Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Hydria Palissandro

Posts

Hydria Palissandro

#1

Hydria Palissandro

David DeCristoforo

I spent the 4th of July (and part of the 2nd and 3rd as well) making another in the seemingly endless "Amphora" series. Every one I have done so far has been colored in some way and I really wanted to do a natural wood version of this. I have enough of a grip on the techniques involved that I was willing to risk some expensive wood. So I dug into my precious small stash of rosewood burl and ebony for this one. Man that stuff is hard! I used the Glaser 15V gouge for most of the heavy cutting and it did perform admirably. I was compelled to make a trip to the grinder halfway through but the last time I turned anything from this rosewood burl, I spent more time sharpening than I did turning. And it's heavy too. Even with the walls down to 1/8" there is still a noticeable heft to this piece. I was tempted to go thinner but the last time I tried that the piece ended up shattering. Hard, dense and dry add up to brittle!

When I posted pics of the last one, Kelly Dunn suggested an emulation of the form body in the embellishment in the stem instead of a sphere. So I thought I would give that a go. Also, I recently had a chance to have one of these examined by a "well known collector" (who shall remain unnamed). He had a lot of nice things to say about the piece but he went totally off on me about the finish (or lack thereof) on the underside of the pedestal base. So I decided to pay a bit more attention to that area on this piece.

All in all I am pleased with the way this "turned out" The detailing of the bottom is probably what I am the most stoked on right now. I have never even given a thought to putting this much work into the underside of a base. Usually just a light sanding and a bit of whatever I finish the piece with. But now I'm hooked on that too so there are a few more hours to be factored into each piece!

This is 4.25" wide at the rim and 15.5" tall. There is no finish, just wax and polish. I just love the way rosewood and ebony polish up.


Re: Hydria Palissandro

#2

Keith Tompkins

Re: Hydria Palissandro

Keith Tompkins

Nice work David. Try inverting the bead as well.

Re: Hydria Palissandro

#3

Re: Hydria Palissandro

ihmserv

very nice, both in balance and form, how stable is this piece?

will you be worried about a breeze blowing it over.

IAN

Re: Hydria Palissandro

#4

Barb Siddiqui

Oh, my goodness. Stunning.

Barb Siddiqui

Re: Hydria Palissandro

#5

Steven Antonucci

Not to hijack, but the collector went off?

steven antonucci

I think the piece is wonderful, but I was sort of scratching my head when you mentioned that the famous collector "went off on you" because of a lack of finish on the bottom of the base? I had a similar situation where I had a famous collector suggest that I change my finish to appeal to collectors.

I thought about it for a minute. I didn't say the words that came into my head, but I think my body may have suggested that he performed an unnatural act upon himself.

I think it is one thing for a turner to critique another turner's work because we CAN DO the work (at least in theory), but what right does a collector have to tell a turner how the final productshould be made? It would be like me buying a book on famous painters and then telling Michelangelo to paint bunnies because I like bunnies (or I read about bunnies in a book).

If the "went off" was overstated, I apologize for overreacting. There's a saying:

Those who can, turn.

Those who can't, collect.

S

Re: Hydria Palissandro

#6

Re: Hydria Palissandro

Randy Gleckler

That is very very beautiful.

Re: Hydria Palissandro

#7

Re: Hydria Palissandro

Scott in Falcon

Wow! I really like the form and how delicate it looks. I don't know if I could display a piece like that in my house though - I have kids! I'd be constantly nagging them to walk softly past the display cabinet! :)

Re: Hydria Palissandro

#8

Spectacular!

Ed Moore in SW VA

David, I like every detail of the piece. And the collector did you a big favor. The bottom of the base you showed is consistent with the quality of the overall piece. As shown, the piece is a 10. If the bottom of the base were merely concave, then the piece would have been an 8.5. You obviously have the ability to operate at the 10 level. Good job!

Ed

Re: Hydria Palissandro

#9

Re: Not to hijack, but the collector went off?

Greg in Oshkosh

I think it's OK for the customer to tell you what they might like to see in the design or finish (like shiny or dull or suggest a slightly different shape) They are entitled to their opinions. The should not tell you how to achieve that shape or finish. No one really cares if you sanded it to shape or used a gouge. Now, you may choose not to follow their suggestions, cause you feel differently. Just ask them how much more they would pay for one like they suggested.

Re: Hydria Palissandro

#10

Re: Not to hijack, but the collector went off?

David Walser

Steve,

With all due respect, I don't think there's much correlation between the talent to turn and the talent known as a sense of design. Some turners, unless they are copying someone else's design, produce absolutely ugly work. Their pieces are out of proportion, the curves don't flow smoothly, and any decorations they add seem to subtract from the beauty of the piece. Yet, these same turners might have no faults in terms of their ability to turn a bead or produce a silky finish on a turned object. They just lack a sense of design.

On the other hand, some people who've never stood at a lathe can tell you the difference between a simply timeless shape and something that's only fit for the fire. Some of these people are collectors. They know what they like and can usually explain in detail why a subtle difference makes one piece vastly superior to another. When such people speak, we can learn a lot if we'll just listen.

Note: I'm not saying all collectors (or even most of them) have a sense of design. Nor am I saying a turner with great technical skills cannot also have a sense of design. I'm simply pointing out one doesn't have to be a turner to recognize beauty. Nor should one have to be a turner to speak authoritatively on the subject.

Re: Hydria Palissandro

#11

gorgeous!

GaryG in MD

I was amazed when I saw the dimensions.

Great work! ...Gary