Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

segmenting sawblades

Posts

segmenting sawblades

#1

segmenting sawblades

avalon

I'm playing around with segmented turnings and I was wondering if the sawblade that came with my craftsmens tablesaw would be adequate or do i need a special blade?

If i do need a better blade, is it something i can get at lowes or is it special?

I have replaced the miter gage it came with, with an incra gage, and i have a digital thingy that helps me get the angles right...

so hopefully im getting there...

Re: segmenting sawblades

#2

Keith Tompkins

Re: segmenting sawblades

keith tompkins

I would suggest a Forrest woodworker 2 with blade stabiliizers. It is important to properly set up your table saw for optimum performance. That includes ensuring the blade is parallel to the mitre slots. If not, the trunions must be adjusted. Then, ensure the rip fence is parallel to the saw blade.

Re: segmenting sawblades

#3

Re: segmenting sawblades

avalon

so what;s the difference between that and a regular blade?

Re: segmenting sawblades

#4

Re: segmenting sawblades

bill Crommett

For a smooth cut you need lots of teeth without too much tooth angle rake.

After you get the saw trunnions adjusted to be parallel to the miter slot, then build a jig for the precise angle angle of the cut. The after market fences are great for flat work, but there is too much flexibility for segmented work. For flat work if your fence it off by 0.1 degree on a 45 degree miter the glue will take care of the discrepancy, but with a segmented bowl of 36 pieces, a 0.1 degree off will magnify by the 72 angles in the ring. 7.2 degrees is not an acceptable degree of run-out.

Re: segmenting sawblades

#5

JL

Re: segmenting sawblades

JL

There are a variety of "reasonable" blades out there.

As Keith suggested, there is the Forrest Woodworker II. Expensive - but worth it. Not available at any Lowes that I've seen.

In my opinion, you want a good, quality combination blade. That way you can rip your lumber and then cross-cut it. Do NOT get a thin kerf blade. You want a nice thick blade and possibly some stabilizers.

Suggestions:

Forrest Woodworker II 40 tooth - ~$120

Freud Fusion 40 tooth (P410) - ~$100

Freud 50 tooth (LU84R011) - ~$70

CMT 50 tooth combo - ~$84

CMT 40 tooth combo - ~$75

Tenyru 40 tooth combo - ~$55

These aren't the only good blades - just some of them.

I would avoid the painted Dewalt blades (yellow tooth). I would avoid Irwin, Timberline and Black and Decker.

You may have to order on-line. Woodcraft and Rockler carry reasonable blades. You might try a lumber yard.

Re: segmenting sawblades

#6

Re: segmenting sawblades

JerryW

Home Depot (yes Home Depot!) carries an amazing blade and it is relatively inexpensive ($40). It is a Rigid 40T combination blade - it has a gold coating and has anti vibration cut outs. It will rip and cross cut with an amazing finish (the cut surface has next to no visible blade marks - suitable for 150 grit sanding). I ran across it by accident and now have one on the saw and one in the package.

Aside for the blade, a big contributor to a smooth cut is a smooth, true running saw, with little vibration. I noticed a phenomenal improvement when I upgraded from an older Craftsman contractor style saw to a General International cabinet saw.

Also build a cross-cut sled for your table saw. It will make repetitive segment cuts a pleasure. There are a number of web "how to's" out there.

Jerry

Re: segmenting sawblades

#7

Re: segmenting sawblades

john lucas

My experience has qualified all of the above. The two best things I've done to improve segmented accuracy is buy a good blade and build a sliding miter table that fits in both miter slots of your saw. For years I fiddled with a homemade miter sliding table that only rode in on slot and it simply isn't repeatable enough.

Having never owned the Incra gauge I can't comment on that. I did fine tune my factory gauge to the Nth degree with special custom filed indentations and a custom locating pin. It just isn't accurate enough. Probably has more to do with riding in one slot than the accuracy of the modified unit. Remember, when you cut a 12 sided segment you multiply any inaccuracies by 12.

I spent way to much time doing things like assembling my rings in 45, 90, and 180 and then checking them against a gauge and sanding them to accuracy. That works but is a huge waste of time. Getting the accurate cuts right off the saw and being able to a glue up a whole ring in one setting is worth the effort.

