Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Need WC help!

Posts

Need WC help!

#1

Need WC help!

dick gerard

Hello everybody! I have a commission to make some medieval style goblets. Not the thin stemmed variety, but the more robust tpe that you see vikings ponding down mead with.

So, I initially designed around white oak. The dimensions of the piece would require eitehr a 3x3 (rather skimpy) a 4x4 (better) or a 5x5 (best!) ... assuming that it would be functional and of 1 piece. So, I contacted frank Miller Lumber, one of the world's leading suppliers of white oak. No luck there!

So, before I abandon the "one piece" solution, I am requesting your help. Specifically:

Does anyone know of a source of white oak, either air dried or KD in the dimensions needed?

My initial choice of white oak was predicated on white oak's ability to hold liquid and not weep or seep. Are there any acceptable substitutes for white oak that would be more readily available? In thge pastI have used maple but with minimal success ... the inside of the "cup", being endgrain, always picks up the color of the liquid.

So, please let me know ... and thanks ahead of time.

And contrary to the contents of this posting I do know how to spell ... but my fingers have not yet caught on to this new fangled typing thing!

Re: Need WC help!

#2

Re: Need WC help!

Terry Quiram

Dick you might search around for someone that salvages old buildings and see if they have any oak timbers. Probably hard as the hubs of hell and you will need carbide to cut them. I would suggest staved segments as a reasonable resort.

Re: Need WC help!

#3

Steve Kubien

Wish I could help.  Sorry.

Steve Kubien

Re: Need WC help!

#4

Re: Need WC help!

Dave Paine

I second the staved segment approach and the separate piece for the bottom. Works for oak barrels.

If you could find a solid piece it would also have end grain on the bottom and absorb staining from any fluids.

Re: Need WC help!

#5

Re: Need WC help! *LINK*

john lucas

Dick Check with places that sell table leg blanks or even table legs. I purchased some from Jeffries lumber near Knoxville, TN quite a few years ago. They usually have table leg stock which is 3 1/2 square by 32" long. Mostly they have maple in this size but I've seen oak.

I purchased some table legs from Osborne one time and returned them to fit my customers needs. You might give them a call and see what they have to offer. It was cheaper than actually buying the wood around here.

Give Nick Cook a call. He knows where all the good lumber places are in Atlanta. I purchased some table leg stock down there one time. I think it was Atlanta hard woods or Atlanta wood products. Can't remember the name but Nick will know.


http://www.osbornewood.com/table-legs.cfm

Re: Need WC help!

#6

JL

Re: Need WC help!

JL

Maple or cherry will work - you just have to seal the inside with an epoxy coating.

Re: Need WC help!

#7

Ellis Walentine

Hens' teeth

Ellis Walentine

Few kiln operators attempt to dry thick oak because the kiln schedule has to be extremely long to avoid honeycombing and checking. My advice would be to get a log section, split out a nice blank, turn your goblet to rough dimension and hollow it, then let it dry before you re-chuck it and take it down to finish dimension.

Ellis

Re: Need WC help!

#8

Steven Antonucci

As the owner of a lot of improperly dried QSWO...

steven antonucci

I highly recommend what Ellis said!

treat it like a bowl blank, and use DNA to accelerate the drying if you need it faster.

S

Re: Need WC help!

#9

Re: Need WC help!

John Veerkamp

Beech was often used for drinking vessels. It will darken inside with liquid use, but the mead will seal the pores. The darkening lends an authentic look to the piece.

Re: Need WC help!

#10

Bring your chainsaw

Ray - Middletown, In

I have a log out back looking for a project.

Ray

Re: Need WC help!

#11

Re: Need WC help!

Ron Bauman

Many years ago I turned a chalice for a priest friend of mine. My ex was a potter and we collaborated. She threw the cup portion and I turned the base. Solved a couple of problems. The bottom of the cup was left rough and epoxied to the base, just sayin".