Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

I have had my last catch...

Posts

I have had my last catch...

#1

I have had my last catch...

GaryG in MD

...with my angled hollowing tool on a 5/16" straight shaft.

The cutting tip is way off axis, and it's just too unpredictable.

I will have no more catches with it because it's going in the trash unless I can convert it to an outrigger tool (torque arrestor for those of you down under).

I don't weld, and I'm wondering if there's a simple place to find a 5/16" steel rod attached to a donut with a set screw that I can just slide on and tighten up.

What would such a thing be called so I can try to Google it and come up with a ready made object?

Thanks, Gary

Re: I have had my last catch...

#2

Re: I have had my last catch...

john lucas

Gary I need more info. How long is this tool? What are you trying to hollow. 5/16" is pretty narrow. I haven't tried to see how deep I can hollow with one but I would think it's probably not much more than 3 or maybe 4". I usually use my 5/16 too for deep ornaments when the 1/4" starts to chatter. Those are rarely over 2 1/2"

Are you wanting to put a 5/16 cutter on a larger bar?

Re: I have had my last catch...

#3

Leo Cuellar

Re: I have had my last catch...

Leo Cuellar

Gary, if you could post a photo of the tool, I'm sure somebody could offer some useful suggestions.

Re: I have had my last catch...

#4

Steven Antonucci

build this

steven antonucci


All or near all of your issues are because you are likely cutting above center. If you make this, that issue goes away...

S

Re: I have had my last catch...

#5

Lyle Jamieson

Re: I have had my last catch...

Lyle Jamieson

I would scrap the 5/16 boring bar the limitations will drive you crazy. 5/8 min. but 3/4 even better. It would take only a little welding to get a captured system going. Most of the work could be done by "anyone" with a drill and capability to tap threads in a hole for a set screw. A local welder can do some cheap welding for you. Or even make all the componants out if wood. Sombody named Steve did it successfully. :-) I used a wood back rest for years. Size and photos are on my web site for those that want to build a home built system. lylejamieson.com

Re: I have had my last catch...

#6

Richard Allen

Re: I have had my last catch...

Richard Allen

Hi Gary,

Talk to CA about one of his swan neck tools. They put the cutting tip on line with the tool shaft.

Re: I have had my last catch...

#7

Leo Cuellar

Now I understand...

Leo Cuellar

A 1/2" heavy coupler nut would provide enough "meat" to allow you to drill & tap for 5/16" then you could thread a long bolt through the side. Thread a nut & lock washer onto the bolt before you snug the end against the shaft of your tool. Make yourself a nice wood handle to slide on it before assembly, 5/16" will be a little uncomfortable to hold for long. Would get you by for a while.

Re: I have had my last catch...

#8

Dick Hines

Re: I have had my last catch...

Dick Hines

Gary. I have a set of 5/16 hollowing tools. They are good for up to about 5-6 inches. That may be pusting things a little but I tend to do that some. They are great for small things.

When you use your bent tool make sure the curved section is "never" on or behind the tool rest. Keep the handle up above center and the tip at center.

Don't give up on a good tool.

Re: I have had my last catch...

#9

Re: I have had my last catch...

john lucas

If you have a curved tip tool the tip should be in line with the center of the tool shaft. Think of it as a question mark shape ?. This will reduce the tendency for the tool to twist. Then as mentioned above you need the tool rest on the straight part of the tool, not the hook part.

I did make a copy of Lyle's captured bar system without welding. I used All thread rod for the cross pieces and used locking nuts to hold it together. If your handy with a drill press and can use a tap to thread a couple of pieces I can tell you how to build one. Finding someone with a welder is better of course.

Re: I have had my last catch...

#10

further explanation...

GaryG in MD

Thanks everyone for your replies.

I guess further explanation is in order...

I have many hollowing tools of all types and sizes -- some unconstrained and some constrained.

This problem child is a small, straight, hand-held hollowing scraper for use on ornaments and other small objects. [See photo in following post.] It's not a swan neck, although perhaps that's what I should have instead. (What I really need is Mike Hunter's back hook designed by Mark St. Leger.)