I have yet to buy a Forrest blade but I'm going to this year. I still fiddle with some inaccuracies and can really only trace it to the blade. I'll cut 5 rings and one or two of them won't fit accurately so I have to glue them up in 180 degree sections and sand that to fit. Although that makes a tight joint it can spoil repeating designs. One side of the piece will be perfect and the other side off.

Another option which I'm now exploring is something taught in Malcolm Tibbets book The Art of Segmented Woodturning (which I highly recommend) is using the bandsaw and disc sander to make your segments. This allows you to cut all segments with the grain running in the proper direction to compensate for wood movement. You an also select exactly where each piece comes from in the board for so the figure matches. A very good process if you want superior work. Of course now you have to go out and find a good bandsaw and disc sander. Another upgrade I will have to do in the future.

Re: segmenting sawblades

#8

Re: segmenting sawblades

Barry Irby

I have done very little segmented turning so I have little experience that directly applies, but I can tell you that a Forrest WWII blade was about the most significant improvement I made to my TS. I have an old Rockwell Delta Contractors saw and it has done everything I have asked of it. I suppose upgrading to a cabinet saw would be better, but the one I have does so well I can't bring myself to sped the money. Get a better blade. You will like it every time you use the saw for anything. I have never regretted the money I spent on the Forest Blade.

Re: segmenting sawblades

#9

Re: segmenting sawblades

JerryW

Correction:

The HD blade is a Ridgid Titanium coated 50 tooth, model 1050C

Re: segmenting sawblades

#10

Re: segmenting sawblades

Gary Asbury

As an owner of a small cabinet/furniture shop, you might want to find a local shop and ask them who sharpens their blades. Most all sharpening shops sell professional blades at good discounts. They also can sharpen and true your blades when they need it. Also, ask them if they "kyro" treat blades. This freezing process makes a world of difference in the performance of the blade.

Re: segmenting sawblades

#11

Re: segmenting sawblades

Dave Paine

I have to agree with the others. A good blade makes a big difference.

You do need to calibrate the blade to be parallel to the mitre slot, and then the fence to the blade.

I have a Forrest WW II 40 tooth. It provides the smoothest cut of any of my blades. I also recommend using with a zero clearance insert to minimize splintering of the cuts.

I have two Incra mitre gauges. I made a zero clearance block for the end so the sides of the piece do not splinter. It also allows me to see exactly where the cut will be.

I also own a Ridge Carbide TS2000 blade. I like this blade. Not quite as smooth as the Forrest but it cuts think maple better. Something about more side clearance of the steel.

Re: segmenting sawblades

#12

Alan Zenreich

Re: segmenting sawblades

Alan Zenreich

I was talking to a guy from Forrest yesterday at a demo, and he says that they're experimenting with some prototype blades targeted at the segmenter's market. I don't have details, but it's nice to know they're even considering such an item.

Re: segmenting sawblades

#13

Re: segmenting sawblades

robo hippy

A big second on talking to the local saw shop, or cabinet shops to find out who does the best job of sharpening. Virtually every blade you buy in the stores will cut a lot better if the right person sharpens it for you. I was amazed at the difference. I don't do segmented pieces, but when I saw Malcolm, he was using a Freud chop saw for his cuts.

robo hippy

Re: segmenting sawblades

#14

Re: segmenting sawblades

avalon

so... how does one measure the parallaraty? of a sawblade to a mitergage?

I think i just invented a word... Par-all-ar-aty-n The measuring of a sawblade..

do you take a square and see how square it is to the 90 deg angle of a mitergage or do you measure it with something else if you want to know PRECISELY how many billionth of a degree it is off?

If you can't tell, im a liberal arts major with major attention deficit. My idea of precision usually involves what we call the shotgun effect... Aim a shotgun at something and you're bound to hit something..

And my idea of straight lines involves curves...

Re: segmenting sawblades

#15

Re: segmenting sawblades

Bill Youngblood

Parralarity? Cool word. :) I use a dial indicator attached to a magnetic base (available at machine tool dealers or even Harbor Freight). Attach that setup to your sliding mitre and check the blade front to rear. It should be within just a few thousands. 4 or 5 max. Then make your sled with 2 slide bars and check it again. Even then, I make my rings in 2 sections and sand each half on a disc sander to fit perfectly. Check Kevin Neeley's web site for some really good info on making sleds. All of the above on the blades.

