Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

An unsolicited and non-commercial message...

Posts

An unsolicited and non-commercial message...

#1

An unsolicited and non-commercial message...

GaryG in MD

When I heard Keith Tompkins describe the new tool he was developing, the "V Skew", on WC some time ago, I was skeptical. Why should it be better or different from what we're already using? Wishful thinking? No. Not from Keith. He's a level-headed guy, and I trust his judgement...

So I get to St. Paul, and there's Keith demonstrating his new tool. Man, it really works. Very slick. Looks easy. I buy one and bring it home. Got to try it for the first time yesterday. I did the right thing when I bought it. This is one sweet tool.

My relationship with skews is jittery at best -- I use them when I have to, but never with real comfort -- I know the theory and have seen plenty of demos and videos, but I still get too many unexpected spirals that I'm not even sure why they happened after the fact.

This tool is bulletproof. It will do pretty much anything you need a skew for, but I had to really push the envelope to get it to misbehave. I can use this tool and relax and still get results. Facing off end grain with either a skew or spindle gouge can be a little iffy -- the starting cut for the latter, and along the way with the former. This tool gets off to a firm and decisive start on either side of the edge and just keeps on trucking to the center. And it'll do all the other cuts too.

I'm just saying... one happy user.

And it comes in two sizes...

...Gary

Re: An unsolicited and non-commercial message...

#2

Re: An unsolicited and non-commercial message...

Terry Quiram

Do you have any pictures of the tool?

Re: An unsolicited and non-commercial message...

#4

Rob Wallace

Re: An unsolicited and non-commercial message... *LINK*

Rob Wallace

Looks like Dave doubled-up on the 'http://' in the link provided....

I hope the link below works OK...

Rob


Tompkins 3/4" skew at Packard Woodworks

Re: An unsolicited and non-commercial message...

#5

JL

How does this differ from Raffan's Spear point?? *LINK*

JL

Seems similar.


Raffan's Spear Point tool

Re: An unsolicited and non-commercial message...

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: How does this differ from Raffan's Spear point

Keith Tompkins

Hi Gary, thanks for the kind words!


Hi JL, Raffan's spearpoint is a scraper, meant to create details in the base of a bowl, etc. My tool is a true skew chisel; however, I use only one bevel, not two. Why? I believe so many people have trouble with a conventional skew because the geometry is all wrong. It has two bevels so it can be used in a right and left hand direction; it's a compromise so two separate tools aren't needed. Now, how many other turning tools use two bevels? Not many. How many other turning tools give so many turners fits? Again, not many. I came up with the hypothesis that the double bevel was the culprit. To test this hypothesis, I did two things...I ground a single bevel skew, then a double bevel gouge. Guess what...the single bevel skew behaved like a dream, but the double bevel gouge was uncontrollable. (try it for yourself) Now, my dilemma was how to create a single bevel skew that cut both directions....the answer was to grind the the other side as well; now both grinds meet in the middle.

If you look at my image above, you will see the difference in geometry between a single and double-bevel skew...you cannot change the way the top bevel approaches the turning on a conventional skew until the grind is perpendicular to the turning. On the single bevel skew, the tool cuts just like a gouge..raise the handle, it cuts deeper, roll it, it behaves just like you would expect. No catches, even when you slide the tool along the entire cutting edge, right up to the point during the cut. Even not looking. Even with your eyes closed.

Does it really work? Many turners tried their hand at it during the symposium...every one who tried could use the tool. Every one, even those who were afraid of the skew. No catches, either. Surprisingly, several big-name turners purchased the tool as well after watching how it worked.

A turner such as yourself who uses a skew chisel on a regular basis will be amazed how easily the tool handles; you can watch the horizon as the shape develops without even thinking of a catch...your turning improves as a result.

Re: An unsolicited and non-commercial message...

#7

Re: An unsolicited and non-commercial message...

robo hippy

I am no skew chisel expert, but when watching it being used, it looked like a beefed up Sorby Spindle Master that was triangular on the tip, instead of round. The Spindle master would work if it was made out of half round stock. A good idea, just made wrong.

robo hippy

Re: An unsolicited and non-commercial message...

#8

JL

Thanks for the explanation.

JL

I guess I'll have to go somewhere where I can see one. Anyplace in Georgia or Western North Carolina anytime soon? Such as Turning Southern Style at Unicoi?

Re: An unsolicited and non-commercial message...

#9

Re: How does this differ from Raffan's Spear point

John Lucas

Keith I don't understand the single bevel concept. I have a bedan than has a single bevel. It doesn't act any different than my skew. How would the wood know that the tool only has one bevel or two? I'm not saying you don't have a great tool I just don't see how the wood can know the difference.

Maybe I need to drive up and do a video of you using the tool. I need a vacation.

Re: An unsolicited and non-commercial message...

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: How does this differ from Raffan's Spear point

Keith Tompkins

HI John, I can put you up...AND I need a video :D With the skew, you are dealing with three planes...the lower bevel, the upper bevel, and the tool itself. On a single bevel skew, only two, the tool shaft and the bevel. The geometry, or approach angle, is not the same. My v-skew behaves exactly like a gouge to user inputs, but cuts like a skew. No spiral cuts if the user comes off the bevel. You'll have to try one!

Re: An unsolicited and non-commercial message...

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: An unsolicited and non-commercial message...

Keith Tompkins

Robo, Did you see this at St. Paul? If you did, you should have introduced yourself..I would have been glad to meet you!

Re: An unsolicited and non-commercial message...

#12

Alan Zenreich

Re: How does this differ from Raffan's Spear point

Alan Zenreich

Keith,

I have some pretty good video and audio equipment... let's talk this weekend about making a video of your tool in use.

Re: An unsolicited and non-commercial message...

#13

Re: An unsolicited and non-commercial message...

robo hippy

Yea, I did see it at the Symposium. I just sat back and watched. Some one was turning some oak pieces, don't know if that was you or not. I don't do much spindle work myself, but I can almost fake it with a skew.

You may remember me, 60ish, balding, bearded, bit of a turning muscle.... Oh, wait, that is about 1/4 or more of the turners there.

robo hippy

Re: An unsolicited and non-commercial message...

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: An unsolicited and non-commercial message...

Keith Tompkins

Yeah, that was me! Turning oak just for the challenge! I think I remember you! :D

Re: An unsolicited and non-commercial message...

#15

Keith Tompkins

Re: How does this differ from Raffan's Spear point

Keith Tompkins

Hi Alan.....good deal!

Re: An unsolicited and non-commercial message...

#16

1/4th    I'd say 2/3rds

john lucas