From time to time, I get into a spot where I need to solve a problem... and I just can't.
I am working on a project that requires attaching one part to another. I would probably peg it with some rods, but that would require some very accurate drilling in small pieces, and I know that I can't pull that feat off.
I also have debated mortising one part into another, but I expect that it will look sloppy. The mortise would be on a complex curve on both parts, and I am just not that precise. (it's why I turn- in most cases 1/16" here or there doesn't look that bad!)
I could glue A to B, and that would work for a while, but I am sure that it would eventually fail. I have enough to do without repairing things that I did poorly...
So, if you were trying to attach a wooden fin on a wooden rocket, what would you do?
Drilling a single dowel hole would be fairly simple. If you want to do 2 then it gets more complicated. Having a V type sled on the drill press would help, and maybe a metal template that could be taped to the rocket for hole spacing, which could also be placed on the fins might work. Also, you might be able, again with a sled, cut a mortice with the table saw in the rocket, then kerf the fin the same way, and make a blade width biscuit to fit into both.
I think you had the answer all the time, mortise and tenon, a little finese with a file ( and maybe some wood filler) and it should look alright while being strong.
Use a trim/molding strip in the corner (on both sides) of the fin and body of the rocket. Depending on the size, you can glue the molding in place or pin/nail/screw in place to both fin and body. The molding could be half round, triangle, or square depending in the need for aerodynamics or strength. Just ask a carpenter how important trim molding is.
I have no idea what you are trying to do but here is what I used to do when wanting to glue two pieces together with pins/dowels to reinforce.
I carefully drilled at least two holes in the smaller piece, i.e. the piece to be glued to the larger and most in need of reinforcement. These two holes were sized to accommodate a brad or finishing nail that would be of the size to not exceed 1/2 the thickness of the material into which the holes were to be drilled.
Then using the same size brad or nail I created sharp dowel points that I could insert in the drilled holes in the smaller piece and mark the location of the holes on the larger piece.
Assuming you have more than one piece to glue on you should save your dowel points for the remaining pieces.
Drill those holes and then cut more brad/nail dowels of the appropriate length and glue them into their respective holes with some quick setting epoxy. You have to be careful to avoid squeeze out. If you use quick epoxy you can hold the pieces together until they glue cures enough to hold it all together.
Depending on the dowel material you choose to use I recommend roughing it up with coarse sandpaper to get more bite with the glue.
I tried to use 1/16" and 1/8" dowel materials because I typically used brads of that size or brass rods. Depending on the wood you have to be careful if you use steel as it can result in stains with age.
When my son and I were in the rocket building business we did this exact procedure but further reinforced the fins with a fillet of glue on each side.
Here is a box turned from face grain material that I was asked to to turn from some angelique. I used that same reinforcement technique from the inside to reinforce the long finial handle on the lid. The brass pin I used for the reinforcement was concealed by a whittled dowel of the same material.
Whenever I need to drill accurately mated holes in a situation like this, I make a drilling jig out of scraps of plywood or, in this case, probably a piece of hardwood. First drill two holes of the pin diameter in your scrap of wood -- make sure the holes are perfectly perpendicular to the scrap -- then figure how to index one side of the jig to one of your parts (the fin?) and the other side to the other part (the rocket). Use a hand-held drill to drill the holes in both parts, and, ouila!, they will line up perfectly when you assemble the joint.
I think I understand your problem with the curved shoulders. You can simply undercut the fin piece with a sharp bench chisel, or, if you want a mechanical solution, consider milling a shallow groove in the rocket with a router. You can do this while the piece is on the lathe by building a box that centers on the ways of your lathe and includes a platform above the rocket body with a groove centered on the rocket body. Use a router template bushing and a plunge router, with a bit the same width as the fin to rout the flat-bottomed groove. This way, you can leave the fin flat on its bottom and it will fit perfectly into the groove. Use the same drilling template to drill the holes in both pieces.
Most of the issue is that I started down the path with making parts, and very little concern for how they would be assembled... If I was to start over, I would be able to do this with no particular struggle.
However, I am male, and I am lost. I also plan on holding on to these parts tightly and making them all go together if it kills me. Figuring it out means I wasn't wrong
The rocket section is hollow, and I have other plans for it... I might have 1/4" for a pin. The rocket fins are 3/16". I have to be able to accurately drill everything and then have it also stand level. Fat chance.
I would start with Ellis's idea. I've done that and it works well. As a Camera repairman I've had to drill some very accurate holes for small dowels. Making a jig works well.
In cases where I simply could not use a jig or had no way to drill the holes accurately, here's what I do. I drill holes in one piece. Then I install pins on this piece that just barely sticks out. Sharpen the stick out end. Now press the parts together to mark the other part. (Think dowel alignment pins) Now I drill other pair of holes. Hopefully they align but often the don't. In this case I drill the second set of holes larger until the 1st piece and it's dowels fit. I cut little grooves or notches in the sides of this part of the dowel. Then I use epoxy to both fill the holes and lock to the dowel. I've been very successful using machine screws with the heads cut off as my dowels in this case.
You do have to figure out how to hold it while the epoxy dries. In your case I would clamp 2 small boards to the fin so it stuck out on each side. Then clamp this combination to the body.
I've used this idea for doing cut in flutes in conjunction with an indexing wheel. Work out how far the bit must extend for the depth of cut you need and use spacers (washers, cardboard, business cards, etc. ) to get it.
With the base flat on the bed of the lathe - and a STOP clamped to the lathe bed to control the start of the cut - press the bit into the wood and slide the jig along on the bed for the initial cut - which should be undersized. Rotate the piece a little bit and make a second cut to widen the groove created by the first pass. Test the fit and tune the fit.
One of my turning clubs has a challenge project which was "It came from outer space", more or less...I started making these boxes to look like fish, so of course, everyone thought they looked like rockets. I figured...if you can't beat them, join them.
So I made a rocket box. It was going to be a pencil box, but I think that it will end up being too fragile to be used often. I need to think of something else...less frequently accessed than pencils.
(and Lyle will be fighting you during the bidding... he likes his pepper!)
IF I was to try this.. my mind is headed in the direction of turning a cup of sorts that would hold the object upright... at the right level. Then cut slots for where the fins go on it. Then... figure out a way to cut essentially - biscuits, so that there was a little up down play in it for leveling.. Now whether I could pull that off is another story, but that's how I'm thinking I'd like to try. All else, Small dowels as John or Ellis described.
Well it could be done the way I do shaker tables. Route 3 dovetails using an index head on the lathe and a router on a table. then you have to route dovetails in the wings and then undercut the wing slightly. I've done it with legs of course but not with fins or wings yet. I'll but an emphasis on YET.
John has the right idea. I would add that ring shank nails work great in this application. The nice thing about this method is that the holes do not have to be that accurate. The epoxy will lock in the nails/bolts. All you have to do is hold them in place while the epoxy dries.
Also if you have two rather small things to join (seems small stuff get broken more often) this works great and adds lots of strength. Best regards, Ralph