonia fuming that is)

#13

Re: Cool- looking forward to seeing it.

Stephen Mushinski

What the heck do you have that fancy phone is you do not take photo's with it? :)

Re: I'm fuming! (ammonia fuming that is)

#14

Steve Kubien

Re: Cool- looking forward to seeing it.

Steve Kubien

Aren't you supposed to be roughing it at the cottage? Go fix your boat or swat flies or something...

Re: I'm fuming! (ammonia fuming that is)

#15

Steve Kubien

Re: Woods with low tannic acid

Steve Kubien

That's really good to hear because I took it out today and to say I am not happy with the results would be a gross understatement. It has something of a green-grey hue to it right now.

Well, I have some elm that's finished that ought to come out better, based on Richard Kennedy's experiments. Of course, we Canadians probably don't grow elm like the Brits. We shall see...