Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

what's everyone think...

Posts

what's everyone think...

#1

what's everyone think... 

Randy Gleckler

Not the best pic in the world, but I use what I have to work with. Made the 'Lid' and finial last night. What's everyone think. Does it flow well?


Re: what's everyone think...

#2

Re: what's everyone think...

Don at Central Illinois

While I'm no expert it seems the lid is lost in the top. The top flows out and then abruptly stops and then you have this nice rounded top and finial. I think it the top sat at the outer edge of the HF it would flow better.

Re: what's everyone think...

#3

My Thought

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Randy,

While it's a bit difficult because you haven't shown the entire piece, my impression is that the vessel is composed of gentle soft curves. In that context, I think your finial, while nicely cut, is a bit too complex so that it "argues" with the tone of what I can see of the piece. Consider another finial with the bottom three elements removed.

HTH

Re: what's everyone think...

#4

Steven Antonucci

Try this:

steven antonucci

Take a picture without the lid and finial.

Turn another scrap of wood for a lid. Don't worry about finish, just try different shapes. See if it gets better or worse.

My thoughts are that with that shape in the neck, it's going to be fairly difficult to make a lid that fits it and looks good. Adding a finial will be even harder.

In addition, it looks like the lid is a piece of ambrosia maple. I'd probably make it black like the finial to unify it with the top. Not a fan of too many woods in a piece...

S

Re: what's everyone think...

#5

Re: what's everyone think...

John Lucas

You did a good job of turning it. That's a nice thin finial. I would agree with Steve. The contrasting woods work against it. I would make it black also. That might compliment the black line below. The finial is well done. My own take on it would have been to make the top saucer shape above the ball just a little smaller than the bottom one. That would help your eye flow upwards. then instead of a perfectly straight upper section I would have take the Hershey's kiss shape and extended it up to just a little below the little bead shape. Again this would keep your eye going up.

I've seen your work and I'll bet it looks better in real life. It's always hard to judge by a photo.

Re: what's everyone think...

#6

Re: what's everyone think... 

charlie belden

I'd skip the horizontal black lines - continuous nice grain looks nicer.

The neck could use a curve which could make it look more delicate.

The half hidden "dome" under the finial is half buried. Taller, more

visible done could make it look less Stuck On.

The finial has too many elements - that don't go together very well.

The little bead between the "onion" and the tip of the finial stands

out incongruously - like a wart on a pretty girl's nose. Cindy Crawford's

mole worked. A wart wouldn't have.

Here's the piece with a version I tweeked in PhotoShop with the quick

and dirty changes I would make. The tweeked finial still needs some

work - but that would take a bit more effort.


Re: what's everyone think...

#7

Re: what's everyone think...

Randy g

Thank you everyone for the replies I will mess with a few more designs for the lid and take some new pics. Unfortunately can't change much on the vessel at this point but can still swap out components on the lid. I'll take better pics next time too. Thanks again

Re: what's everyone think...

#8

Steven Antonucci

Assume the burned line hides another line?

steven antonucci

Re: what's everyone think...

#9

Re: Assume the burned line hides another line?

charlie belden

Rather than hiding, what I assume is a joint line, this accentuates it - drawing the eye AWAY from the nice continuous grain flow - and TO the BLACK line.

Makes more sense to me to "slip" a punch - than to "lean into it".

Adding a second, lower, black line doesn't help at all and makes matters even worse.

If you HAVE to hide the joint, use a bead and its more subtle shadown lines.


img

Re: what's everyone think...

#10

Steven Antonucci

I agree, but I wasn't sure since it's not mine

steven antonucci

I agree with you wholeheartedly about the line, but I was only pointing out the reason I suspected it was put there in the first place. I think that the line could have worked better if it was in a different location, and perhaps one our three lines done some other way, or...

S

Re: what's everyone think...

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: what's everyone think...

keith tompkins

HI, Looking at the piece, it's complete without a finial...it doesn't need it. I would incorporate a knob or pull into the lid, and that's it. To me, a finial is the epitome of the turning craft, and requires careful forethought on how it relates to the form. I feel your finial has too many straight lines, which don't compliment the flow of the form beneath. I like to sketch my forms with finials ahead of time to see how they relate to each other.