This is just a very short note; there is a lot more info out there to be Googled.
The fact is that "thousand cancer" disease has been found on walnuts south of Richmond. Previously, this was only found on the West Coast, but last year it got into Tennessee and ravaged forests there. Now it's on the move again. A long, informative article from last year in Tennessee is at:
We don't have many walnuts here, but it seems all the great timber we love is under threat of some sort. Chestnut was wiped out long ago, Ash is under attack, Butternuts are dying off. Globalization is taking a heavy toll on our environment. I've spent a lot of time in our woods fighting against invasive species that have been introduced and threaten our ecosystems.
Yeah, I have my "Weed Warrior" card too, plus I'm also volunteering as an Urban Tree Steward to help the County keep track of what's going on on their Park land -- because they're too understaffed to do it by themselves.
Every day it seems like another tree species is endangered by some kind of bug or disease -- it's definitely looking grim. ...Gary
We see many invasive plants and animals coming in either on purpose for a number of reasons or as hitch hikers. Does this also go the other way. Not the disease so much but the deliberate plants and animals. Are other countries fighting "weeds" from America or Canada that are a threat to them?
Need to separate 'disease' from 'invasive species'
Rob Wallace
Gary, et al.:
The process of the spreading of disease organisms such as the reported 'thousand cankers' (not cancer) disease is quite different biologically from the concept of 'invasive species'.
For a "new" disease to spread into populations previously unaffected by it, there has to be a susceptible host organism already established in the environment that is biologically compatible with the disease or parasite. The "new" host species is often evolutionarily-related to the disease's host species in which the disease developed, but in a different part of the world. This is what has happened with Dutch Elm disease, the chestnut blight, and thousand cankers, to name a few. The "new" host species being effected in the 'new' geographic region likely had not previously evolved with the pathogen/parasite, and thus has no (or limited) defense against it, thereby making it very susceptible to the disease with catastrophic consequences for the new host species' population.
The concepts around invasive species are actually quite different - with the sole exception of the similarity of some organism "getting somewhere new". The negative impact an invasive species has on native populations is primarily through out-competing them for available resources, and eventually being so reproductively successful as to displace the native species from their part of the ecological spectrum in that environment. Most invasive species have a very wide range of tolerance to various ecological conditions, can establish quickly, have high growth rates, and are highly fecund (i.e. reproduce well with large numbers of offspring, regardless of growing situation). Invasive species do not require a pre-existing host organism to establish themselves in the new environment. They just get there, "establish a beachhead", grow (quickly), and reproduce very well. The result is that those native organisms are "beaten" by the "successfulness" of the invader, and eventually the natives are unable to maintain themselves in their environment since they were "pushed out of existence" by the invader (displacement) because they could not compete.
While both processes (disease spread and invasion of alien species) produce a very significant negative impact on native populations the invade, which often happens rather quickly, the fundamental processes are quite different and distinct biologically, and should not be thought of as being similar. They operate under quite different "rules" and biological interactions, usually with devastating consequences to natural populations.
That humans often cause or mediate the spread of disease or invasive species is all the more frustrating and maddening to those of us who study such processes and attempt to reduce the impact on the environment caused by ignorance, neglect, or deliberate actions involving these organisms. Biological interactions between the organisms don't stop because a new disease or invasion becomes messy or inconvenient to us, and ignoring the situation or looking the other direction will not help to fix the problem. At least with Emerald Ash Borer some important steps are being taken, but it may be too little, too late.
End of today's Biology class. (Don't forget to study for the exam..... )
Rob, I fully understand the differences between the diseases and pests (thousand cankers, emerald ash borer) threatening some timbers and the threats that invasives pose. I had a short time to respond and just grouped a bunch of things that threaten our wooded ecosystems which I believe are largely due to the shrinking of the earth (OK, not really shrinking earth, rather cheaper more efficient transportation of humans and goods). It seems that there are more and more pressures on the woods around me, and I just wonder if we even have an inkling how much human activity has negatively impacted our natural world. In the long run, it really doesn't matter much since mother nature will come up with other ecosystems (in the form of natural selection/evolution), but it can be pretty hard to take for us who love the woods and the lumber/turning stock it provides
No 'rebukage' (?) needed or meant by my reply - given the direction the thread was heading, I just wanted to make sure folks knew that disease spread and invasive species operate very differently, and under different scenarios of species movement and establishment.
I also neglected to comment that there are also reciprocal movements of invasive (and disease) species, where "american" species move to other parts of the world and become problems there. A classic, textbook (literally) example is the spread of prickly pear cactus from North or South America to Australia and South Africa, which have become noxious pests in these arid regions capable of supporting them. Prickly pear cacti (Opuntia) are native only to N. & S. America, and were introduced into these other areas as potential cattle feed. Epic FAIL.
