Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Carnac the Magnificent

Posts

Carnac the Magnificent

#1

Carnac the Magnificent

GaryG in MD

And the answer is.... "wood bleach"

For a change, I decided to post an answer instead of a question.

Ever since seeing Betty Scarpino demonstrate, I've been wanting to do some bleaching. Unfortunately Kleen Strip has stopped making the reasonably sized two-part wood bleach kit (quart-size containers) and is only selling in gallon size for the ridiculous rip-off price of $120/kit. No way.

I looked at the MSDS and found that their part A is nothing but a weak lye solution (3-7%), and Part B is a relatively strong hydrogen peroxide (25-30%).

I went to the hardware store and got a pound of Rooto 100% lye drain cleaner crystals for $8. This is enough to make many, many gallons at the 6% (by weight) concentration that I chose to make. [Do not use Drano which has other chemicals and aluminum slivers in it -- make sure it says "100% lye".] Beware: this stuff is extremely hydroscopic -- it has to be kept very dry and can be dangerous if you get it wet in the container. It is also exothermic -- it gets very hot when you purposely mix it with water. It is highly caustic. Take proper precautions and wear eye protection.

I went to the pool supply store and got a gallon of Baquacil swimming pool oxidizer for $18. It is 27% hydrogen peroxide. Perfect.

My total investment is now well under $30 for enough of the two needed chemicals to last me a lifetime.

I mixed up a pint of 6% lye (6 grams per 100 cc water) and stored it in an old glass reagent bottle I had laying around. Plastic is ok -- do not store in metal. It keeps indefinitely.

I mixed small, equal amounts of the lye solution and the Baquacil in another small glass jar. I used a Q-Tip and tested it on some red oak and walnut -- just swipe it on to wet the wood, and let it dry.

Works like a champ! Great results. One coat does a pretty good job. The second coat makes it better. I didn't try more.

Just sand down the raised grain with some 320 sandpaper and maybe take it up to Abralon 1000 to put a little sheen on it. No finish is a good finish -- or some Ren Wax; maybe some clear fixative. Most finishes will yellow it, and you don't want that.

You have to mix the two parts freshly every time. Throw away your excess (in a responsible manner) when you're done applying it because it goes bad quickly -- I tested the mixture after 24 hours, and it was no longer effective.

Give it a try! ...Gary

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

#2

Thank you Gary- I'm running low so I'll try this

John Lucas

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

#3

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

Sean Troy

Just go to a beauty supply store for hydrogen peroxide. It's a lot less expensive and stronger.

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

#4

Thank you Carnac the Magnificent!!

Mike from Saint Claire Shores

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

#5

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

GaryG in MD

Sean,

Thanks for the comment. I did try that first, without success.

I don't know what product you're talking about, but you have to be careful about the nomenclature. My experience with the hair bleach products is that they are listed with a "volume" designation to indicate the strength. This means the volume of oxygen gas given off by a certain amount of liquid. The numbers are NOT percentages.

Indeed, the "40 volume" is only 12%. I tried this, and it did not work. Furthermore, it was in a kind of gel form that was nasty to work with.

I'd also be surprised if you could get a gallon of a "beauty"/hair product for only $18. I'd be interested to hear your experience in more detail.

Thanks, Gary

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

#6

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

Sean Troy

A couple of years ago I got a quart of 30% for 8 bucks or so.

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

#7

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

GaryG in MD

That would be worth looking into, although isn't that stuff mostly sold only to hair professionals? The goo I tried had a lot of other chemicals in it -- emulsifiers, etc., that I'd just as well not have anyway. A quart would certainly be plenty for a long, long time. I didn't need a gallon, but the $18 was way preferable to the $60 for the same thing from Kleen Strip! ...GG

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

#8

Thank you Gary

Jorge Casta�eda

I had the same reaction to the prize of the Kleen strip, and had several project that could have been ideal for bleaching. I will give it a try.

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

#9

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

Sean Troy

Sally's Beauty Supply chain has it, or at least used to. I always used it to make a poltice to remove stains from granite.

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

#10

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

GaryG in MD

What's the name of the product? I searched their online products with the terms "bleach" and "peroxide", and the strongest I could find is "50 volume creme developer". That's only 15% hydrogen peroxide. That will not work very well (if at all), compared to the 27% Bacquacil.

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

#11

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

Sean Troy

It's been over a year sense the last time I purchased any but it was in a brown bottle and came in 15% and 30%. I'm almost sure there was a 40% I saw every so often. I wish I could be of more help. A local store may carry it and not be seen on their website. I bought some in Az. when I lived there and here in Ky. over the last five years several times. Both at Sally beauty Supply.

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

#12

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

GaryG in MD

Thanks Sean. We have several Sally's near here according to their web site (I'd never heard of it before, until now), so I'll call and see what they might have.

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

#13

Thanks Gary

Mike Foster

I still have some wood bleach on the shelf, but will save the recipe for when I run out.

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

#14

Steven Antonucci

FYI_The Kleen Strip comes in plastic bottles

steven antonucci

I could never quite resolve if there was a mix then apply or apply A then apply B difference?

Do you mix A&B and get a better result? Or vice versa?

(BTW- DIY chemistry...now that is cool!)

S

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

#15

Re: Thanks Gary

Barbara Dill

You are amazing. Thanks for your research!!!

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

#16

Re: FYI_The Kleen Strip comes in plastic bottles

Bart Leetch

�I could never quite resolve if there was a mix then apply or apply A then apply B difference?