Good luck.

Re: segmenting sawblades

#16

JL

Re: segmenting sawblades

JL

As Bill said, a dial indicator.

If you have a REALLY good engineering square, you can get a rough approximation of the miter slots being parallel to the blade. For most work, that is good enough. I do NOT mean a combination square - unless you have a Starrett square.

You will have to learn how to align your table saw top to your blade. Refer to your manual.

Re: segmenting sawblades

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: segmenting sawblades

keith tompkins

For the most accurate measurement, mark one tooth of the blade with a marker. Rotate that tooth to the front. Make your measurement, then rotate the same tooth to the back. Make your measurement again. That compensates for any blade runout.

Re: segmenting sawblades

#18

Re: segmenting sawblades

john lucas

Well Ideally you have one of the fancy gadgets that sits in the miter slot and has a dial indicator to measure the distance from them miter slot to the saw blade in thousands of an inch.

OK lacking that here is how I used to do it. Clamp a piece of steel rod to your miter gauge so it's very close to the blade but not touching. Now take a feeler gauge and find out which gauge just barely fits between the blade and steel rod. For arguments sake lets say it's the .025" gauge. Now move the miter gauge to the other end of the blade and check again. If it's perfectly parallel the .025 gauge will just barely fit. If not try other another gauge. That will tell how much it's off.

The hard part is doing the adjustment.You have to either loosen the top or loosen the trunion depending on what saw you have.

Re: segmenting sawblades

#19

Re: segmenting sawblades

avalon

so a 40 tooth sawblade is ok? Thought the more teeth the merrier... cause i've seen 180t blades..

Re: segmenting sawblades

#20

Bill Blasic

Re: segmenting sawblades

Bill Blasic

If I remember correctly Malcolm is now using a Festool Kapex that he raved about.

Bill

Re: segmenting sawblades

#21

I do it by ear.....

Barry Irby

I do what John said except I clamp a HARD pencil to the miter guage and fit it so that the tooth just snicks it when the tooth is to the front. Rotating the same tooth to the rear, I move the miter guage to the back and see it the "snick" sounds the same. Not sure how accurate it is, but it works for me.

Re: segmenting sawblades

#22

Re: segmenting sawblades

John Lucas

Malcolm does use the Festool. I've been drooling over it. I made the mistake of using one. It is an incredibly sweet running machine and leaves a cut as smooth as, well you know. Unfortunately it is almost twice the price of any other sliding miter saw. I've been looking hard. Talking to the other segmented turners any of the top end miter saws will work if you put a good blade on them and spend the time tuning them up. That makes the decision harder.

One possible problem with the Forrest blade is resharpening. Forrest will do it of course. I don't know how much they charge and how long it takes. I have a local guy who sharpens my blades and he does a better job than any of the more expensive places I've sent blades off to around the country. I would feel a little insecure asking him to do the Forrest Blade although if it doesn't come back perfect I suppose I could then send it back to Forrest.

Re: segmenting sawblades

#23

Re: segmenting sawblades

John Lucas

Malcolm does use the Festool. I've been drooling over it. I made the mistake of using one. It is an incredibly sweet running machine and leaves a cut as smooth as, well you know. Unfortunately it is almost twice the price of any other sliding miter saw. I've been looking hard. Talking to the other segmented turners any of the top end miter saws will work if you put a good blade on them and spend the time tuning them up. That makes the decision harder.

One possible problem with the Forrest blade is resharpening. Forrest will do it of course. I don't know how much they charge and how long it takes. I have a local guy who sharpens my blades and he does a better job than any of the more expensive places I've sent blades off to around the country. I would feel a little insecure asking him to do the Forrest Blade although if it doesn't come back perfect I suppose I could then send it back to Forrest.

Re: segmenting sawblades

#24

same experience here,barry

bob davis

Re: segmenting sawblades

#25

Alan Zenreich

Re: segmenting sawblades

Alan Zenreich

John,

Forrest is about 15 minutes from me. I think they charge about $20 to sharpen my WWII blade. Can't get much better than a new factory edge from that company.