yesterday.... it does get easier, right?
avalon
it went boom again...
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
yesterday.... it does get easier, right?
avalon
it went boom again...
Re: yesterday.... it does get easier, right?
avalon
Re: yesterday.... it does get easier, right?
Doc Green
This piece of wood is obviously degraded, to my eye, and I've turned a ton just like it. I'll bet it's very light. My guess is that it came apart just from centrifugal force. You must keep the RPM down. Way down.
Sorry about the mishap. It would have been a nice bowl. ~Doc
Re: yesterday.... it does get easier, right?
Barry Irby
How fast were you turning? How big and how deep was that bowl? I must be turning way slower than you, I have not exploded one in a long time. Either that, or I am chicken and you are not. Doesn't look like you were too thin, was there a serious crack in the piece when you started? And yes it does get easier.
Re: yesterday.... it does get easier, right?
Bob Macgregor
It's kind of hard to see that one as a "design opportunity"... unless you are into designer firewood.
I guess its time to chuck up a fresh (sound) piece and just work your way into it.
BOB
Only if you respect physics
Ed Moore in SW VA
If you ignore physics then you are dancing with the devil in the pale moonlight. You didn't say whether you had a catch or if the wood suddenly gave way.
From the looks of the wood there may have been some checks or cracks. This means that if you simply increased the speed then at some critical point the centrifugal force will exceed the ability of the wood to hold together and then the wood explodes.
If you had a catch, then a force was applied to the wood that caused some wood to stop while the rest of the wood kept going due to momentum. And, the wood exploded.
How do you prevent this from occurring again?
1. Choose sound wood without observable defects.
2. Take less aggressive cuts. Use a smaller bowl gouge so that a smaller cut occurs. Make sure that the tool is sharp.
3. Pay attention to how the tool is meeting the wood, so that it cannot grab.
4. Consider having an experienced turner observe you turn a bowl and offer their opinion.
The 45 - 45 - 45 approach to turning bowls that was popularized by Bill Grumbine and Jimmy Clewes, and probably others, is a good principle to observe. Bill and Jimmy each have excellent tapes that explain this.
Remember, if you don't do something different next time, the same result will occur.
Ed
I think I know what happened...
steven antonucci
If you can post three things, I can almost guarantee you I know what happened:
1.) Assume you were inside the vessel when you self destructed? Where in the vessel were you cutting when you got the catch?
2.) What tool were you using?
3.) Why did you have a curved tool rest on?
Steven
Re: yesterday.... it does get easier, right?
john lucas
there are several good responses. One is I'll agree with Doc. the wood looks almost rotten. That alone can make it weak. Keep the speed down on those.
I'll agree with Steve. If you used the curved rest I hope you had the inside curve on the inside of the bowl. If not you probably had too much tool hanging over the rest which invites a catch.
On wood than crumbly it's important not to put too much pressure on the bevel of the tool. Think about gliding the bevel not pushing on it. The same is true with the forward pressure of the cut. don't force the tool, relax your grip and let it cut.
Lastly follow Ed's advice. See if you can find an experienced turner and let them look over your shoulder and help you with your cuts. If not The Bill Grumbine video is excellent to help you.
Re: yesterday.... it does get easier, right?
Phil Stivers
I'm no "expert" but it also looks to me that the chuck jaws might be a little small for the size of the turning. Had there been more support perhaps the jaws could have absorbed the catch without shearing the tenon.
I'll venture several speculations ......
JamieDonaldson
based on observations of this "crime" scene, any of which could have been a contributing factor, or maybe not.
1. Old dry wood with pre-existing internal weaknesses and defects.
2. Use of a scraper for making wall thickness uniform from rim to center in a single process, rather than thinning down from rim to center in several steps. This often leads to chatter at the rim, which leads to kindling.
3. Tenon in chuck jaws too small for condition of material and size of project.
4. Excess speed and tool/tool rest location could have also been contributing factors in the above. Using that rotating headstock and extended tool rest is an accident waiting to happen due to the spring in the extension, and I would throw the extension away before it actually breaks and you really get hurt!
#2 is my guess
steven antonucci
but I disagree with the rest.
