Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

OT - Benefit Auction v Benefit Raffle

Posts

OT - Benefit Auction v Benefit Raffle

#1

OT - Benefit Auction v Benefit Raffle

David Walser

Recently Glaser Hitec donated to WoodCentral some turning tools that were auctioned off. The auction raised close to $300. (Many thanks to Glaser and to those who bid.) My question, would it be possible for such items to be raffled off rather than auctioned off? A raffle might raise much more than an item's retail value. In contrast, an item's retail value often sets the ceiling on it's auction price. For example, had WoodCentral sold 50 tickets at $5 for each of the two tools donated, the amount raised would have been $500 in total.

For such items, I think a raffle is superior to an auction for at least three reasons: First, a $5 or $10 ticket price allows more of us to participate in the fund raising. Even if someone doesn't particularly want an item (enough to pay close to retail for it), many will still buy a ticket or two. Second, some prospective donors may fear a low auction price might create a false perception of their product's "real" value. This problem is avoided with a raffle. Third, the opportunity to help raise $500 by contributing something that retails for about $100 might attract more donations.

I understand that there might be some legal obstacles to holding a raffle. If so, there might be some legitimate ways to address those concerns.

Thoughts?

Re: OT - Benefit Auction v Benefit Raffle

#2

Katherine Kowalski

Re: OT - Benefit Auction v Benefit Raffle

Katherine Kowalski

David,

I think a raffle for some items is an EXCELLENT idea, especially for the reasons you stated.

I'm always willing to buy a raffle ticket or two.

Katherine

Re: OT - Benefit Auction v Benefit Raffle

#3

Betty Scarpino

Re: OT - Benefit Auction v Benefit Raffle

Betty Scarpino

David, I think a raffle would probably raise more money than an auction, however, someone has to manage the tickets, be responsible for collecting the money, and send the tickets to buyers. For some of the $5 tickets purchased, it would require an envelope and a first-class stamp ($.44) and someone to lick the envelope .....

Sometimes it's just easier to donate and bid, otherwise no money gets raised.

And yes, the legal issues might be prohibitive. That's been the case for the AAW (Minnesota laws for gambling) for the Powermatic/Binh Pho lathe that will be raffled off at the symposium later this month. Rules say that it's illegal to mail raffle tickets via USPS.

Maybe more publicity for the auctions might be the best way to help raise more funds? Or maybe a daily auction item? Again, though, it would require that someone be in charge ..... and right now I'm not in a position to volunteer.

Re: OT - Benefit Auction v Benefit Raffle

#4

Steve Kubien

Re: OT - Benefit Auction v Benefit Raffle

Steve Kubien

I think you could get around mailing tickets quite easily... If the "ticket" price was set at $5 (or 10 or whatever), people send their funds for the number of tickets purchased via paypal and include a note saying what the funds are for. Ellis ( or whoever handles the paypal account for WC) determines total number of tickets, assigns each ticket a number (one through total tickets sold) and uses a random number generator on the web to come up with a winner. So, if you bought tickets 20-25 inclusive and #22 was generated, you win! No actual tickets get printed/mailed. I suppose this would all hinge on the legalities of Pennsylvania more than anywhere else.

Anyway, I think this would be a great way to raise additional funds for WoodCentral so the lights stay on.

Re: OT - Benefit Auction v Benefit Raffle

#5

Re: OT - Benefit Auction v Benefit Raffle

HeatherAinAK

We looked into being able to put our tool raffle on our club website and it was a no-go on a couple of different levels including (if I remember correctly) taking credit cards and interstate issues. Not sure if your state rules are the same.

Heather

Re: OT - Benefit Auction v Benefit Raffle

#6

Steven Antonucci

No-go in NJ too

steven antonucci

The nuts and bolts of it are that you need to have a gaming license to be able to sell tickets to a raffle. The prize would have to be worth substantially more to cover the cost of the license.

We throw $5 in a hat, and pick out a winner...last time it was me!

S

Re: OT - Benefit Auction v Benefit Raffle

#7

Re: OT - Benefit Auction v Benefit Raffle

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Betty,

You suggested, "Or maybe a daily auction item?"

The Benefits Auctions are made possible by the occasional donated tool, but more often by donations from WC community members. So the frequency of auction items depends entirely on folks combing through their shops and finding things they're not using that someone else might want.

I have an apparently incurable tendency to buy things at garage sales when they're in good shape and cheap, which has made it possible for me to put some stuff up there; others may have more self-control and thus not have anything in their shops that they don't actually use.

Re: OT - Benefit Auction v Benefit Raffle

#8

Ellis Walentine

Legal obstacle to raffles

Ellis Walentine

David, thank you for your thoughtful idea. I do agree that a raffle would be a potentially more lucrative fund-raising method, but I discussed raffles with an attorney several years ago, and he advised me against it. Apparently I can run afoul of some Pennsylvania law. I'll have to see if I can reconstruct the particulars sometime. At any rate, it was enough to make me give up on the idea of raffles.

I appreciate everyone's support and good wishes. All suggestions are welcome, whether for fund-raising or site improvements or anything else.

Best,

Ellis

Re: OT - Benefit Auction v Benefit Raffle

#9

Re: Legal obstacle to raffles

Mark Wollschlager

There is no obstacle to clicking and the button that is at the top of any page.

It is about time for that ( for me ) anyway.


img