Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Finishing the bottom ...

Posts

Finishing the bottom ...

#1

Finishing the bottom ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

David DeCristoforo just posted pictures of a spectacular piece with comments about advice he had gotten from a collector. So as not to detract from David's excellent work nor hijack, I decided to start a new thread.

First a suggestion: If a noted collector or turner offers an opinion or suggestion about your work, LISTEN! Let your emotions take a walk as you consider what you have been told. I had such a person point out some scratch marks on a box that I had made. I thought the marks were on the surface of the finish and he suggested that they were sanding marks. Either way, I have worked hard since then to avoid sanding marks and I have been rewarded accordingly.

To the point: I am getting ready to make some bowls since my "celebration gouge" is about to arrive. I have made many natural-edged bowls from red oak and ambrosia maple. Each has had a simple ring as a base and I think that it is time for me to "step up" and do something on the bottom that is more interesting.

What treatment do you suggest for the base of a natural-edged bowl that would add a little class and not be plain-jane?

Ed

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

#2

Example, needing a better bottom

Ed Moore in SW VA

This sold quickly, but I would have liked a more interesting bottom treatment.


Ed

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

#3

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

John Lucas

Ed I'm still in a quandry about this. I've turned bowls with no foot, a rebate so it sits flat and I can sign it inside. I've usually prefer a smaller foot than what you have pictured. I want the bowl suspended but just enough to keep it from looking grounded on the table. I have also tried the other extreme with a foot that is several inches tall. I still don't know what's the best and I'll bet it will look like the argument over skew shapes, everyone will have a different opinion. In the top photo the foot is pretty non intrusive when viewed from normal angles. It still gives the foot some lift.

In the box elder bowl I wanted the foot to be part of the composition so I made it much larger (compared to the size of the bowl) so your eye goes there as well as to the bowl. The tapered shape helps give more lift to the bowl and sort of looks like a pedestal presenting the bowl to you. I've tried tube shaped feet at this height and they look very bland.

remember these aren't particularly functional bowls. If I was making a cereal bowl it would have a much wider foot to make the bowl stable.



Re: Finishing the bottom ...

#4

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

David Walser

Ed,

For a natural edged bowl, I prefer a round bottom to the bowl -- no foot and no depression to allow the bowl to sit stable on the table. I feel a natural edge bowl is more for display rather than actual use, so I don't mind that the bowl rocks a little when it's touched. Indeed, I think that's one of the bowl's charms. It allows the viewer to interact with the bowl more fully. The person can, like a regular bowl, pick the bowl up and caress the curve and feel the silky smoothness of the wood. In addition, the person can get th bowl to spin, rock, and wobble with a gentle tap of a finger. I think this type of finish to the bottom emphasizes the "natural" aspects of the bowl. It's as if the bowl was ripped out of the side of a tree and formed by nature.

That's my preference. My wife's preference is for a high foot/pedestal that lifts the bowl off the table an inch or two into the air. (The height would depend on the size of the bowl.) The foot would be set off from the bowl with a small bead and then flare out in an ogee shaped curve. Her feeling is this size and shape foot shows off the bowl to its best advantage.

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

#5

Steven Antonucci

Technical vs. aesthetic recommendations

steven antonucci

I read David's post as the collector felt that the bottom of his piece was aesthetically unappealing. I have no issue with someone pointing out sanding scratches or tearout, as I do it myself to encourage better work.

However, to suggest that the bottom was plain or aesthetically an issue in such a way that David posted it as "the collector went off" causes me consternation. While the collector has a right to his/her opinion about the piece (which they exercise by either buying it or not buying it), I found it somewhat sanctimonious that the collect should feel the need to influence a maker (whether they were a potential customer or not).

The main issue (aside from the "implied expertise" from someone who may have never turned) is that the collector is now influencing the maker outside of the maker's own creative process and experience. If David comes to the realization that he needs to do something with the foot of the piece without inside influence, it is far more valid than trying to appease the collector.

I make things that I want to make. You buy things that you have to have. When the two intersect, we have a sale. When they don't, they don't. It's wrong of the collector to try to color David's work with his experience, IM(NS)HO.

That said, I hate footed bowls. I wouldn't have one at all.

Steven

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

#6

I have a personal "signature style" ......

