Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Tool Zealots

Posts

Tool Zealots

#1

Tool Zealots

Stuart Johnson

Why is there such a need for the different tool zealots to take get so personal about their choice. If questions are asked they are interpreted as personal attacks. If a new tool or line of tools comes out and you try it and like it why not just say so and explain why. If someone else doesn't care for the tool, the name on it, the color of the handle why respond with judgmental and negative comments?

Some of the recent threads puts to rest the idea all woodturners are pleasant friendly folks. Maybe so in person but not in cyberspace.

Re: Tool Zealots

#2

Re: Tool Zealots

Dick Wilson

I totally agree Stuart. I remember past threads that intimated that if someone was not using a certain tool they were not good turners. I found them pretty offensive but kept my mouth shut.

Re: Tool Zealots

#3

Re: Tool Zealots

Brian McInturff

That's a good question. I'd venture to say that most do it thinking it's "Sarcastic Humor". I hope it is and not from envy or worse, personal attack. I'm a tool junkie so I hope more discussions come up about tools. Tool discussions are what leads to new ideas, concepts, and inventions. They are needed but some won't participate because of the attacks/rude comments to them.

Re: Tool Zealots

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: Tool Zealots

keith tompkins

Thanks Stuart. I feel that needed to be said. You don't need a Oneway lathe in order to be a good turner. You don't need turning tools made of V-1000 or Z-2000 or whatever the latest high-tech steel is. There is no substitute for skill.

Re: Tool Zealots

#5

As A Potential Tool Zealots...

George Guadiane

I'd like to say;

A) If I have offended anyone with my opinions about tools, I humbly apologize.

B) No one pays me to use their tools or give my opinion. I only talk about the tools I use and I TRY to only say nice things about those.

I have a bucket full of clunkers, but I just don't use them.

C) The reason I talk up the tools I REALLY like is because I think they help make me a better turner. For the most part, I think that is (or should be) the purpose of talking about them.

AND, on occasion, I find that I'm having trouble with a tool and look for help or suggestions, because sometimes I just can't get the hang of it. If I still can't get it, I might let people know that it didn't work for me but I don't think that suggests that they don't work for others.

Re: Tool Zealots

#6

Brian, I truly hope that ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

you enjoy using the new tools to the absolute maximum that you can. Your enthusiasm is wonderful.

Unfortunately there are folks on this messageboard who cannot tolerate anyone having an opinion different from theirs. Don't let them bother you. After all, YOU have (or will soon have) the tools to use and they will not. I cannot understand why people feel put down because you, and possibly I, have made our own choices about which tools to purchase. Folks should be happy for you that you will enjoy the new tools and learning how to use them. But it is their shortcomings that will not allow them that luxury of wishing good fortune to others.

I wish you the absolute best,

Ed

Re: Tool Zealots

#7

Alan Zenreich

Re: Tool Zealots

Alan Zenreich

It's funny... when I showed the Nano tools to a fellow at our local club, his reaction was "there's no need for that stuff, I do it all with sharpened allen wrenches"

And no... it wasn't Steven A.

I'm at a point in my life that I try to acquire the best that I can afford, and hopefully grow to learn how to get the most out of the tools. I have a mandolin that's capable of better sound than I'll ever get out of it. But while learning to play, it's nice to know that it's not the instrument that's holding me back or causing me to sound 'off'.

Theres a gap between those of us who like new (and hopefully improved) tools/toys, and those who yearn for the 'good old' days/tools.

So in the spirit of "we were happier back then", I humbly present:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xe1a1wHxTyo

Re: Tool Zealots

#8

Re: Tool Zealots

woodspinner-Harry Robinette

I understand what your saying but it's been going on forever and always will. Some people just think they have the only tool to do the job. Myself I have about a dozen Doug Thompson tools and handles because his handles fit and don't aggravate the nerve damage in my thumbs and I believe his tools are the best bar none. I don't think everyone should use them, everyone should use what they thinks best for them. I turned for about 9 or 10 years with Sorby, Henry Taylor, Ashley Isle and Crown plus some Specialty tools and did some very nice work from what I've been told. I have a set of Crown mini tools about 8 or 9 inches long and I use them for anything I decide they will work for little or big what ever. I hope to get some more of DT's tools in the next few months only because I really like his tools and his warranty is outstanding. I truly hope I didn't cause any problems I'm only stating my opinion.As Always JM $.02

Re: Tool Zealots

#9

Mike Stafford

Re: Tool Zealots

Mike Stafford

I understand brand loyalty. Everyone knows that Fords are better than Chevys, right? :b

It seems that nothing creates unhappiness any faster in the woodturning world than discussions of tools, chucks or lathes when someone makes the heinous mistake of saying that they like one over the other.

Why is it that we visit these forums to learn and when posts are made discussing the relative merits of various pieces of metal folks have to get so disagreeable?

I thought the purpose of these forums were to provide sources of information and inspiration for the hobby we all are engaged in. I, for one, have learned most of what I know from people on the various forums. Over the years during discussions on tools numerous suggestions have been made that caused me to try a tool that I did not know about.