Do you mix A&B and get a better result? Or vice versa?

(BTW- DIY chemistry...now that is cool!) �

S

�I mixed small, equal amounts of the lye solution and the Baquacil in another small glass jar. I used a Q-Tip and tested it on some red oak and walnut -- just swipe it on to wet the wood, and let it dry.

Works like a champ! Great results. One coat does a pretty good job. The second coat makes it better. I didn't try more.�

Is this the answer you were looking for Steven?

Bart

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

#17

Steven Antonucci

I just reread the Kleen Strip instructions

steven antonucci

Not sure why I thought you applied one and then the other, but it says that you mix equal parts of A&B like Gary suggests.

I wonder what the resulting "wood bleach" actually is? Assume that it's nasty stuff, since it suggests carefully disposing of any leftover stuff.

FYI-

The directions also suggest wetting the surface with water first to get better penetration and neutralizing with diluted vinegar afterwards. Knowing that vinegar is an acid, then the bleach must be a base compound...

Wear glasses AND a faceshield while doing this. A drop in the eye will make you blind...

S

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

#18

Re: I just reread the Kleen Strip instructions

John Lucas

Steve I've never used the neutralizer. As far as I can tell it's simply not needed. I've talked to other bleacher's who don't use it either.

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

#19

what's interesting...

GaryG in MD

...is putting the two parts on separately in two different locations.

The lye alone darkens the wood.

The peroxide alone only slightly lightens the wood.

Together, they bleach the wood.

Having said that, I don't believe the mixture actually creates another chemical compound -- I think it remains a simple mixture. There's something about the application of the two chemicals together at the same time that causes the bleaching reaction. Apparently, the oxidizing property of the peroxide has better access to the coloring agents in a strongly "basic" (alkaline, as opposed to acid) solution.

See http://bleaching-of-wood-pulp.co.tv

where it says:

"The objective of bleaching mechanical pulp (also referred to as brightening) is to remove only the chromophores (color-causing groups). This is possible because the structures responsible for color are also more susceptible to oxidation or reduction. Alkaline hydrogen peroxide is the most commonly used bleaching agent for mechanical pulp. The amount of base such as sodium hydroxide is less than that used in bleaching chemical pulps and the temperatures are lower. These conditions allow alkaline peroxide to selectively oxidize non-aromatic conjugated groups responsible for absorbing visible light."

There you have it!

It's not "nasty stuff" -- nothing more than a weak drain cleaner with some hair bleach. Treat it as you would Drano -- keep it off your clothes and out of your eyes. Wash hands after using.

There appears to be no short term reason to neutralize with a weak acid (vinegar, lemon juice, etc.) -- there may be archival repercussions for leaving the surface alkaline, but I have no idea what that story may be...

...Gary

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

#20

Steven Antonucci

Good stuff

steven antonucci

I didn't mean that the mixture was "nasty stuff", but the chemicals to make it will need to be diluted significantly to reduce it to being less dangerous. The concentrated forms have to be handled with extra care until they get into a diluted form.

As an aside, the last time I tried to bleach something, I got "something" (can't recall if it was A, B or mixed A+B) splashed on my arm. Within a few seconds, I KNEW it was there. It was more than a little bit uncomfortable, but didn't leave any marks. Still, I was much happier after I washed it off.

S

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

#21

Re: Good stuff

GaryG in MD

It was probably "B" -- the 30% peroxide has a 'kick' to it. It'll make your skin white very quickly (so I've heard). ;-)

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

#22

Alphabet

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Kim Blatt does a lot of bleached work and he insists that the two solutions need to be applied separately for better control. As noted by John's quote, the lye conditions the wood for the peroxide to bleach it.

As far a neutralizing goes, a sponge with white vinegar and water rinse will make sure that the lye doesn't mess with your finishing chemistry. This may be more important if you're using waterborne finishes and/or if you're bleaching prior to coloring with dyes.

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

#23

Steven Antonucci

Like everything- ask three woodturners...

steven antonucci

get 4 answers!

At least we are consistent! :b

S

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

#24

Re: Alphabet

GaryG in MD

Thanks Mark. I'm sure Kim knows a lot more about it than I do. Having said that, the mixture worked just fine -- it was white by the time it got dry after one application, and quite white after two.

Regarding the neutralizer -- I agree that, in general, it might be a good idea to neutralize to be safe in terms of finishing and archival behavior. OTOH, it requires wetting and drying one more time (not a terrible thing, but time consuming). As far as the finishes are concerned, I haven't tried it, but, if I had to guess, I suspect it may not matter much.

For what I've done so far, I want a kind of almost chalky white, so I haven't used any finish -- just sand to Abralon 1000 to add a slight (very slight) sheen. Typical finishes would want to be the "water white" ones -- acrylic, lacquer, water-based poly, or just Ren. wax. Has anyone out there got any experience with bleaching under these finishes in terms of their archival behavior?

I'll add this -- the bleach "takes" differently to different wood densities. This is a good thing because it tends to bring out the grain patterns. For my application, I consider this a benefit. I guess it might not be in all cases.

Re: Carnac the Magnificent

#25

Here's what it looks like

GaryG in MD

I've been playing musical computers -- finally got a photo example available here.

The X on the red oak cutoff is one very quick coat -- just a swiped X -- no going back over it.

The cylinder is walnut sap wood with just an edge of heart wood. Same deal -- just a quick swipe in two spots.

The egg is the same red oak as the cutoff, but with two good solid coats. That's what I was after.