S
Re: yesterday.... it does get easier, right?
Steve Kubien
The chuck jaws were the first thing I looked at. I really hate Nova's dovetail jaws. Even if you form the dovetail correctly, over-tightening can cut fibers, distort how the tenon fits the jaws and lead to all sorts of creative and premature dismounts.
I prefer the Oneway profiled jaws and use them in my Nova SN2 chucks.
Re: yesterday.... it does get easier, right?
Darry Hansen
What gouge were you using. Can you show us a picture of it??
Re: yesterday.... it does get easier, right?
JMOHNIKE
In looking at the pic's there appears to be a knot, with checks in it, a possible weak point. On the part which is laying on the bed, there appears to be some discoloration near the bottom left, maybe jus a shadow, which may indicate a check/crack in the woood, another weak point. You may have avoided this by cutting more off the blank, to remove the knot and check. I do not feel the problem is with the chuck. I have also found, not always, that outboard tool rests are not as good as over the bed tool rests, they seem to vibrate, and cause more chatter causeing the tool to grab. If possible turn over the bed.
Just my thoughts.
Re: yesterday.... it does get easier, right?
Dick Wilson
My two cents for what it is worth.........
It doesn't look like you were using the "step process" for removing the inside. I go gradually deeper 1-2" at a time, finishing the inside wall as I go. All that mass in the bowl is your friend. I never returned to the wall that I have finished turning!!!
I see another problem in that you were turning a side grain bowl if the picture of the wood in the chuck is not deceiving. For me side grain bowls are a lot trickier for me than end grain bowls. The walls are a lot more flexible. I have knocked turnings off at the tenon....and it always looked like your picture. Someone correct me if I am wrong but when you turn a side grain bowl the wood fibers don't give you nearly the support that an end grain bowl will. Your tenon support might be too small. A larger tenon would give more support.
As mentioned before slow the speed down. Centrifugal force enters into the equation much more on side grain work.
I take it you were not injured.......just startled....and you darn well better have been wearing a faceshield!!!!! Go on to your next piece and turn safe.
Re: yesterday.... it does get easier, right?
avalon
oH... i know what happened... i just wanted to show the photo...
It was full of bug holes... one area had a bunch near the bottom... a combination of getting the bottom too thin and the weakness fo the bugholes made for a boom...
i was cleaning up the outside with something... dont remmeber what..
and u gotta remember... im in texas.. the tree of choice is live oak and water oak,... so i use what i can get... that was a piece of ash given to me by a turner in houston who's been doing it forever...
pretty much any wood im going to get is going to have some flaw, either small cracks or bugs.. either that or do segmented turnings...
It's not the wood or the chuck, it's your method
steven antonucci
Generally speaking, I observe that people starting out with hollowform turning have the same issues. If you don't have a process for making them, it is likely that you will lose a bunch.
Here's what I do.
Starting between centers, I turn a rough outer shape and an ACCURATE tenon.
Next, mount in a chuck and return to final form on the outside. Finish it knowing that you will not cut an exterior surface on the lathe again.
As others have suggested, hollow down a little at a time. When you are done in the top, you are done. No going backwards. Ever.
Finish the inside to whatever thickness and make the foot to almost final size. Remove from chuck.
Reverse on a spigot. At this point, you will be glad that you put the center mark in the chuck hold, and you can use it to recenter your form.
Cut the foot as small as you dare, then finish sand the lower part to blend tooled with upper sanded areas.
Handsaw and remove the nub any way you like.
I don't think there was anything wrong with your wood, but I wouldn't want to recut the outside of a side grain vessel after it was hollowed. The vessel was likely out of round and you caught an edge...and kerplooie!
S
Re: It's not the wood or the chuck, it's your meth
john lucas
Also in the photo it looks thinner in the bottom than the rim. It should be the other way around while your working on it. get the first inch or so of the rim area as thick, or thin, as you want it and then work your way down. I believe that's what Jamie suggested above.
Re: It's not the wood or the chuck, it's your meth
Keith Tompkins
HI John, I agree. The bottom is too thin....even if it hadn't exploded, he probably couldn't have reverse-turned it anyway. The base would have been translucent, or non-existant.
