It is our first attempt and I'm going to shoot it again, but I'd love some feedback on whether or not you like it and/or what changes/improvements you might suggest.
Good job, George! I agree with what Alan said. Closer shots of your grill would be nice, and some closeups of the figure details you pointed out would look nice I think. Thank you for taking the time to do this.
For those of you that "wax" blanks, do you find that it works better than Anchorseal? I'm just wondering why wax over Anchorseal? No fire hazards. No extra steps like a frying pan to melt the wax. Easy clean up with water. Same cost?
I have a 5G bucket with about a gallon of Anchorseal in it. I do the dip method for smaller stuff, and an old paintbrush for large pieces. I outsource the painting...to the kids.
I MUCH prefer the anchorseal, and for a variety of reasons. Not sure about the cost differential, but if you have to buy blocks of wax, I suspect that the difference would be negligible. (Hope things are better with your family, Steve)
As others have said, I suggest getting in much closer to the actual process - we don't need to see the jointer, radial arm saw, band saw and grinder to watch the process - these are distractions, and take away from the subject of you and what you are doing. Close-ups are your friend. Enlist the aid of a camera person to move-in and vary the perspective. Show the wax heater, the molten wax and how you coat the wood - all up close. Show us what you mean by bubbling, etc. The camera is much too far away to allow us to see what you are really doing, and how you are doing it.
We can only assume there is figure in the wood being disclosed by waxing because you simply tell the viewer, given that we can't see it. This aspect is interesting but not convincing unless we can see what you mean. Reducing the "silent" waiting time (what we called "dead air" in radio) while dripping extra wax, holding the blocks, etc. would make the video more interesting without losing any of the information being presented. The total time could probably be reduced by a third if most "dead" waiting time were removed.
(BTW - You also didn't include any footage of a nice, smooth bikini line!)
Great idea and good start for an instructional video on waxing (...the wood blanks, that is!)
These statements and questions will be a great help to me and my college film student stepson. I let him make the lighting, camera positioning and sound decisions on this run. We were working with two cameras, him controlling the one on me. The "wax Cam" was stationary and just running.
I was purposeful about not including any of my own critiques, I think I'll have better luck getting "the director" to make the changes we need if the suggestions come from others than me.
Your input will give me something to show him from test audiences who understand the process and know what they want from an instructional film.
I hope you guys didn't hold back, I want to make a good product.
I think you brought up most of the things that I was concerned about and at least a couple that I didn't think of.
Alan, Lighting and sound were the first two film issues that I saw, but obviously IMPORTANT. Neither of us checked those things before we did ALL the filming.
Steve, I switched BACK to hot waxing because I was getting so much loss due to cracking, by comparison. I think they changed the formula, AND, unless I applied at least two coats, I found it fairly ineffective, especially with a brush.
Since I buy the vast majority of my wax at garage sales, for under $1.00 per pound, the hot wax is cheaper, even with the electric and when you figure in the double handling and time involved with AnchorSeal minus the loss I don't get with hot wax, I think the processing and cleanup is well worth the effort.
Mike, I WAS an AnchorSeal advocate for a long time. When I first started trying to preserve wood, cost was paramount. A $5.00 electric frying pan and $0.25 a pound scrap candles, even the pigmented ones were CHEAP and readily replaceable. As soon as my finances got better I bought a gallon at our club, then more, finally buying a 5 gallon can direct from the manufacturer. When I started losing as much as 90% of the wood I was covering (lost almost a whole load of curly walnut), I started doing a second coat. That improved things a great deal, but still not CLOSE to the 95.?% success I had always had with hot wax.
Leo, Thank you for the attaboy. I'm happy to do this, I think it will help. Especially beginners and people on a budget.
Bill, As I say in the video, waxing the whole piece of wood is rather like putting it back in the tree as no moisture escapes. If there are no dirty spalt spores in the wax, it also keeps the wood from spalting.
Rob, Your specifics are all dead on in my opinion. I have already broached some of the things you mention. As a film student, I think he thinks he knows more/better... In many cases, I'm certain that's true, but for the content we need, the suggestions that you and the rest have made are paramount. I'll be sure to get some closeup of that bikini line for you (wood perv ).
Drying wood is a water removal process, air circulation and evaporation will bring down MC over time. Completely sealing wood blank in wax does not allow or encourage water evaporating from wood. Wood will lose moisture from end grain 12 times faster than side grain. End sealing slows that water escaping too fast and prevent end checking and splitting.
Wood suppliers to woodturning and carving vendors completely seal wood in wax and do not worry about MC. They sell their wood by the pound. Most people selling wood to woodturning community do not guarantee MC. Some vendors may say their wood is partially dry, kiln dry, or wet.
I only end seal with wax when dealing with small quantities of spindle and bowl blanks. For pick-up load of freshly cut wood, will split and use latex paint to end seal. As wood dries it shrinks, wax end sealed blanks develop an air space between wax coatings. May or may not find mold growing there, wax may also crack or have holes too. Once MC of waxed seal logs below 25 % to 20% not much mold growth or end checking while bark still on. Some species of wood will not check if remove bark and wax end seal with MC of 20% in my area. Bradford Pear will, so do not rough turn until MC down to 12% to 15%.
Wax will not allow moisture to escape until some shrinking has occurred. Latex paint only slows down escape of moisture from end of blanks does not stop it completely. Latex sealed blanks will end check and split if not stored out of weather and direct sun light.
First, thanks for doing this! There was a lot of good information in the videos and I appreciate your willingness to share your knowledge with the woodturning community.
Second, in addition to some of the things others said about lighting, zooming in, and such, my only specific suggestion is to be more specific. Tell us (about) how deep the wax should be in the pan, what temperature setting you use, explain when you'd seal all sides of a blank and when you'd just seal the end grain (you explained why you seal all edges of a blank that has bark on it, but not the other stuff), etc. To you, this is old hat. To your audience, much of it is new. So, don't gloss over the details assuming your audience knows more than it does. Explain (virtually) everything without talking down to the viewer. That's a difficult thing to do, but, your video shows you have the talent to explain without talking down your nose at us. That's a real talent.
Third, have your "director" view two or three videos (each) from two or three of the better YouTube turning instructors. (My own list might include Bob Hamilton, Ed Davidson, and Cap'n Eddie.) As he watches the videos, have your director make a list of the five strengths and weaknesses of each of your "competitors". Watching the videos will give your director a better sense of the type of instructional video you'd like to produce and, if you mimic those strengths while avoiding those weaknesses, you'll produce some outstanding videos.