Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

The Value of Concepts and Vocabulary

Posts

The Value of Concepts and Vocabulary

#1

The Value of Concepts and Vocabulary

charlie belden

For the aesthetics of an art form to develop, a vocabulary for it is needed in order to enable artists / artisans to share concepts / ideas and techniques - a shorthand for communication and for the disemination knowledge and information. The development of fundamental concepts on which the artform is based, that link cause and effect/results makes it possible to develop, and over time, refine the artform.

For single axis wood turnings, the aesthetics - and vocabulary - were already there - created by potters who �threw� pieces on a potter�s wheel long before the advent of the lathe and wood turning tools. The mediums and methods are different, but the resulting shapes and forms, along with their proportions are basically the same.

For turning, we play with three fundamental components to create the profile of a single axis, symetric piece - with round cross sections. And we have terms that are their descriptors - beads, coves and grooves ( concave or convex curves and intersecting straight lines). We also have terms that describe where these components meet - transitions, shoulder, neck, foot, fair curves, finials, along with �guidelines� for proportions for the basic single axis turned forms - plates/platters, bowls, hollow forms, lidded boxes - and even terms like �winged�, �natural edge�, . . .

The profile of a single axis piece turned to round cross sections is predictable. Rotated it about its axis - and the profile remains constant. There�s no need to think about the profile we see - because we already have a mental model, concepts of what single axis symetric things are - some idea of how they�re created - and a set of mental criteria for what looks good and what doesn�t. The look of the wood may change - but the profile remains constant - no surprises - no �Wait a Minute. The Profile Changed! HUH!?� - no conscious thinking is required to interpret what we are seeing before deciding if we like a piece or not.

Ornamental Turning has, because it�s been around for quite a while, no doubt, its own vocabulary, mental models and underlying concepts.

Multi axis and eccentric turning is just beginning to develop it�s own vocabulary, it�s own fundamental concepts - and Barbara Dill�s Multi Axis Papers, DVD, demos, presentations and multi axis turnings just may be the foundation for the aesthetics that will develop for multi axis turned pieces.

When you're living in the midst of what will become "history" - it's often difficult to recognize, let alone appreciate, the significance of certain events. I think years from now, that Barbara Dill's sharing of her insights will be one of those significant events.

Re: The Value of Concepts and Vocabulary

#2

I've been following this discussion ......

JamieDonaldson

...about "camera perspective" and POV with some interest, because definitions must be based on some "universal" understanding to have validity. As a philosophy major I spent much time studying language analysis, the bricks that form our understanding of commonly used vocabulary. And as a photographer(retired) there is no universal definition of camera perspective, because that happens to be wherever the individual operator decides to place the camera at any given time. For my teaching purposes I prefer to use the view of the turner's eyes as the best point of observation, because that's what the viewer would see when attempting the same operation, eliminating any chance for disorientation caused by camera location. I have not seen Barbara's DVD so I'm not aware of her camera locations and definitions, but for multi-axis work I believe the best view is also from the position of the turner's eyes, which allows viewing of the ghost images and cutting tool movements exactly as they are happening. You are correct that creating a lexicon for multi-axis turning techniques is essential for advancing the process, so start collecting the terminology!

Re: The Value of Concepts and Vocabulary

#3

Re: I've been following this discussion ......

charlie belden

Might want to start with the definitions for Multi Axes and Eccentric turning. Are they the same thing, mutually exclusive or have some overlap?

The term Barbara coined "air wood" is a very useful term - once you've seen what it means. The term "lens" to describe two Arcs intersecting at two points is useful for visualizing some types of multiple pairs of centers turnings. I've not seen a word that brings to mind the shape of three arcs, each with its own center, intersecting. And the terms "two sided", "three sided", "four sided" might not work since they imply PLANES not curved surfaces. How many sides does a sphere have? Maybe adapting plane geometry terms - for triangles for example - might be helpful - equilateral for three arcs of equal radii, isosceles for three sided arc turnings that have two of the arcs having the same radius. Chords and chord lengths could be useful descriptors as well.

Re: Camera position:

The problem I see with having the camera looking over the shoulder of the turner is analogous to trying to show someone how to aim a rifle with the camera looking over the shooter's shoulder. If the camera can't provide the shooters "sight picture" and you need to see and understand that "sight picture", all the video in the world won't help.

Here are four screen captures from Barbara's DVD showing the wood's eye view of her spindle gouge cutting "air wood". As you can see, your can see the cutting edge, where it's cutting and the "shadow wood" it's cutting. These still images merely hint at what you see in action in the video. Except for the lower left image, what you see in the still images is a Right Rolling Cut


Hope this illustrates the camera position, the translucency of the "shadow wood" and the visual information about how the cuts are being made.

Re: The Value of Concepts and Vocabulary

#4

Re: The Value of Concepts and Vocabulary

Paulo Marin

Charlie,

Beautiful introduction of Barbara's accomplishments. I find her work fantastic.

I would like to take this opportunity if you allow me to pay homage to another phenomenal woodturner who has been one of the most influential figures in multi-axis work and an inspiration to many... and that is Jean Francois Escoulen ( http://www.escoulen.com/ang/pages/atelier.html )

It is refreshing to see people exploring new forms and shapes. Innovation and creativity are most important to propel woodturning to the future.

I enjoyed reading your post!

Congratulations Barbara!

Paulo Marin

Glaser Hitec Engineering

Re: The Value of Concepts and Vocabulary

#5

Re: The Value of Concepts and Vocabulary

charlie belden

Pardon my not invoking the name Escoulen when discussing multi-axes / eccentric turning. It was Escoulen who brought this form of turning to the consciousness of the woodturning community. Others. such as Gary Fisher and Keith Holt increased the interest in and appreciation of this turning area.

It's one thing to be impressed with fine examples of multi-axis / eccentric turning. And being able to teach others to turn pieces that copy pieces already done is valuable. But what Barbara is doing is to provide the underlying concepts, terms and basic methods for this area of turning that can take turners beyond copying - into the area of CREATING - their own unique application of those concepts, terms and methods. THAT accomplishment is what should put her in the history of modern wood turning. That she is now applying her knowledge and skills to begin creating the aesthetics of multi-axes turning puts her well on her way to earning an additional entry in the history of modern woodturninig.

Now if she'd just start working on a Terms & Definitions Paper . . .