I would never try to use it more than 3" off the rest, if that.

I hand hold it, and that's the problem.



I accidentally "enlarged" the nice small access hole in this 4" dia. 'flattish' box elder HF (golden ratio) with it while trying to work up under the near shoulder. As I said... never again. It started as a closed form and nearly became an open form because I can't stop my natural reaction to pull the tool back when I sense it starting to catch.

This tool is too unpredictable because of the large torque lever arm,

and I have to hang on so tightly to keep it from twisting that I'm going to get my turner's elbow back if I'm not careful.

The simple fix is adding an outrigger. Outriggers are a good compromise between constrained and unconstrained hollowers. They're still a free hand tool, but they don't twist.

I'm not interested in finding a welder. I should be able to gin something up from the hardware store. Thanks to Leo saying the magic word "coupler" (the mental trigger I needed), I'm now thinking about a "tee coupler" with a 5/16 ID. I should be able to find one that will permit me to slide the shaft in and to attach the outrigger shaft to the tee, after bending it in the general direction of one end. Copper may be strong enough for this light-duty tool -- all I need is something to keep it from twisting -- but I'd feel better with steel.

Any plumbing, air, gas, liquid, or other fixtures come to mind?

Rick: this IS from CA. ;-)

Steve: I didn't understand your statement -- I always work slightly above center inside. To do otherwise courts disaster. How's your boy doing?

Thanks, Gary

Re: I have had my last catch...

#11

I also posted a photo of the tool...

GaryG in MD

...but apparently the second pic overwrote the first (??).

Anyway, here's the pic of the tool tip (again). ...GG


Re: I have had my last catch...

#12

Re: I also posted a photo of the tool...

john lucas

Gary It's a simply fix. Just heat the tool about 3/4" down from the end and bend it back so the tip of the tool lines up with the central shaft of the tool. Use the tool with the tool rest on the straight part of the shaft and most of the twisting force will be gone.

When I was working on designs for an ornament hollowing tool for Mike Hunter I tried lots of bends and curves. My tool works great but obviously Mark's design won out. Keeping the cutting tip in line with the central axis of the tool is important.

I was going to post a photo of the tool but I can't seem to find that folder on my new computer. I guess it's in my back up drive somewhere. I'll have to get my son to help me figure that out.

Re: I have had my last catch...

#13

Richard Allen

Re: further explanation...

Richard Allen

I have a set of 3/8" hollowing tools (straight, medium curve, large curve). I am sure he would be happy to make you a curved 5/16" one.

You should be using a straight too for the bulk of the hollowing. Switch to the angle tool only when you can't hollow any more with the straight tool. After a little hollowing with the angle tool you should be able to switch back to the straight tool for additional hollowing.

If you talk with CA at the next meeting about this he will be able to provide a solution. That solution will most likely be a change in technique.

Re: I have had my last catch...

#14

CA will just make him another tool!

JamieDonaldson

Re: I have had my last catch...

#15

Re: I also posted a photo of the tool...

GaryG in MD

Yes, there's no question that it's much better to have the cutting tip on-axis! ...GG

Re: I have had my last catch...

#16

Re: I have had my last catch...

pete labelle

Gary -

I built the Lyle Jamieson style boring system and love it. Have not had a blow-out yet on a hollow form. He gave me some pointers on the set up. You may not know how to weld, but I'm sure somebody that you know does. Work out a trade for welding/fabrication services for some of your work......or beer.

Pete

Re: I have had my last catch...

#17

Steven Antonucci

Smaller cutter is another answer

steven antonucci

I used to want to tear out wood as fast as I could cut it, so I started using bigger cutters. A bigger cutter makes a small mistake larger. A smaller cutter minimizes how catchy a tool is.

I have undercutting tools where the bits are 2" long and at 90 degrees to the shaft. They are only 1/8" bits, and I can freehand cut with them easily. I also tend to use them on or below center, as it creates more clearance under the cutter, and a catch just rotates the cutter into empty space...

(Frank's fine, thanks for asking!)

Steve