Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

The Disarming Possibilities of the Unexpected

Posts

The Disarming Possibilities of the Unexpected

#1

The Disarming Possibilities of the Unexpected

charlie belden

When I see "traditional" turned shapes and forms my reaction to an individual piece is biased by other similar pieces I've seen. I expect to see certain things having to do with the profile, fair curves, proportions and the like.

But when I see a piece that doesn't fit in with what I'm familiar with - something unexpected - it's disarming. I have nothing to compare it to. With no preconceived notions of good or bad, right or wrong - I've got only first impressions to go on. Is it interesting or not. Either way, I've got to THINK about WHY.

Think of what your brain went through the first time you saw one of Escoulen's pieces. Or one of Bin Pho's pieces. Or one of David Belser's pieces. Or one of Keith Holt's pieces, Or one of Graeme Priddles pieces. Or one of Alan Carter's suspended pieces. Or . . .

Have you done a piece that exploits the disarming nature of the unexpected, or have ideas for pieces that do? Care to share?

Re: The Disarming Possibilities of the Unexpected

#2

Well....

Dave Belser

I turned a simple bowl the other day and it scared the crap out of me! ;)

Something I observed / figured out that early on with traditional pieces was that stuff I made caused emotion, reaction maybe excitement but a definite physical and mental interaction. A product of my imagination that I had made real contained all of this power and completely without verbal dialog - (and I'm talking about bowls and tops with people that had little exposure to woodturning).

This was truly a profound new experience for me, although it seems obvious now, I was blown away by the power of these simple things I was making and the effect that they had on other people.

I started thinking about how to make powerful work that would excite people. Over time I've developed some meta-principles -

If you are not excited / passionate about your work why would you expect others to be? : work on things that your are passionate and excited about.

While we are all unique individuals, as humans we share a common sense of primitive perception - a smiley face : ) [not sideways] is almost universally recognized across language and cultures as a representation of a human face, we are programed to see faces.

This applies to strong and powerful experiences that you have had. Of course they are unique to you, but if you can express the emotion and power of the experience in a basic or more primitive way you will succeed in raising similar emotions / reactions in others based on there similar or even wildly different experiences and your work will be more "successful" (not using success in a judgmental or material way).

So I'm not sure about "disarming" - but engaging in as through a way as you can, put all of that passion emotion excitement into your work.

- Dave

Re: The Disarming Possibilities of the Unexpected

#3

Ellis Walentine

Primitive understanding

Ellis Walentine

I like your concept of the non-verbal, primitive reaction to visual stimuli that is at the root of every viewer's appreciation of a piece. I've long felt that, for whatever reason, our perceptions are tuned to certain frequencies, which can be reactions to individual aspects of a piece -- color, form, etc. -- and/or to various conjunctions of elements. It is the onus of the artist to imagine those elements and to render them effectively.

Great topic.

Ellis

Re: The Disarming Possibilities of the Unexpected

#4

Steven Antonucci

Mental gymnastics

steven antonucci

I am a fan of magic. I know that the coin hasn't violated some law of physics or a space time continuum, but I have to know how tricks are done. I have a box full of magic tricks that I can semi-pull off in front of a group of kids, but no long term goal of being a magician.

Turning is also the same way for me. If I see something that I can't immediately resolve how it was done, I need to know. I may never attempt such work, but I still have to know how I would if I wanted to. Whether or not I choose to push myself in that direction matters less to me than knowing that I know I can (maybe with 2 or 3 practice attempts).

So, disarming? Keith Holt and Derek Weidemann, yeah. Peter Exton, for sure. Art Liestman's thermed pieces? Keith Tompkins roses? Mike Foster's recent work?

Far too many ideas to deal with...for pieces that I will probably never attempt.

S

Re: The Disarming Possibilities of the Unexpected

#5

Re: The Disarming Possibilities of the Unexpected

John Lucas

Charlie Along those same lines are learning to appreciate the work or maybe a better term is understanding the concept. For example when you first see work by Picasso it's easy to be shocked and not like the work. However after you read up on him and find out how that work evolved you understand where he's coming from and then you are more likely to appreciate the work.

Of course there are two thoughts here. One is, you should be allowed to like or dislike the work base solely on the piece without any outside influences. I think that's your first impression, primal sort of thing that is based mostly on our individual backgrounds. The second thought is that are inclined to learn about the piece and the artist and then learn to appreciate the work.

Re: The Disarming Possibilities of the Unexpected

#6

Alan Zenreich

Re: Mental gymnastics

Alan Zenreich

Steve,

As a long time dilettante amateur magician (and both of my sons are magicians), I understand your desire to know how things are done, and appreciate the skill required... sometimes.

In "The Art of Astonishment", Paul Harris likens it to enjoying the sound of a vibrating tuning fork. But if you grab the fork the singing stops.

