Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

An interesting YouTube video

Posts

An interesting YouTube video

#1

Steven Antonucci

An interesting YouTube video

steven antonucci


Hook tools are super efficient cutting tools, huh?

S

Re: An interesting YouTube video

#2

Is this south of the equator??

jake Niedling

I have heard things move in the opposite direction south of the equator like the swirl in a toliet when it is flushed. The lathe is rotating backwards and they are cutting on what we would call the wrong side. HMMMMMM!!! Maybe Terry could help us out on this. :) :)

Re: An interesting YouTube video

#3

Steven Antonucci

and his bowl gouge is really a bowl hook!

steven antonucci

Re: An interesting YouTube video

#4

Re: An interesting YouTube video

Colin Spencer

Hook tools are the traditional turning tools in Northern Spain and they use them for spindle work as well as bowls. Many different shapes and sizes are used, most are home made and shaped to suit the task at hand. Seeing some of the expert 'old timers' use them is incredible.

Re: An interesting YouTube video

#5

In pause mode...

Jack Savona

...it looked like a 90 degree bend at the end with a round carbide disc doing the cutting.

Re: An interesting YouTube video

#6

Robin Hood and his hook tool  *LINK*

john lucas


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w3RZ2ltC8Ps&feature=related

Re: An interesting YouTube video

#7

A close up of hook tool working  *LINK*

john lucas


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NmX-C79aQNk&feature=fvwrel

Re: An interesting YouTube video

#8

Spanish hook tools

Colin Spencer

An example of some homemade Spanish hook tools, typical of the type used here.


img

Re: An interesting YouTube video

#9

Rob Wallace

I agree Steve, BUT.......

Rob Wallace

.......from a teaching perspective, this is one that I could only suggest as being "interesting" to watch, but is not a particularly useful video to send a beginner to learn something from. There is no narrative, no explanation of what is going on as far as initiating and making the cuts, and most importantly, that the lathe is running opposite to the usual mode of turning. (A beginner would not likely catch this at first [...no pun intended!].) And you are correct that the video's title is mis-named; it clearly is a hook tool!

It would also be helpful to see some closeups of the tool's cutter structure and geometry, the actual cutting action in progress, how the tool meets the wood on the initial contact, and how the cut progresses through multiple passes. The annoying back lighting in the upper left that washes-out about 20-25% of the image throughout the entire video further detracts from the teaching impact his video could have.

Maybe I'm being too picky, but there are so many bad turning videos freely available out there (with quite a few that show/promote unsafe of otherwise bad technique) that could be significantly improved with minor modifications, and an understanding of what a video is supposed to do for the viewer.

Thanks for posting this!

Rob

Re: An interesting YouTube video

#10

Rob   That's why I posted other 2.

john lucas

Re: An interesting YouTube video

#11

Steven Antonucci

Purpose of post

steven antonucci

I can only assume that the purpose of the original posted video was to have the poster demonstrate his capabilities, not teach or make an educational video. My purpose was only to show that you can cut a lot of wood very quickly and cleanly with a hook (which is why I sometimes hollow with them).

As far as the production values of the video, I assume he wasn't trying to win an Oscar. I also don't think it matters if the lathe is running "backwards", as he would just flip the tool over and cut on the bottom edge on the left side if it was running normally.

What I found interesting is the fact that the bevel is being pushed into the wood and supported in front of the cut and along the right. I have to guess that it's pretty solid and much less likely to catch than a bowl gouge because it is a much simpler motion (push...straight).

I have some hooks, and I will have to try this. I may shoot a video too...with even lower production values...

S