Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Camera Perspective - Turner's POV vs Wood's POV

Posts

Camera Perspective - Turner's POV vs Wood's POV

#1

Camera Perspective - Turner's POV vs Wood's POV

charlie belden

Barbara Dill was kind enough to send me a copy of her DVD on Multi Axis Turning. After watching it once - and having learned a LOT about how to use her Mental Models to bring Order Out Of Apparent Chaos - I have a question (he finally got to his question!).

ALL the turning videos I'd watched give a Turner's Point Of View (POV) perspective. In Barbara's video you get the Wood's POV perspective. Because multi axis turning involves "turning" what I call In The Shadows, Barbara refers to it as turning "Air Wood" - you can SEE - what the tool is doing as it appears to be removing the Air Wood - EXACTLY which part of the cutting edge is cutting wood - and the orientation of the tool as the cut progresses.

Now it's one thing to mentally visualize what the tool is doing - but it's MUCH better to actually SEE what it's doing - from the wood's perspective - more accurately - the Air Wood's perspective.

My question:

Why don't turning videos use this Air Wood POV when demonstrating how a tool is used to make different types of cuts? By seeing the tool being used for a cut - in Air Wood - that by definition you can see THROUGH, yet still see - things are MUCH clearer and easier to understand.

Re: Camera Perspective - Turner's POV vs Wood's POV

#2

Re: Camera Perspective - Turner's POV vs Wood's PO

john lucas

Charlie Not sure I totally understand what your saying. Are you saying the camera should be mounted at the turners head position. I don't know if you've seen my video's. I'm trying to learn what works. I have two that might show what your hinting at. One is turning a bottle stopper. I needed to show someone the actual cuts so I got in close with the camera at my point of view.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lfZsH-Xprtg

The other one of interest for this discussion was to see inside a vessel to see how the tool worked.

//www.youtube.com/watch?v=0v7-HMuCvvM

Re: Camera Perspective - Turner's POV vs Wood's POV

#3

Re: Camera Perspective - Turner's POV vs Wood's PO

charlie belden

Look at the Yellow Blue and Green illustration at the top of the attached web page.

With the piece mounted between the offset centers for the RED line, as the piece rotates, the Yellow and Blue areas are Air Wood, the Green area is the Solid Wood.

The Air Wood is translucent since HALF the time while it's spinning it's not actually there (which is why I think of it as a Shadow.

Look at that illustration and imagine that the camera is in close and set a bit above centerline. As the turning tool is turning in the Air Wood, you can see "through" the Air Wood as it's being cut. And you can see exactly which part of the cutting edge is being used and how the tool is oriented as the cut is made. You can thus see the tool's rotation around its long axis AND how it's moving or pivoting on the tool rest (where the handle end is going).

Of course this POV can only be done with a multi-axis turning - that starts off with a lot of Air Wood to be removed.

Re: Camera Perspective - Turner's POV vs Wood's POV

#4

Charlie- what attached web page? I...

JamieDonaldson

..agree with John that the best viewing is from the turner's point of view, just as if the viewer was holding the tool and doing the turning. When I do multi-axis work, I'm viewing the ghost image of the wood being either kept or removed, and of course the tool position is always in plain view and requires good lighting. There is much practice required to master this process, and you can't do it with your eyes closed as you can hollowing! :D

Re: Camera Perspective - Turner's POV vs Wood's POV

#5

Re: Charlie- what attached web page? I...  *LINK*

charlie belden

OOPS!

THIS times I've included the link.

The problem with the Turner's POV camera shots are that the wood streaming off the cutting edge obstructs the view where the edge meets the wood. And even in a tight shot you can see enough of the tool to understand how the tool is being rotated and what the handle is doing based on what you see the end in front of the tool rest is doing. You really have to see Barbara's video to understand and appreciate the camera postion used.

The use of a spindle gouge is pretty complicated when you think about it -rotation about the long axis, the tool tilted at compound angles which are almost constantly changing. This Wood's Side View of turning Air Wood conveys what's going on better - for me - than any other video I've seen.