JamieDonaldson

..foot that I often place on many of my bowls, not necessarily natural edge pieces. It consists of a small step ring at the transition of the foot to bowl form, and is usually about 1/3 the size of the height of the foot. You are welcome to copy it without payment of royalties!!! :D

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

#7

Mike Stafford

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

Mike Stafford

I don't have a picture of what I am going to describe because I don't have it on this computer.

I like a little raised bead at the bottom of the bowl immediately adjacent to a slightly concave foot similar to what Jamie has pictured. Inside the foot I like to shape a dome that intimates a continuation of the curve of the bowl.

Let us see what you come up with....

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

#8

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

Wally Dickerman

A lot of folks who turn pieces copying SW style pottery don't realize that the the ancient pottery always had round bottoms. If you want the piece to stand upright, just a small dimple turned on the bottom will be all that is needed.

I agree that the appearance of the bottom of a bowl is important. Just watch any turner who picks up a a bowl. First thing they do is turn it over and look at the bottom. An attractive design helps the overall appearance of the piece.

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

#9

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

David DeCristoforo

I ran a woodworking shop for many years, working closely with designers and architects. One of the first things I learned was that ego has no place in these relationships. A co-worker and good friend put it this way. If your ego prevents you from recognizing that your vocabulary could be expanded, your vocabulary will never expand.

Mr. Antonucci's quoted axiom that "Those who can, turn. Those who can't, collect." may contain a kernel of truth. But it is also a potential pitfall to close one's mind to what can be either constructive or negative input depending on how it is construed by the receiver. I could have easily allowed my ego to intervene, telling myself that there is no need to worry about the undersides of my turnings, most of which have been left raw after parting off. I might have even gone as far as to see this as a "signature" element, expressing distain for something "beneath" the higher concerns of form, proportion, balance and color.

What I chose to do was to realize that there will be those who will want to look at the undersides of my pieces and who will be disappointed to see rough, unfinished or minimally finished surfaces. So I went ahead and detailed the bottom of my pedestal. I allowed for the possibility that I might end up feeling that this was a waste of time and energy that would be better spent starting a new piece. But I find now, that I am taking some delight in knowing that there is more there than what meets the eye and that the person who looks at the underside of this piece will have a pleasant surprise.

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

#10

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

Lyle Jamieson

The responses and question are confusing. We need to be more specific about what we are refering to. 1)The foot would be the shape of the bowl (or hollow form)where it meets the table. The foot can be big, small, short , tall, detailed, simple. 2) the bottom is the area under the foot that you must pick up the bowl to see. This should be finished to the same standards as the rest of the vessel. It can have detail or be relatively plain. It can be concave or convex (wabble bowl) The piece you made (Hydria Palissandro) has significant detail in the foot and the bottom.

I prefer to do my talking with the bottom with minimal detail to tell that it was reverse turned and sanded and finished perfectly. It does not have to be glitzy to show significant class.

The foot I prefer to have rather small. Most of my pieces are non functional and thin so a small foot communicates a consistant message of fragile and light.

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

#11

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

Don at Central Illinois

While on vacation in Georgia a couple of weeks ago I got to meet and talk with Terry Daniel. He showed me a number of his signature pieces. Most, if not all of his has a recess for expanding chucks and this is where he dates, signs, etc. He leaves the recess sanded but unfinished to show the wood before any oil, lacquer, etc. finish. i may even copy that to leave a little 'natural' wood to show contrast to the finish.

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

#12

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

Lan Brady

Don,

That is so coincidental as I have read this thread. I was comparing everyones comments to what I learned from Terry 6 years ago. His foot design elevates the piece where it looks delicate, but still gives enough mass to be functional.

I have tried (unsuccessful) to duplicate his foot design.

You are very fortunate to meet and talk with Terry.

Lan

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

#13

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

Carole Valentine

I use the same style on nearly every bowl...a very slight foot with an ogee to add a little elegance.

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

#14

Steven Antonucci

A few clarifications to my post

steven antonucci

Mr. Antonucci? No need to be so formal...

A few things that I think have gotten misinterpretted in my/your post.

1.) You suggested that the collector wasn't presenting the suggestion in a positive manner. If that was my misinterpretation, I apologize. If it was a negative critique, it has little value. A good critique occurs when the maker is the one who "gets it without being hit over the head".

