Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Tracy Owen Finishing Tool Video *LINK*

Posts

Tracy Owen Finishing Tool Video *LINK*

#1

Tracy Owen Finishing Tool Video *LINK*

john lopez

Has anybody tried one of these tools yet?

From my corner of the peanut gallery the

round vs flat stock idea seems reasonable.

Making a shop made scraper thicker and stronger

this way seems like it would reduce vibration and chatter

considerably in some situations.

Ellis,

I'm having trouble posting this link.

The second portion of it isn't working.

I tried to delete it but the second portion does not show up

in the edit window.

link

http://www.woodturnerscatalog.com/store/Turning_Tools___Special_Purpose_Tools___Tracy_Owen_Fine_Finishing_Tools___htt_tracy_owen?Args=


http://http://www.woodturnerscatalog.com/store/Turning_Tools___Special_Purpose_Tools___Tracy_Owen_Fine_Finishing_Tools___htt_tracy_owen?Args=http://www.woodturnerscatalog.com/store/Turning_Tools___Special_Purpose_Tools___Tracy_Owen_Fine_Finishing_Too

Re: Tracy Owen Finishing Tool Video *LINK*

#2

Re: Tracy Owen Finishing Tool Video

ronnyeelen

I do have a set. And yes, they work well.

I think the fact that the working edge is in the center of the tool helps. And the rounded bottom side makes tilting a natural thing to do.

I do put a burr on them, and use them shear scraping mode.

(Is it rude to start each sentence with I?)

Ronny

Re: Tracy Owen Finishing Tool Video *LINK*

#3

Re: Tracy Owen Finishing Tool Video

john lucas

I don't think it's rude to start each sentence with an I. I did. I think these are interesting tools. I made one years ago. I had a left hand and right hand flat scraper that I made. I saw these and needed a beefier round one so I built one.

I have 2 other flat round scrapers that I use. I didn't see any advantage other than mass. I now have a very thick Henry Taylor that I like a lot. So much so I gave away the round one. The HT is also quite wide but I've never had any problem tilting it. It's never been a problem at all to tilt the scrapers. In fact I use John Jordan's flat scraper a lot and at first I was worried because it's cutting edge is so long. No problems at all.

These are probably fabulous tools and if you don't own any good scrapers I'd get them. However I don't think they have any advantages unless they are thicker than the ones your now using.

Re: Tracy Owen Finishing Tool Video *LINK*

#4

Re: I see your point

ronnyeelen

I see your point.

I however, I was never very good at handling a scraper so when I saw these, and I was still tool minded then but I stopped being that, I thought what a good idea.

I could be mislead but I no longer have a problem using scrapers, or at least no longer do I feel uncomfortable.

I find it not always easy to start a sentence with I, when you try to make a point of it.

I 's pronounciation is 'aai' when written in Flemish. Aai is from the verb 'aaien' which means 'to pet', like 'to pet a dog'. See how this one also starts with I but then in written Flemish. I find myself being more fluent with words when writing then when speaking. I am actually rather shy, that is 'shaai' when the pronounciation is written in Flemish. I however, do not know of any correct Flemish word that is written like that.

I

Re: Tracy Owen Finishing Tool Video *LINK*

#5

For many years I have been using.....

JamieDonaldson

.. the old Sorby Muilti-Tip tool with moveable tips and a rounded back shaft. Unfortunately Sorby really upgraded the tool cost several years ago, and I then made a similar tool from some 3/4" cold rolled stock with a shaper blade bolted on, allowing a great variety of shape adjustments and used in the angled shearing mode. I also value JJ's double ended shearing cutter for smoooooothing exterior surfaces.

Re: Tracy Owen Finishing Tool Video *LINK*

#6

Re: Tracy Owen Finishing Tool Video

robo hippy

They should do fine as a finish cut tool, but I wouldn't use them for roughing. If you get off to a side, the tool would roll. For me, I just take my scrapers to the grinder and do a 1/4 round profile on the side. This makes it easy to use as a scraper because you still have the flat side, and when you roll it up on its edge for a shear/finish cut, it is more easy to control than one that is square sided. The thing you need to be careful about if you are using standard scrapers for shear finish cuts is to work on the bottom half of the tip. This is easy with a round nose scraper, and especially if you are using a swept back grind on them, like an inside scraper design.

robo hippy

Re: Tracy Owen Finishing Tool Video *LINK*

#7

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Tracy Owen Finishing Tool Video

Jesper, Denmark

Ronny, It's not rude to start the sentence with "I" in this context, as you are giving your personal opinion.

In general correspondence and speech, starting too many sentences with "I" tend to give the reader/listener the impression of selfcenteredness, and should be avoided.

The diagram showing the resting point under the cutting force seems to be a good argument, but I really wonder if this is not a solution to a problem that (almost) does not exist? If your cutting point is a little away from the supporting point of the tool, have really gained anything?

I tend to "shearscrape" with the wings of a bowlgouge - also a round-shanked tool, where you can rotate and change tilt angles till you find the sweet spot, where the tool cuts well on the particular shape you are working on.

We had a long discussion at a recent local meeting about tool angles and angles of cut. The novices would like some specific data for different situations, but the experienced turners were really at a loss to provide this information. One of the problems is that you can never really see the actual cutting action, so you end up using feel and small changes in cutting angles. This is impossible to explain to others, as it is developed by experience. It's no good to tell the novice to just change the whatever till it feels right!

Re: Tracy Owen Finishing Tool Video *LINK*

#8

Jesper- I usually explain that there......

JamieDonaldson

..are 3 basic types of cutting action: sheer, slice, and scrape.

Re: Tracy Owen Finishing Tool Video *LINK*

#9

Re: Tracy Owen Finishing Tool Video

john lopez

Thanks for all the input

John