I'm getting ready to upgrade my saw to sliding miter saw. I want to use it for segmented work as well as the usual cutting long boards into short boards and cutting wide boards that are hard to fit on the table saw.
I need your recommendations. 10" vs 12" I've heard 10" saws are more accurate but have less capacity than the 12". do I really need that capacity, I'm not sure.
I like the Festool but it's just an awful lot of money and I don't know if I can go that much.
I swear by the 10" Makita, it has the biggest table even than the 12" saws and cross cuts to 13" none of the 12ves do that The only thing they can do better than the 10" Makita is cross cut thicker boards.
Take a hard look at it, as a bonus, the blade that comes with it is very good.
I have considered replacing my old Makita slider and probably #1 on the list was the Bosch 4410 that was highly rated by FWW in a recent article. However, Makita has just come out with a new slider that is really attractive and may end up getting my business if I ever decide to take the plunge. It has a dual slide mechanism that really is attractive giving the saw with the same capabilities in a smaller footprint. Check out the Makita LS1016 in a google search. I think the Makita is actually cheaper and FWW gave the saw a great review. These are both 10" saws, and I have always used them for segmented work. A larger blade would give you ability to cut thicker stock, and maybe a bit wider, but it would not be a concern for me at all. Just my 2 cents.
I have a 12" Dewalt slider and put an 80 tooth blade on it. I have done a lot of segmented pieces using it. My friend just got a Makita 12" slider and I think it is even better than my Dewalt. If I were buying one today I would give the Makita a good look. Whatever you get I would upgrade the blade to more teeth to use in segmenting. That's my 2 cents...
My oldest is a trim carpenter - and a real stickler for Doing It Right. He had and still has a Dewalt 12" SCMS and he's used my Makita 12" SCMS. He THOUGHT both were OK. Then I took him up to look at the Festool Kapex - which has "only" a 10+" blade. He was concerned about a loss of capacity - 'til he looked at the specs.
(see attached link to the Kapex specs). He's a bright lad who analyzes tools, sort of like I do - and noted several significant advantages to the Kapex over the Makita or Dewalt - access and ease of setting compound angles, click in position detentes for crown molding - range of angles beyond 45 degrees (real world corners are often less than or greater than 90 degrees) - ease of setting angles - easy blade change - range of blade types for different applications - dust port that matches the rest of the Festool System's "dust extractors" - depth of cut adjustment for "notching" like is common with radial arm saws - angle transfer device included for measuring ACTUAL corner angle and then splitting it into two equal angles - dual laser guides so you can see to Take The Line, Leave The Line or Split The Line cutting - the list went on and on.
it was the QUALITY of the cut that really impressed him - and later when he took the KAPEX to a job - inpressed his boss as well. He also appreciated that the KAPEX weighs 47 pounds - every pound you don't have to lug around is meaningful when you have to lug it to the work area - and back to your truck.
What impressed me was the footprint of the KAPEX. Both the Makita and Dewalt need a LOT of room behind them.
The KAPEX costs a chunk of change - as do its accessories. But if you make a living using tools, this one pays for itself pretty quickly. His boss forked over the money for one after Tyler showed him what the KAPEX could do - and how easy it was to do.
Like most Festool tools, this one was designed starting with a clean sheet of paper and a criteria list. The result is precision, intuitive means of set up and use - and - when connected to a Festool Dust Extractor (which I have and lend him when needed) - nearly dustless. Home owners LOVE that feature - and it saves clean up time.
I also got him Festool's plunge saw and guide along with their Multi-Function Table - with accessories.
If you want the BEST - it always costs more - initially. But over the long haul - it's less expensive in the end. Buy Once - Cry Once.
I have no connection with Festool other than owning some of their tools.
I'm pretty new to turning, but I've been building furniture and precision guitar components for quite awhile. I've got a 10" bosch compound saw with a Forrest blade(this will help a lot on any saw) and I'm able to get extreme precision with it. I've found that the Makita's are good, but can loose there accuracy fairly quickly.
If you go with a 12, please be careful. The big blade has a lot of torque and there have been a lot of injuries from the blade grabbing in thick stock or when material is not sitting properly against the fence.
BTW, thanks to the board for all the wonderful knowledge you make available
Richard I like the looks of that saw. Do you or anyone you know actually own and use one. It looks great but I would like a hands on report if anyone has it.
Ken I've read a lot of reviews from the construction and cabinetmaker crew. Although I highly respect what they do and don't doubt their skills, cutting a mitered corner isn't anything like cutting 12 to 16 segments that must fit perfectly. An then ideally do the same thing over and over to get stacks of rings. I was hoping to get more reviews from segmented turners.
Over on the segmented site they did offer advice but everyone has a different saw and few have the latest which makes choosing harder. Everyone who has the Festool loves it and if it were just a little more than the other saws I'd jump on it but it's twice as expensive and that's just a little too much. I'm still trying to convince myself that I'll enjoy it but Insurance payments are coming next month and I car repairs to do and other expenses and could use that extra $600.
I agree with Jorge. The Makita LS1013 that I have is very accurate and when I do compound miter stave cuts for the segmented work I occasionally due it is very accurate.
I recommend this saw highly and would also recommend buying the best blade you possibly can. I really like the Freud 10X80 Ultimate cutoff blade I have on this saw. I am sure there are better blades out there but this one serves my purposes very well.