Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Wood strong enough to chip steel?

Posts

Wood strong enough to chip steel?

#1

Steven Antonucci

Wood strong enough to chip steel?

steven antonucci

I am hollowing a black locust vessel and I am using a cobalt steel cutter in a 3/4" boring bar. I have wanded the log with a metal detector (a cheap one), and it isn't finding anything. Why? because the cobalt steel cutter keeps chipping!

I am assuming that there is something buried in the interior, but I can't see it. One second I am cutting, the next second, nothing and the edge looks like a serrated butter knife.

Is there any wood that is stronger than steel?

Help! I still have a bunch of this to turn!

S

Re: Wood strong enough to chip steel?

#2

Re: Wood strong enough to chip steel?

Ace Foster

End grain black locust is harder than Woody's lips. Good luck.

Re: Wood strong enough to chip steel?

#3

Steve Kubien

Re: Wood strong enough to chip steel?

Steve Kubien

Very tough stuff, especially if it is dry. What sort of angle have you got the tip ground to? I would want it rather blunt.

Maybe this is one of those time when the slicing action of a hook tool or a Hunter cutter would be better suited?

Re: Wood strong enough to chip steel?

#4

Richard Allen

Re: Wood strong enough to chip steel?

Richard Allen

Could be silica. But you should be able to hear a tick tick tick is a chunk pf something like silica is chipping your cutting tool. You might want to switch to a tougher steel. It could be that your cutter is to hard (holds an edge but is susceptible to chipping.

If you can detect a tick tick tick then you can work to dig out the offending material.

If the silica is in finer particles you will be doing a LOT of sharpening. Might be one of those hunks of wood to leave alone.

Re: Wood strong enough to chip steel?

#5

Re: Wood strong enough to chip steel?

BillTurpin in WNC mountains

Dry, cured black locust will make a chainsaw spark.

Re: Wood strong enough to chip steel?

#6

Steven Antonucci

Broke my hook first...

steven antonucci

Re: Wood strong enough to chip steel?

#7

Re: Wood strong enough to chip steel?

robo hippy

Generally the steel is harder and should not chip. Some steels are rather brittle, and will tend to chip, especially if there is a shallow angle on the tool. I would want a 75 degree bevel or so on the tip. Also, could be the particular piece of steel. If it has been quenched after grinding, or improperly tempered, that would make it want to break more.

Makes me wonder if Doug should sell hollow form bits.

robo hippy

Re: Wood strong enough to chip steel?

#8

Steven Antonucci

The bevel is pretty blunt- 75 degrees or so

steven antonucci

There has to be something in the wood that I just can't see... these tips are harder than cement.

I'm going to stick a camera inside to see...

S

Re: Wood strong enough to chip steel?

#10

Re: The bevel is pretty blunt- 75 degrees or so

john lucas

I agree with Robbo. The metal may simply be too hard for the angle of the edge. I know if you look at the edge of Hunter tools and EAsywoodtools after a fair amount of use they will have that saw tooth look. They are very small chips and the tools still cut pretty well. Just not as easy as a fresh edge.

I'll be cutting up a locust tree on Sunday if I can get a new chain and bar for my saw. We just keep having bad storms and I keep losing trees.

Re: Wood strong enough to chip steel?

#11

Re: Wood strong enough to chip steel?

Terry Scott

Some of the Australian desert woods are so hard that I turn I gave up and I put my chisel between centers and turned with the wood

The hardest thing I have ever turned was a bowling ball that I took to be liguem vatea it was Hermalite .That stuff will take the teeth off diamond bit

Re: Wood strong enough to chip steel?

#12

Yes, Locust is hard enough to chip carbon

John Cotten

Try using HSS instead, it is not brittle, yes you will have to sharpen more often, but you will get a great job, and not ruin a $100.00 tool. After 42 years of turning I have learned some woods are better turned with a cheap tool that can be sharpened often, rather than tearing up a good quality tool and wearing out the cutting edge. Most of the locust I have turned either turns a dark honey brown, or a burnt orange after a period of time.

Osage Orange (Hedge Apple), Persimmon, and Mesquite all fall into this catagorey of extremely hard woods. I have also turned some burls that the knots have been this hard, particularly an old piece of western elm burl a Don Weber gave me sevearl years ago.

Re: Wood strong enough to chip steel?

#13

Re: Yes, Locust is hard enough to chip carbon

Mark Trenier

I have a high speed steel gouge that has been broken by Ash. It's the only wood that will do that, but the tip or the wings came right off.

Re: Wood strong enough to chip steel?

#14

Re: I have found ceramic insulators and other

steve worcester

I ran into a steel jacket bullet awhile back, but also have found some wood that wouldn't cut but a few seconds with 10V (or M4), but the Teak burls cut awesome with carbide.

Re: Wood strong enough to chip steel?

#15

Re: Yes, Locust is hard enough to chip carbon

John Cotten

HSS will break also, although as mentioned earlier, for some hard woods you have to change the pitch of the grind to a steep bevel. I have never broken one on ash, but snaped a spindle gouge at the handle on time turning teaberry, No hang, just snapped. I determined later that it fallen off the lathe and fractured the steel. This could also be the cast where the wings snapped on your tool.

The reason the woods I mentioned will chip carbon is they all are very heavy oily, dense woods. Even with carbide or other similar exotic metals, the heat build up from the friction is enough to make the carbide break.

Re: Wood strong enough to chip steel?

#16

Re: Wood strong enough to chip steel?

GDeavers

Steven,

a little late in replying, however wanted to explain that Turning Black Locust is just like turning Concrete, only different! However, buffs and finishes wonderfully.... It is a lot of fun after the turning process is complete... Another one which I have had loads of fun with, is Burr Oak - only use for a test of your intestinal fortitude, and grit.

Best Wishes!

GBD