Re: yesterday.... it does get easier, right?
Barry Irby
This is my second whack at answering this.
It appears some people thought this was a hollow form. It appears to me that it was a bowl somewhere in the 8 to 10" range.
It appears to me the chuck foot is smaller than I find desirable. I like to have the foot about 1/3 the rim diameter. I have four inch jaws and use them a lot. I like to work with the jaws nearly closed, perhaps and 1/8 or 1/4" between them when the blank is mounted. (Better contact with the blank that way) And It is important that the shoulder on the blanks seat firmly against the face of the jaws. Do not let the tenon bottom out.
I turn the outside of the bowl and then the inside, working my way from the rim down to the bottom.
I have a walnut blank in the shop I will send you if you send me your address. I will put it in a the biggest flat rate box I can find and you can take a whack at it anyway you see fit. Its a bit thin, perhaps 12 by 12 and maybe 2 1/2" thick. If I were to turn it I might want to use a glue block to save every bit of it.
Just give me the word and its on its way.
uber coolness.. but i gotta quit turning...
avalon
Temporarily.. Two reasons..
1. I'm turning a pet bird aviary into a woodshop, so im finally getting rid of 600 odd pet birds ive raised for years... down to 60 and a few cages... I have to quit this hobby because I can't go on vacation, or go anywhere, cause i have to spend about 2-3 hours a day, every day, feeding and watering them... I have to quit this, because...
2. Sometime in the next 2-3 weeks my wife is going to birth identical twin girls. I've been working for weeks painting a room pink, putting cribs together, etc.. My parents bought a dresser for them from sears, and i started putting it together when i found out it was made of particle board.... I put it about 10% together and then took it apart and put it back in the box and called sears to come pick it up.. i dont like particle board... it started disintigrating as i was pulling parts out of the box... but it was a gift... so i did try... then went downtown to an unfinished furniture place... averate $600-1200 for a unpainted pine 6 drawer dresser...
So i went to lowes and got some pine and started to build a small sewing desk for my wife so we can put her sewing stuff on to clear up room. Then IF i like it, i'm gonna attempt a 6 drawer dresser. Since the twins will not need it for a month or two i think i can attempt it...
thus... bout to get extremely insane (more than normal)... so i want to concentrate on getting the aviary emptied, cleaned, painted, and then start on adding a wood work bench, and putting a nova dvr lathe with extention, a 16 inch jet planer, a 6' tall craftsmen drill, and a router table... and i also would like to add a table saw, some kind of drum sander, and whatever else i can fit in a 16x25' building. ANd thats in my spare time...
Just fyi,,, Im 42 and semi retired... my wife and i own a wedding facility and i do all the yardwork, mowing, landscaping, weeding, etc.... www.avalonweddingsbcs.com. By retired i mean i work all the time cause im self employed, but at this time of year i only need to work about 3-5 hours a day cause working out doors in 100+ isnt fun. And since i make the same amount of $ whether i work 3 hours a day or 15, i figured i can just keep the weeds down at this time... But i do pretty much work every day and sometiems work 15 hour work days... just depends on the time of the year... OH.. and im also a full time 20 year Master Photographer.. (sorry john... had to put in a ppa plug)... so i photograph a lot..
wow.. didnt mean to make a disertation.. so after the twins are born, i will (Not) have a wee bit more spare time cause the shop is now about 3 miles away at my dads. The new one is about 40 feet out my back door..
and yes.. as soon as the building is emptied, cleaned, and painted, i will photograph it (cause right now it's a mess) and post it... And i would encourage people to tell me how to put it together cause again, if ignorance is bliss, i am very happy...
Re: uber coolness.. but i gotta quit turning...
matt overton
Good luck with the babies! Don't quit turning. You might try smaller, quicker projects to do in those sleepless hours of the night. You know, they are going to need a pair of matching rattles.
Re: uber coolness.. but i gotta quit turning...
avalon
i;ve actually made a few rattles... out of black and white ebony.. didnt know if it was safe but i had a piece and was bored... so...
made one from a piece of drying oak, but it wasnt dry enough and split, so im gonna try some kiln dried oak from lowes ..