This question was asked on another board and I though I would get your opinions. for the way I use a lathe I would say the most of the time it doesn't matter. So I thought I would ask in what operations do you think it's critical?
When turning pens, the concentricity of the turned blank, and the very close tolerances make alignment critical for a good fit with the metal pen components.
Alignment is important to me during certain operations when I am turning boxes.
When I jam fit the lid on the body I always use the live center to provide a little extra support. If the tailstock is not properly aligned I will not have a concentric lid and this can be visible after the final shaping of the lid.
Likewise I use the tailstock and live center to reverse turn the bottom of the body of the box. Again, poor alignment will result in some lack of concentricity but it is not as important or apparent on the body as it is on the lid.
I also want to have alignment when I am turning miniature birdhouse ornaments.
It would depend on what you're turning. As already mentioned, pen turning and other disciplines (if that applies to styles of turning) that have close tolerances, it's crucial. Like anything, I think the best is better. Do I hardly ever really use the "high speed" pulley on my lathe, nope. Do I want a lathe without it? Nope. :-) If I was demonstrating on a lathe that had its tailstock off slightly, would I spend time, any time, in aligning it with shims? Nope. We all have our personal techniques and preferences. I think the best of something is better, but depending on the discipline, its importance varies.
To me a tailstock is pretty much the means to add some extra support while roughing or truing a bowl. Or for setting a bowl on a vacuum chuck. Do I want them to align? Yep. If they don't, I'm still turning. :-)
It seems in woodworking there is always a relative accuracy that begins to matter dependant on the circumstances and the scale. Someone who only turns bowls and does not drill using the tailstock may never notice one that is out, and I have found that many are.
One of the turning situations that always seems to require very accurate tailstock alignment is metal spinning. When using a compression stub to press the metal disc to the rotating form- if it isn�t concentric, it squeaks like crazy, and during a spinning class at a school a few years ago, only the lathe tailstocks of a certain color ran true.
If the bed of your lathe is not very rigid torsionally, having one foot of the lathe base not on the floor can cause the tailstock to be off center. It�s amazing what a little foot adjustment can do to correct it.
I would say any time that you are mounting a piece rigidly in chuck, a face plate or a pen mandrel and want to use the tail stock for either support or registration or accurate drilling. With spindle work between centers it would not be a problem.
As others have said, for a great deal of turning, it does not matter if the tail stock is perfectly aligned with the headstock. Any precision turning or drilling requires alignment as perfect as possible. For example, when turning a Chinese Ball, one has 12 primary holes to drill that must be as round as possible and this requires the tail stock to align as perfectly as possible. When turning bowls, I start them between the chuck face and the tail stock. Here is it very important to have perfect or near perfect alignment. Most spindle turning it will not make any difference.
Whenever I am making a thin finial for a christmas ornament or a two piece ornament where the two halves are cut, hollowed out and reglued. The finial will want to orbit a little especially when you are cutting it free near the tip. The two piece ornament never glues back to be on center. Of course, I usually will have one end in the scroll chuck and the tail center in the end for support.
The tailstock not being aligned not only makes for a creaking sound during spinning, it can make centering the disc under power a difficult if not impossible task.
I bought a double ended taper because the headstock on my Nova rotates. It was really hard to get it perfect every time without the double taper after swinging the headstock out.
I've leveled the lathe as best as I can, and the ways are as untwisted as I can manage without a machine shop. Its probably a few 1000ths out over the length of the ways, but I don't even know if it's possible to make it better with the crude screws it came with. I'd think you'd need a much finer thread to get that last 1000th.
S
P.S. It goes out the window the first time you have a large, out of balance blank on the lathe anyway...
As some have mentioned depending on what you are doing it can be critical, multi-axis turning, boxes, drilling, some spindle work can get ruined in a hurry with an out of alignment spindle. Even a large heavy lathe like my Powermatic 3520 can get the ways twisted if the lathe is not perfectly leveled. I use a Starett machinest level to work my ways in using a 3' metal machinest straight edge. If you are bowl turning, and not planning on using a lid, it is not as big a deal, although having the bed properly level with no twist will also cut down on vibration.