One of the reasons that magicians don't disclose their methods to non magicians is that the joy of the 'illusion' evaporates so quickly with the 'disillusion' that accompanies exposing the method.

So as much as I like knowing the methods used by various experts, there's a lot of pleasure in not knowing. Amazement, being full of wonder, and astonishment are actually nice feelings.

Unless of course, you're Vincent Laguardia Gambini (Gallo/Callo).

Re: The Disarming Possibilities of the Unexpected

#7

I've been turning for 25 yrs. and generally.....

JamieDonaldson

..have a previsualized concept of my turning projects. Several yrs. ago I made a winged form that came out just as conceived, but in the process of sanding discovered I had overlooked a hazardous part of the design accomplishment- how to get my fingers with sandpaper up under the wings to sand the round form! After I whacked my knuckles a few times the solution appeared in a flash of inspiration- sandpaper on a stick!

Re: The Disarming Possibilities of the Unexpected

#8

Mike Mills

Re: The Disarming Possibilities of the Unexpected

Mike Mills

As Allen Z. stated�.

�So as much as I like knowing the methods used by various experts, there's a lot of pleasure in not knowing. Amazement, being full of wonder, and astonishment are actually nice feelings.�

To quote Judge Haller ��That is a lucid, intelligent, well thought-out objection.�

And while I may not appreciate Picasso, I find Mona Lisa (Vito) terrific.

Re: The Disarming Possibilities of the Unexpected

#9

Alan Zenreich

Re: The Disarming Possibilities of the Unexpected

Alan Zenreich

Mike,

Keep in mind that his final say on that particular objection was "Overruuuuuuuled" < vbg >

Re: The Disarming Possibilities of the Unexpected

#10

Steven Antonucci

Yeah, but my head would explode if I didn't...

steven antonucci

figure it out on my own. I only buy the ones I can't get through analysis.

I do have a handful of tricks that I can do reasonably well. Someday, I will do kids birthday parties dressed as a clown. I can also make balloon animals, but only if you like snakes.

S

Re: The Disarming Possibilities of the Unexpected

#11

Re: Primitive understanding

charlie belden

David:

Your first statement would have caused a Spit Take, had I a mouthful of liquid when I read it. Had I no familiarity with your works the response would probably have been more quizzical - simple AND scary? I don't get it.

As to evoking/provoking physical and/or emotional responses - research indicates that about 85% of what we "see" (perceive) did NOT come from the receptors in our eyes but rather by associations to the incoming 15% that connect it with information already stored in other parts of the brain.

A brain researcher hypothesizes that all art is the brain attempting to externalize itself. Looking at microscopic images of brain tissue - and a Jackson Pollock painting - seems to support that hypothesis. And Munch's The Scream would support the hypothesis as well.

If being passionate about an idea is the same as a compulsion, the brain compelled to try and get what's going on within it - outside, this

Externalization hypothesis would fit.

Ellis:

Recent brain research supports your premise that we all have a semi-universal Built In sense of aesthetics - which - is not limited to just "beauty".

A study was set up to attempt to quantitatively examine how the experiment's subjects brains reacted to seeing - and classifying as "like" or "dislike" - images - after seeing an image for only a second. The subjects were college students made up of equal numbers of Art Majors, Engineering Majors, Psychology Majors and Math/Science Majors. The pool of candidate images for the experiment were taken from photos - of paintings in major art collections, old Brownie Camera snap shots and from a book "100 of the Worst Post Cards". The images were "normalized" using PhotoShop tools that displays a "histogram" of the visual data - distribution of light and dark, brightness and contrast, etc. images too far from the average values of the entire candidate images sample were thrown out.

The researches measured not only the "like" and "dislike" responses, but also the time it took for the visual cortex to react to the image as well as the time taken to press the "like" or "dislike" button. The Art Major's button pressing took slightly longer than for the other subjects in the experiment, indicating additional time to associate the visual data received in the visual cortex with already "learned" data stored elsewhere in the brain.

The images that the experiment's subjects identified as "liked" were almost the same, the Art Major's "likes" only slightly different from the rest of the subjects.

The study concluded that it's likely that or sense of aesthetics is predominately built in and that formal aesthetic training plays a minor role in what we "like".

There's even a branch of neuro science that is investigating our sense of aesthetics - appropriately called neuroaesthetics. Google the term and you'll be surprised out how much of our sense of aesthetics is not a conscious thing.

On a related note - having to do with how our visual attention works - here's a sample pair of images a Russian researcher used for studying just that. Note that with faces, the attention concentrates on the eyes - whereas with the forest scene with bears it's the bears that get the most attention, the darker areas getting most of the rest of the attention - and the light areas getting almost none.

If you're gonna work in a visual art, knowing this type of stuff - and using it - might lead to more interesting pieces.