Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Skew chisel observation/textbook

Posts

Skew chisel observation/textbook

#1

Keith Tompkins

Skew chisel observation/textbook

Keith Tompkins

I recently found an old woodworking textbook at work dated 1946, which was previously used to teach woodworking to prison inmates. There is a large chapter on woodturning, including a section on proficiency tests with the gouge and skew chisel. One interesting piece of information I noticed, which contradicts current wisdom...The text instructs that v-gooves are cut with a heel-down/toe-up position, not the toe-down position. Also, it advocates a straight-in approach, not an arcing cut as recommended by Richard Raffan and others.

Frankly, I have a hard time understanding the reason for arcing the long point into the wood, since the tool already has a skewed approach to the wood, which is spinning right into the cutting edge. I currently cut v-grooves with the long point down, riding either bevel (depending on which side I'm cutting)pushing the tool straight in. I find the cut is cleaner than when I raise the handle and cut with the long point, no matter how many times I attempt either cut.

I am going to work on the heel-down cut as well, just to compare...after all, beads are cut that way. I'd be interested to hear any comments. I may post the bead-cutting proficiency test...it's a good one.

Re: Skew chisel observation/textbook

#2

Re: Skew chisel observation/textbook

john lucas

Keith I do cut beads short point down but if I get nervous or want a really tight line between the two beads I use the toe down.

I have tried arcing the tool down on V cuts as well as arcing up, both with the long point down. What I find useful in either technique is exactly how the blade is oriented during the cut, not whether it's arced or not.

For example when I push straight in with the handle level the blade is cutting about 50 to 70 degrees to the spinning wood. If I hold the handle higher the blade is cutting about 80 or more degrees which leaves a much cleaner cut, especially in problem woods. I use that same approach when cutting beads. If the edges aren't coming out really clean I lift the handle with the toe down for a cleaner cut.

Re: Skew chisel observation/textbook

#3

Re: Skew chisel observation/textbook

Fred Holder

Keith,

I cut V-grooves with the long point down first push straight in to form a small v-cut. I then rotate the tool 2 or 3 degrees one way and make an arcing cut into the bottom of the first cut. I repeat this for the other side.

To make a bead between two V-Cuts, I first cut from the center to the left by holding the skew level and the heal of the cutting edge just to left of center. I make sure the tool is perpendicular to the wood and then rotate the tool to the left. The skew will run down into the left hand V-groove and with luck will cut half of the bead at one pass. I then turn the tool over and repeat the process on the right side. With luck, one can cut a bead between two v-grooves with just two cuts.

Re: Skew chisel observation/textbook

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: Skew chisel observation/textbook

Keith Tompkins

HI Fred, Yes, that is the correct "textbook" method. But, WHY the arcing cut? Do you think it produces a cleaner finish? I seem to feel rubbing the entire bevel down the "v" straight in cuts cleaner. I'd like you, and some others to try it and let me know the results.

Re: Skew chisel observation/textbook

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: Skew chisel observation/textbook

Keith Tompkins

HI John, Thanks. I find if I arc the tool into the cut using the long point, it leaves a jagged, rough edge. If I ride a section of the grind flat against the side of the "v", I get a clean cut. Perhaps the curved skew would work better....there's more of the cutting edge exposed.

Re: Skew chisel observation/textbook

#6

Re: Skew chisel observation/textbook

Carol Reed, Strawberry, AZ

Boy, if there was ever a thread that could benefit from a comparative video clip, this one is it!

Re: Skew chisel observation/textbook

#7

Re: Skew chisel observation/textbook

Michael Mocho

Personally, I believe that the arcing cut (raising the handle so the point drops downward into the cut) produces a significantly better cut than jabbing the skew into the wood. It slices like a knife, instead of only scratching like a needle. As long as the clearance angle on the bevel contacting side is kept to a minimum, and the skew is kept vertical, it cut with very little resistance- depending on the thickness of the shaving being released.

Using the one-finger-under-the toolrest grip seems to help- the thumb stays on the tool rest as a stop, and the three fingers work in opposition to the thumb to capture and control the tool. Lifting the handle allows the slicing cut to be powered by the lathe instead of forced by plunging the tool.