While this POV shot can only be done when the piece being turned is multi-axis - and you can see what the tool is doing as it cuts through the Air Wood - seeing the process was an AH HA! thing for me.


MultiAxis - Air Wood Illustration

Re: Camera Perspective - Turner's POV vs Wood's POV

#6

Katherine Kowalski

Re: Charlie- what attached web page? I...  *LINK*

Katherine Kowalski

Charlie,

While most turning videos are project-oriented, there are some excellent ones that include tool usage. I can specifically recommend Cindy Drozda's videos for tooling instruction -- she gives a clear description of the movement of the tool as they are being used. The camera angles clearly show the path of the gouges, et al. Cindy also uses visual aids for reference. Check out "Finial Star Box" for a comprehensive guide to spindle turning, (and a great sharpening section as well).

Katherine


http://www.cindydrozda.com

Re: Camera Perspective - Turner's POV vs Wood's POV

#7

Re: Camera Perspective - Turner's POV vs Wood's PO

Barbara Dill

Charlie,

Thanks for your comments. I'm glad the video made things clearer for you. Reading an article is one thing, but seeing the demo and the spindles being turned makes it more understandable. I've often wondered about the camera angle. I personally can not understand the turning when the camera is above the axis of the lathe. I prefer the camera angle being at the tail stock end so the tool's bevel can be seen, or the turner's view. The camera being in front of the lathe in my video did show some great shots of the tool cutting the wood. I was amazed and happy with the results. My friend, Cindy, did a great job with the video.

Re: Camera Perspective - Turner's POV vs Wood's POV

#8

Re: Camera Perspective - Turner's POV vs Wood's PO

R Henrickson

Is the DVD you are referring to the one mentioned on this webpage?

http://www.barbaradill.com/schedule.html

She has also posted revised versions of her two articles and a handout on her website:

http://www.barbaradill.com/paper.html

Re: Camera Perspective - Turner's POV vs Wood's POV

#9

Re: Charlie- what attached web page? I...

charlie belden

Had the pleasure of attending a Cindy Drozda day long demonstration and have, and have gone through, two of her DVDs. I totally agree with you. Her demonstrations are excellent - as are her DVDs. And her passion for turning is infectuous and inspirng. I went home after her demo thinking "I can do an inlayed rim lidded box with finial like Cindy showed us" - and did - AFTER putting together my notes into illustrated step by step instructions which I revised to fill in details not in my notes but that I remembered.

I'm a Visual Learner and I'm pretty good at understanding fairly complex concepts. I can see a turning tool making a cut and THINK I understand what it's doing and how it's doing it. But it can be like seeing only two, maybe three views of something - top, front and end views for example. Additional views, especially of a complex shape - or a cutting tool - as it rotates, pivots and slides - that let me see it in action - from the wood's perspective has significantly improved my understanding of what's going on.

So the wood's eye view - of a spindle gouge - cutting Air Wood is enlightening.

Re: Camera Perspective - Turner's POV vs Wood's POV

#10

Re: Camera Perspective - Turner's POV vs Wood's PO

charlie belden

The DVD available on her website looks like it's probably the one she sent me and that I referred to. Didn't know it was available yet, thinking it was sent to me for review and comment. Now I'm going to have to pay for it so as to avoid the even the appearance of a conflict of interest (my years in Civil Service conditioned me to being civil and of service and always aware of possible conflicts of interests or even the impression of a conflict of interest).

Barbara Dill has brought Order To Chaos - at least for me - and introduced me to ARCS and TWISTS. By providing a structured systematic approach to multi axis turning - she's opened up the world of multi axis turning to anyone who wants to get into it - because she's flattened the learning curve significantly. The combination of her papers, presentations, demonstrations, and and now her DVD, may become the foundation for the development of the aesthetics of multi axis turning.

Re: Camera Perspective - Turner's POV vs Wood's POV

#11

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Camera Perspective - Turner's POV vs Wood's PO

Lyle Jamieson

This POV works on the edge of a natural edge bowl or a hollow form with voids too. Its cool to put a strong light shining directly from above and watch the tools work their magic in mid air on the inside of a hollow form. Its not the camra angle but the "air" that makes it viewable.