An example of human-mediated invasive species movement is the noxious marine green alga Caulerpa taxifolia. It is native to the Indian Ocean region, but was taken "into captivity" and grown in marine aquaria for a long time, notably at an aquarium in Monaco. Accidental (?) "escape" of living algae of this species into the Mediterranean Sea in the 1980s from the aquarium in Monaco provided the start of a massive colonization of the entire Mediterranean Sea after a few decades. Long distance dispersal of these organisms (presumably in the ballast of ocean-going ships) from the Mediterranean to other suitable warm water places (e.g. southern California coast, Caribbean) has established Caulerpa taxifolia as a (the?) major invasive species of algae in warm-water coastal marine ecosystems throughout the World. Control methods are only partially effective and are very costly. This situation has been caused COMPLETELY by human activity. Read more about Caulerpa at the link below.
It is clear that any form of movement of non-native organisms to new areas has the potential to create massive ecological (and potentially economic) disasters. Our ability to move effortlessly around the world needs to be considered carefully as a possible cause for such disasters.
Re: Need to separate 'disease' from 'invasive spec *LINK*
Bob Macgregor
Maybe I didn't read carefully enough, but I don't remember seeing mention of country (continent) of origin for thousand cankers disease, though resistance of English walnut is suggetive of a European origin.
At the risk of pulling the discussion even farther astray, I wanted to climb on a favourite soapbox of mine. Undoubtedly, the introduction of exotic species into new (to them) habitats can wreak serious ecological damage. However, most people overlook the very most serious, worldwide, human-mediated habitat destruction, namely farming. Humans have claimed a tremendous, and increasing proportion of the world's biotic production potential resulting in decimation of fish stocks and widescale destruction of "wild" terrestrial habitats. I've put in a link to a paper that attributes 7.7B ha worth of biomass capture for food, feed, fuel and materials. If my calculations are correct, this represents over half of the world's land area stolen (or maybe that's "borrowed" from nature).
Humans mediate the spread of domesticated exotic species like wheat, soybeans, maize, rice, tomatoes, potatoes, cotton, cattle, sheep, etc., etc. from regions of origin to huge landscapes continents removed from the original homeland. Most of these domesticated species owe their continued existance to humans, since the act of domestication has rendered them uncompetitive (or reproductively incompetent) in an uncultivated landscape.
I'm not suggesting that we should, or are likely to, change this status quo, but I wanted to put the scope of habitat alteration due to exotic species into a broader context of human-mediated habitat changes.
I always have an eye out for good potential trees to harvest. Last time I was down at frogwarts, our cabin, I spotted an old walnut which is along a country back-road where a home place once was. I have ask around, and found the property owner, so I know who to contact about harvesting it.
However, it looks like it could be dying from this. All of the outer branches are already dead, yet there is some vigorous growth down lower near the trunk. Now, instead of just thinking of cutting it, I need to take a ladder down, and climb up for a closer inspection. Bummer,,,,,,, I hope it is something else.
Thanks for the reminder. I think I probably started the last thread on this subject about a year ago, yet I might not have noticed the symptoms if I had not seen this reminder.
I just finished reading a good enlightening book "Bringing Nature Home" by Douglas W. Tallamy. Subtitled; How you can Sustain Wildlife with Native Plants.
Through the years nursery people have been offering non-native species, with a selling point, that they can be insect-free without the aide of chemicals. This is due to the fact that most plants have a way of producing chemicals which are toxic to all but a few insects which manage to find ways to neutralize those toxins. Unfortunately, if there are no insects eating any of your plants, there will be nothing for birds to feed their young, and to add enough fat to sustain them through the arduous task of migration.
There seem to be a fair number of people on this site, that are sensitive to the environment, that would enjoy, and probably learn from this book.
If you suspect the tree has the disease and you do take it down, I am certain the local extension office would be interested in confirming the presence or absence of beetles (& their galleries) and any active phloem cankers within this tree. If you're taking-down the tree, staff from the extension office might want to be there to sample different parts of the tree to confirm (or not) the presence of the disease in your region.
It is great that people can be aware of this situation, and can help in noting possible infections and spreading awareness about the disease, but hopefully not the disease itself!
To take it down. This tree measures 40" DBH, with the first branch only about six feet up, but it is 30" D, so I am expecting a lot of highly figured wood under where it turns out.
While trying to find the owner, I contacted an old friend from nearby, who offered me a couple of other walnut trees on one of his farms. One of those was 33" DBH. Which I will take later.
Then just down the road, I found a dying cherry on another friend's place, ~28" DBH. Did I forget to mention that I had a great weekend. Gloat.
Re: Thanks, I did an inspection, and got permissio
charlie belden
Got a metal detector? Trees near a house or road often have surpises at 4 to 8 feet off the ground. You CAN find the surprise(s) with your chainsaw or saw blade - but a metal detector works better.
A sawyer friend's Lucas Mill blade found 1" diameter rod - with nuts and washers on the ends - in a crotch piece - 4-6" under where the bark was now. Apparently you don't want to be that close when the carbide teeth start flyng off the blade.