The only finishes i know of are tung oil and polyurathane high gloss... if you do segmented or treelimbs, whats your favorite and why?
there are probably billions of different ways and i'm sure it varies on individual preferences, but I just need a push in the right direction..
and if you use several different, still want to know why on each step..
ie... spit (cause it's shiny and free,) a coat of sandingsealer cause i want to do repairs in cracks with cs to prevent staining (last weeks post, btw) a coat of minwax happy woodsealer (cause it was 50% off at lowes) another coat of spit, and then a buff with tripoli, diamond paste, carnuba, and a bit of ...
There are MANY finishes out there. It sort of depends on what you have available.
Mark Kauder - one of the masters (IMO) of segmented bowls uses a spray-on lacquer finish. If you have a HVLP sprayer - go for it. It's easy, dries fast and you can really build your coats.
I like using oil/varnish blends. I either buy them or make them. To mean they have a depth and a luster - not a shine.
I've also used spray-on lacquer and brush-on lacquer.
It really also depends on the final use. If it's going to be a display piece, a shiny finish is fine - but not for a piece that is going to be constantly used.
I think people make finishing wood way more complicated than it needs to be.
Start by considering your piece, and ask questions:
Is it treenware (salad/mixing/nut bowl, etm.) or some other active use? Active use calls for some oil and wax but no more as any film finish will fail and look like crap in short order.
If it's display/decoration, is the piece a candidate for shiny, dull, flat, semi, etc. You can make it shinny with 3-5 coats of rattle-can lacquer in a day, or you can fuss with 12 coats of Waterlox of hand sanded, hand rubbed slow-build polymerized oil for a kickass deep gloss in a week or two. Each will show every scratch when the housekeeper dusts it.
You can get a nice sheen with a couple coats of shellac topped with some matte-finish artist's "Fixatiff" that you then rub out with 4-O steel wool.
You can get a lovely finish by sanding to 600 grit or so and then letting handling and body oil produce a shine.
There are a zillion permutations on all of the above. You're the maker. What do you want your piece to look like?
My favorite finish for American Black Walnut is Walnut oil from the grocery store. Test the oil first by smearing a drop or two of the oil on glass. The oil should be hard in a few days. It the oil doesn't get hard then that bottle of walnut oil isn't going to work.
For maple I like Minwax wipe on poly. This goes on really easy. The finish applies very thin so I like to put on 5 to 8 coats.
For darker woods that aren't oily (cocobolo is oily) I like Zars wipe-on finish. It builds fast, dries fairly quick and is super easy to apply. This finish has a nice amber cast to it and buffs out well.
For oily wood I like to push a wipe-on finish. This means that once the finish is wiped on then wiped off it is hand buffed with a paper towel and the lathe spinning at a fairly good speed. The idea being that the finish will be heated up a bit which will help cause the finish cure more quickly.
For small items I like EEE followed by one of the friction polishes (shellac and wax).
For pens I like thin CA glue as the finish.
The selection, application, cure and buffing of woodturnings is dependent on a lot of different concerns, wood species, intended use, temperature, humidity, time available, current inspiration, the finish the last demonstrator used at the club meeting, what finishes are being talked about on WoodCentral...
Polyurethane is great for woodwork and TV show furniture, but unless you want your piece to look like it's coated with shrink wrap plastic, leave that stuff in the cabinet when you're doing turnings.
check out Russ's Corner under articles on the left. He left us a rather in depth discussion of finishes. I prefer semi gloss lacquer sprayed with a "Critter" gun. builds rapidly and I 'kinda like the finish
I like a high gloss finish. Around here in my neck of the woods glossy out sells matte 10 to 1. I use lots of different finishes but like gloss lacquer the best.