2.) I also believe that finishing the bottom is a really good idea. I never suggested that a parting cut and 80 grit sanding was enough. I probably wouldn't have said "this is bad, you should be ashamed" but I may have asked you how you would chuck it to undercut a bead. The difference is that I give you the choice to take the advice and pursue it if you choose to, not a mandate to change to appease a collector.

3.) Opinions and egos. I think this is an interesting topic. I have met a couple of collectors who buy stuff because it was made by someone with a name. Some of these collectors know almost nothing about turning, and are merely following "the pack". Having money doesn't mean having taste. Owning a big collection doesn't make you an expert on anything. Anyone can buy a Picasso.

So, my read of your post was that a collector, who positioned himself as an expert about turning, critiqued your work negatively. I wonder if the critique was aimed at helping you improve your work, or if it was aimed at letting you know that he was a big, important collector?

If the collector lost interest in your work because it wasn't finished underneath, perhaps there was a shred of usefulness in his advice...

S

P.S. I have an ego, but it's nowhere near as big as most people give me credit for. I work in sales for a living, and I spend all day talking to people with opinions, some less valid than others. If you aren't interested in the work as it is, you can still have an opinion, and I can choose to either make one to your spec, or not.

P.P.S. Take input, but also make sure you understand the source (including here)

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

#15

Re: A few clarifications to my post

David DeCristoforo

Well OK... Steve, I was not trying to be critical. And I apologize if I misunderstood your comments. The thing is, I really did not care what the motive was behind the opinion. It was a good point either way. If the guy got a jolt out of it, well... maybe he needs more fun in his life or something! When I said that the criticism could "be either constructive or negative input depending on how it is construed", what I was trying to say is that there was some good advice there regardless of the intent of the one offering it. Anyway, FWIW, this person is not only a collector but a highly skilled turner as well. I've only been at this for about fourteen months so I still have much to learn. The "going off" was good natured but very much in the "aw comeon.... you gotta be kidding!" vein. It's not like I changed my methods to please but more that I realized that I needed to pay more attention to these "details" if I ever hope to become as good as I would like to become.

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

#16

Re: A few clarifications to my post

Carol Reed, Strawberry, AZ

OK. Now I am totally blown away. First, that perfectly gorgeous piece that started this thread. Then, you've 'only' been at this for 14 months! And you hope to be better at it. Would that we all aimed that high! I humbly stand in awe of you, kind sir.

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

#17

Steven Antonucci

Must be those Glasers, huh?

steven antonucci

The work you are producing in your first year of turning is simply stunning. Can it be better? I don't know.

We bat around the topic of influence and copying ad nauseum around here. A lot of people will tell you copying is good. The same number of people will tell you copying is bad. Filtering data is part of your own experience. I know of a turner who I had some influence over, who now has some following. I feel sort of good that he listened, but also sort of bad that I had to browbeat him into doing it (and I did...)

In the end, I used data that I filtered and hardcoded it into his work. It would have been better for him to have that "come to religion moment" on his own.

I'll repeat for Ed's sake: I HATE FOOTED BOWLS. ;)

S

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

#18

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

woodspinner-Harry Robinette

I always put a couple rings or small beads on the bottom of most of my work. I don't finish the bottoms I only put a coat of wax on them,most of my bowl work is done green wood to finish piece and I've found that I get allot less cracking if I let the bottom only waxed so the wood can breath. I know allot of you say the wood wont breath but whatever it does it works for me.

We all have to take criticism good,bad or indifferent and ether let it go by or use it to are own advantage. If you take everyones criticism the same way you well never find yourself in you work only what others wont your work to be.

As always just my $.02

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

#19

karl jr

that's nice peice of exposition

karl jr

well done.. To take criticism constructively is a virtue. To make something from it is even better. BTW that's an outstanding piece of work you shared with us.

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

#20

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

charlie belden

Charles Loloma, a Hopi jeweler, often put the most interesting parts of his rings in bracelets on the underside or inside - where only the wearer would know the that the best was out of sight.

Cindy Drozda sometimes puts a small gem in the underside of her lidded boxes - o using a single earring - the gem in a four or six prong setting.

Incorporating the unexpected in a piece means walking a fine line - between a gimmick and an enhancement.

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

#21

Re: Finishing the bottom ...

Terry Scott

Just my preference but I like 3 feet with the curve of the bowl flowing through in one continuous curve This method I use on 90% of the burls I turn gives them great lift and adds to the overall quality



Or if not that then a round bottom