Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Stubborn Wood - errrr!

Posts

Stubborn Wood - errrr!

#1

Stubborn Wood - errrr!

jake Niedling

Just trying to finish a 9"roughed out cherry bowl that was sitting around for about 1 yr. Doing the sanding and fighting a couple of spots on the outside. Usually cherry and walnut sand up wonderfully, but not this little gem. Using all the my tricks and finally getting almost there, where I am happy with the final sanded finish. There were two end grain spots that just did not want to sand smooth. Forward, reverse, power sand, hand sand, drop back a couple of grit sizes, etc. At one point I thought maybe I should just put a textured finish on the outside. About 90% there before I quit for the evening. I will get'er done tomorrow. And by the way, I started sanding after I had done a nice shear scrap which also did not smooth out these spots.

What is the saying " Never give up" but I almost did on this one.

Having fun in Knoxville.

Jake

Re: Stubborn Wood - errrr!

#2

Re: Stubborn Wood - errrr!

Randy Gleckler

Glad your turning and not Traveling... Done for a while?

Re: Stubborn Wood - errrr!

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: Stubborn Wood - errrr!

keith tompkins

Hey Jake , perhaps you can try this. It works for me as a last resort. Sharpen a 3/8" spindle gouge, then hone it, inside as well as the bevel. Whatever honing method you use, try to maintain the same angles without rounding over the edge; you want the sharpest possible edge. Then, with the flute facing away from the bowl at ninety degrees and riding the bevel...start at the rim, and cut towards the foot. Let the tool feed itself, don't try to hurry it. I've done some difficult bowls this way that needed almost no sanding. If you try it, let me know how you make out.

Re: Stubborn Wood - errrr!

#4

Re: Stubborn Wood - errrr!

john lucas

Jake if you have a round card scraper you can selectively clean up those areas. I've never tried it but a regular round nose scraper with a fresh burr on it might do the same thing. Leave the lathe off of course. Then just drag the scraper across the area in different directions until you've gotten rid of the tearout.

Re: Stubborn Wood - errrr!

#5

Re: Stubborn Wood - errrr!

jake Niedling

I think I know that cut, but have not mastered it. It seems like just a little twist or rotation of the handle makes a equal change in the cut depth. It does cut very clean. The first time I saw it was by Nick Cook and I was impressed. He made it look easy, but when I got home to try it, I found out it takes some practice, surprise, surprise.

I typically don't hone my gouges, but I will give that a try the next time as well.

I have a very good shape and don't want to make it a practice piece now. But I will certainly remember to try that cut in the future.

Re: Stubborn Wood - errrr!

#6

Re: Stubborn Wood - errrr!

jake Niedling

Still travelling about 60% of the time. I try to turn a little every week-end. Hope to see you at the club meeting this month, I should be in town.

Re: Stubborn Wood - errrr!

#7

Re: Stubborn Wood - errrr!

jake Niedling

How about just taking a ball peen hammer to the entire outside surface? I thought a good craftsman knew how to cover up his problems or mistakes. :D :D

Re: Stubborn Wood - errrr!

#8

Stub-bor-ron

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Jake,

Have you stied some shellac or lacquer as a sanding sealer? Wet the areas to raise the grain, let dry, spray a bit of lacquer; resand after an hour.

Re: Stubborn Wood - errrr!

#9

Richard Allen

Re: Stub-bor-ron

Richard Allen

Filling the tear-out prone area with something can help the cut a LOT. The filler can be a lot of different things.

Water, wax, oil, CA glue, varnish, shellac, sanding sealer or anything which can fill the voids between the wood fibers so the fibers can be cut instead of bent over and ripped out of the wood. Consider what you are using as the filler to be sure that it doesn't interfere with finish you intend to use.

Sharp tools also help a lot, you have already received that good advice.

Re: Stubborn Wood - errrr!

#10

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Stubborn Wood - errrr!

Lyle Jamieson

I might be a little late to help the last bowl but it might help others in the future. Its all about sharp tools and grain direction. Going down hill or the direction of supported fibers would minimize the torn out areas. Steep angle sheering/slicing with a sharp edge will help if you go the correct direction. I like John L's suggestion of scraping with the lathe off at this point because Im sure the piece is no longer round after all that abuse. But John's Idea will only work if it is scraped in the correct direction. With the lathe off the scraping action will be opposite to the normal rotational forces used while turning.

Its all about grain orientation both to prevent and to fix torn out grain. Filling it would only leave a cloudy finish and obscure the wood character.

Re: Stubborn Wood - errrr!

#11

Re: Stubborn Wood - errrr!

Dick Wilson

Jake, I had the same dang problem on two cherry bowls that I turned. End grain spots just flat out would not sand smooth. I finally got totally frustrated, got out my Whe-Cheer and used a bur to texture the whole outside. I then dyed the outside of the bowls green and finished. Both sold. :D :D :D

Re: Stubborn Wood - errrr!

#12

Thanks all for listening and suggestions!!

jake Niedling