As has been said, drilling for peppermills or pens and turning pens, its pretty darned important. When turning bowls? Not so much. I use the tailstock for support for as long as I can but even when I go to remove the nub at the bottom, alignment is not critical.
While I'm not completely fanatical about it tail stock alignment is just as critical as headstock alignment for any operation that you are using the two in conjunction. It helps cut down on vibration which gives you the ability to true up a piece more quickly. Say you're working on a stacked lamination with lots of beads or coves & etc., if you're out of alignment by very much then your details won't match the edges of your lamination. Pretty soon a piece that should have been magnificent becomes a shame hidden in the reject pile to be burned later Even though probably no one but another turner would notice, you know they are there.
Only consideration not mentioned here today is cost of lathes today. My Jet lathe only cost $1,800 and have the ability to align head/tailstock myself by leveling. No head/tailstock alignment problems with old Grizzly, Delta, and Jet mini lathes.
If could not get head/tailstock in alignment would definitely want to know what manufacturer could do for me otherwise it would go back. Why? All the reasons already posted. Once you pay more than $1,000 for a wood lathe why settle for miss-aligned parts?
While spindle turning between two centers can be done regardless, most other turning has a need for the axis of the headstock to be co-linear (parallel) with the travel of the tailstock -
If the points of the drive center and the tail center are in perfect contact, and the point of the tailstock is not co-linear, it will be off more and more as the distance grows between the points.
By the way -- pen turning on a mandrel really want to be colinear and very close to having the points on the same line. Turning between centers without a mandrel makes the alignment much less critical.
Many (most?) lathes have enough "slop" in the ways that there is some difference between the position of the live center depending on if you push to the back when setting the clamp, or pull to the front when setting the clamp. Better consistency will happen if you use the same push/pull when setting the clamp on the tailstock. Not a huge difference but measurable on most lathes.
If you live with a lathe that has this misalignment for any length of time, you'll know the frustrations it can cause...particularly, if, like I was, you are so new to the game that you really don't know why you are having so much trouble. (Love my PM 3520!)
Ken Do you know how to check for that. I've tried to figure out a way but everything I can come up with at home is too sloppy. I think I need a #2 morse taper with a scope alignment laser in it.
John -- I have a Stubby (movable bed lathe) and I was wondering how to check alighment with a bed that slides and turns.
I startd with a fine high strength wire and dial indicator and then realized it was easier -
I use ER 32 collet chucks with a runout of about 0.002 (measured with a dial indicator) with a laser pointer (Scope checking laser would work too) in the collet. The colated beam is a little large but if it hits a pretty consistent pattern around the tailstock, I am good. Finer focus laset would allow precision measurement.
After messing a bit I found that this lathe has the bed in good alignment with the pen in place, and the alignment is closest to center if I push away a bit as I set the clamp.
The points do not line up perfectly -- there is about 30 thousands offset (about 1/32) that using the less than machinist precise measurements I used was consistent along the bed.
I compensate for that by assuring that I set the tailrest/live center and use it to anchor all items used in a chuck. It helps my process sense to try to keep evidence of the center for purpose of rechucking/remounting. I am just getting into boxes and lids so cannot comment there.
I have not noticed a particular problem with pens and a mandrel, but will note that I turn more and more of them between centers as well as peppermills and similar.
Collet Chuck and Laser will work --- I will have to try a scope sighting laser.
Ken I thought that might work but I've been balking at the price of a bore sight laser. I really do need one because I'm fussing with different scopes on my rifles right now and it would probably pay for itself in the savings on ammo.
I have looked at those which fit on the muzzle because of the dual purpose. The arbors which go into the muzzle will go into a collet chuck easily.
The better ones look to cost a couple hundred, (a couple lathe tools or a new Patriot chuck) though the cheap end is at about $25 (midway search). I should go there too -- the higher priced ones have better focus. And green laser.
I'm guessing that one of the double-ended 2MT tapers would help with aligning the headstock and tailstock. Many people who have rotating headstocks say it simplifies realigning the lathe when desired.