Re: Skew chisel observation/textbook

#8

Re: Skew chisel observation/textbook

John Lucas

Keith I will play this weekend while trying out the new Delta Midi. I was thinking about the arcing cut. I'll bet it got started because it's kind of like cutting a bead. As you cut downhill on the bead the spindle is getting smaller so you have to lift the handle. I do this when cutting the flying saucer shape on ornament spindles. For whatever reason I start the cut (toe down) well above center. Then I kind of ark down toward the stopping point. It's kind of the same movement I do when cutting a bead I just change the shape and use the toe instead of the heel.

Re: Skew chisel observation/textbook

#9

Mocho Method works well for Me

jake Niedling

I spent a day with Michael in Crossville, Tn workshop about 2 months ago. I am an experienced turner, but would not say the skew was one of my go to tools. After doing it how Michael suggests above made using the skew much more comfortable and produced some outstanding clean cuts on end grain. The method he uses to hold the skew was strange to me at the beginning of the day. But the control it gives you, shows pretty quickly in the results of the cut. No fear of a catch and nowing you will get a silkly smooth finish. With some pracitices during the day, I am now very comfortable using it. I was using my old Craftsman 1" skew with no curved edge.

Re: Skew chisel observation/textbook

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: Skew chisel observation/textbook

Keith Tompkins

AHA! I think you are on to something, John. I cut using a very low toolrest, so there is no need to raise the handle...I can cut straight in.

Re: Skew chisel observation/textbook

#11

Ken Vaughan

Amen Carol

Ken Vaughan

Re: Skew chisel observation/textbook

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: Skew chisel observation/textbook

Keith Tompkins

HI Michael, It was good to meet you in St. Paul. I wish we had more time for you to show me your technique.Our conversation got me thinking about the contents of this post. If I'm correct, you hold the skew vertical, so only the part where the grind meets the long point rests against the "v" being cut..similar to when cutting 90 degrees across end grain. I assume rolling the tool toward the side of the "v" being cut will create a deeper cut. Your tool rest must be positioned a bit higher than mine in order to arc the tool downward. I just cut straight in, with the tool canted inward; bevel rubbing, but the tip isn't touching the wood at all.

Re: Skew chisel observation/textbook

#13

Re: Skew chisel observation/textbook

Michael Mocho

Hi Keith,

Great to meet you as well, and I hope I didn't bombard you with opinion about your new tool- I think it is quite interesting.

I think the slicing action is the common ground in using the skew, regardless of grip. I do believe that keeping the handle butt moving upward as the skew drops into the cut seems to reduce the resistance of the cutting action, and I don�t need to roll the cut of tilt the skew off vertical unless I am cutting something other than a straight line. The key to an exceptionally clean cut on end grain is to take a shin shaving and let the lathe do the work, rather than trying to �crunch� through a thick shaving that will also put undo pressure on the bevel and compress the wood as the edge of the hollow grind touches the wood.

The cut is always tangent to the bevel, and one doesn�t need to put a lot of pressure on it- a thin shaving provides enough force to capture the sharp edge of the skew and hold it against the bevel. Once the cut is started properly, it can be done with just one hand steering and raising the handle.

I would be glad to post a short video clip of the cut, but I don�t really know how to upload it- I have only posted photos. Anyone want to offer suggestions? What format does the video have to be, and do I need to find a particular viewer too?

Re: Skew chisel observation/textbook

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: Skew chisel observation/textbook

Keith Tompkins

HI Michael...Opinions? I hadn't noticed :D (You may have noticed I'm not opinionated at all!) If you have a copy of Best of Fine Woodworking" Woodturning Basics, there is an article by Richard Raffan on cutting "V"s. He uses an arcing cut, but the cuts are ragged. I'll work on your method....something to add to my arsenal.

Re: Skew chisel observation/textbook

#15

Steven Antonucci

Video help

steven antonucci

Shoot your video.

Upload it to Youtube

Click on the link that gives you the embed code.

Cut and past that code into this window.

It will embed the video inside WC.

Steve