Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Go for the color - or - the contrast?

Posts

Go for the color - or - the contrast?

#1

Go for the color - or - the contrast?

charlie belden

I've got some recently cut olive branches. This is the first piece I'm playing with. - some nice figured heartwood surrounded by almost white, featureless sapwood. Here's my classic dilema.

I can leave the light sapwood which contrasts nicely with the dark, figured heartwood and pinch in the top that'll show the heartwood

or

I can turn away almost all of the sapwood and show much more darker heartwood - but on a smaller piece.

Been reading about how our sense of sight prioritizes what to focus our attention on. Movement seems to have the highest priority - which makes sense since moving things may be coming at you - to eat you - or run you over. Next to focus attention on is contrast/edge detection. We can pick up even a 2% change in gray. Handy if you want to pick our an antelope or deer from its background - or that tiger crouched in the reeds - staring at YOU. Lower on the attention scale are EYES - if present, And they don't have to be actual eyes - just something that looks like it might be an eye or eyes. Then it's shape/form - is that a rock - or something that might be edible. At the lower end of what grabs our visual attention is color - is it ripe enough to eat?

Anyone playing in the visual arts should really do some reading on how our eyes work and how our brain interprets the information our eyes provide.

While olive heartwood is really visually interesting, I'm leaning heavily towards leaving as much of the light sapwood and go for CONTRAST.

What would YOU do - and why?


Re: Go for the color - or - the contrast?

#2

Re: Go for the color - or - the contrast?

GaryG in MD

Charlie,

There are obviously many possible answers. Here's mine:

As much as I like the beautiful patterns in the heartwood, and acknowledge that they would make a fine piece without the sapwood, I'd go for the max size and contrast.

I'd turn it with the small end at the top and let the presently exposed heartwood cascade down the side of the white sapwood like melting fudge. The circle of heartwood on the bottom will act as a "base" of sorts.

Great piece of wood.

...Gary

Re: Go for the color - or - the contrast?

#3

Re: Go for the color - or - the contrast?

John Veerkamp

I really like the contrast.

Re: Go for the color - or - the contrast?

#4

Steven Antonucci

Purposeful composition

steven antonucci

In looking at the piece of wood, I might have started with something shorter, and perhaps even with the pith perpendicular to the lathe axis. I struggle with this issue when I turn cherry. I want the light on top, and the darker on the bottom, but I can't get there with an end grain orientation unless I am turning a crotch.

With the beautiful grain that I have seen in olive, I think this might work out pretty nicely. Having a band of white around the vessel as you do now doesn't work for me. I'd probably turn it down to all heartwood to unify it.

Steve

Re: Go for the color - or - the contrast?

#5

Re: Purposeful composition

charlie belden

Orienting the pith line at 90s to the axis of the lathe is common when turning bowls - the differential shrinkage causing the pith line to remain higher than outsides of the original half log blank.

Putting the pith line 90s to the axis of the lathe - and half way down the side of a vase or other hollow form seems to be asking for trouble - which would come in the form of cracking and splitting radiating out from the pith. Given that this is a recently cut section of branch - that's pretty wet - differential shrinkage is the enemy - regardless of how the blank is oriented.

All that aside - dark at the top and bottom with lighter separating them would provide two areas of abrupt contrast - regardless of the setting of the piece - light or dark background. The eye would thus be drawn to the piece - focusing attention on it and pulling it out of the background surrounding it.

A darker, all heartwood piece would stand out and catch the eye - if it's set in a much lighter background environment - the contrast being between the darker piece and the lighter background. If the piece were set off by itself in a light background this would work well. But given that pieces are usually amongst other things I think it would take some pretty dramatic grain/figure to grab attention. Going with All Heartwood might hold one's interest with its figure and dark colors - once visually pulled out of the background.

About Light On Top: Dark On Bottom vs Dark On Top: Light On Bottom

Light On Top seems to me to provide some "lift" to the piece, Dark On Bottom "anchoring" it to earth.

On the other hand, Dark On Top, Light On Bottom could pose a visually paradox - the dark - which might seem "heavy" - floating above the surface - somehow suspended would be interesting.

I think Russ Fairfield addressed the issue of Light On Top or Dark On Top thing in an article on turning design.

Re: Go for the color - or - the contrast?

#6

Re: Purposeful composition

Cindy Drozda

Hollow vessels turned with the pith through the cross axis work just fine with a lot of species of wood. The hollowing takes care of the problems of shrinkage when drying. I've done it with good success. My guess is that olive will respond well and look great!