I, like most of you, have tools in my arsenal that range from homemade crudities to expensive (well, relatively expensive) factory made tools. My choice about which to use has a lot to do with whether or not I am capable of using that tool for the job I want it to do. I have no tools that automatically do any woodturning for me. But many of my tools that I do use were suggested as solutions for a turning problem or improvements over a tool that I was currently using.

It is highly unlikely that I would have learned the solution or became aware of the tool if someone on one of the forums had not brought it to my attention by discussing it. The one thing I know for sure is that the only time I am the smartest person in the room is when I am by myself. I think that holds true for all of us.

So please let people express their opinions. You don't have to agree with them and just because you do something differently or use a different tool doesn't mean that it is the best solution or tool for everyone. Folks come up with new ideas everyday. Ain't that wonderful!!!

Like I said everyone knows that Chevys are better than Fords, right? :b

Re: Tool Zealots

#10

Re: Tool Zealots

Clifton C

Skill ? Is there an APP for that? :)

Re: Tool Zealots

#11

Steven Antonucci

Glad you fixed the typo at the bottom

steven antonucci

as I drive a Nissan these days, but only because the small Chevy was too small and overpriced...

:-)

S

Re: Tool Zealots

#12

Steven Antonucci

10,000 hours

steven antonucci

There is no shortcut for time at the lathe.

The best steel in the worst hands will always lose to the worst steel in the best hands. You simply cannot buy the hours.

What bothers me is how any question (even when they aren't specifically focused on a brand or manufacturer) gets defended to the death by "the team". Ask a question about "mini-tools", and it turn into a Glaser thread.

Whatever.

S

Re: Tool Zealots

#13

Re: Tool Zealots

David Walser

Stuart,

I think there are at least three factors that contribute to the behaviors you describe:

1st: A lot of turners are informal if not sloppy in communicating with other turners. This can lead to misunderstandings. For example: When turner A says: "That's stupid! I can turn the same thing with left over parts out of my Craftsman socket wrench set." Turner B is apt to take what was said as a personal insult. He might think Turner A called him stupid and wasteful in his spending. Of course, this was just a misunderstanding. What Turner A meant was, "If I didn't have to follow my stupid budget, it would be really cool to have that new tool. As is, I'll have to work twice as hard to do the same thing you can do with your new tool."

2nd: Some turners are conflicted over their tools. Some might have spent a lot of money on a tool they don't really like, but they don't want to admit they made a mistake. Others find a new tool really alluring, but they don't want to admit that even to themselves. In either case, these turners are apt to get fairly loud and belligerent when the topic of tools comes up -- "That tool can't be nearly as good as mine and anyone who says it is is an idiot!" Or, "A real turner can turn a masterpiece with nothing more than his fingernails and anyone who wants that tool isn't a real turner!" These people make all this noise to drown out a message they don't want to hear.

3rd: Some people are just jerks. I've never met any of these people, but I've heard the rumors.

Fortunately, Stuart, neither of us fall into any of these three categories. We should thank God for our blessings and pray for those who are less fortunate.

Re: Tool Zealots

#14

Buy Ruth's T-Shirt

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

with Don Geiger's quote: "We're all just one tool away from excellence"

;)

Re: Tool Zealots

#15

Jim Evans

Re: Brian, I truly hope that ... *LINK*

Jim Evans

Sorry Ed, But this is one of the reasons I rarely post any more.


http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/turning.pl/pro/search/pmd/sread/srchid/207229G6GbkEJqj7d4A1307629222/spage/2/sanc/247353/sbid/2000/md/read/id/247370/sbj/i-don-t-buy-all-that-i-am-reading/

Re: Tool Zealots

#16

Re: Buy Ruth's T-Shirt

matt overton

I bought that tee shirt the same day I bought the backhoe that my wife doesn't understand the need for. No kidding.

Re: Tool Zealots

#17

Re: Tool Zealots

Bart Leetch

Heck I make all my turning tools out of the teeth removed from the backhoe buckets of Bobcats (skid loaders) with handles made from old base ball bats He He He..... Not really. But I don't & cannot afford expensive tools. Hence I have....are you ready an old 8 piece set of tool steel craftsman tools from my Dad's lathe, a 12 piece Craftsman HSS tool set given to me by a friend found in a garage sale & a HSS set of Steelex from Grizzly. All used on a 1930's Delta double duty lathe with more money in the 3 phase motor & VFD than the lathe. Or on a Jet 1014 received as a door prize at a turners/woodworkers BBQ Picnic.

along with a 1 way talon chuck & face plates live center dead center & spur. I also have the 1 way sharpening system with 60g & 120g wheels on my grinder.

I dream of a Vicmarc lathe or a Vega or if I could get the parts just build one.

I am not an artist yet & don't have a studio in fact at this time I don't even have a shop & can't use my lathes.

As to the one up's man ship I just ignore them life's to short.

Re: Tool Zealots

#18

Steven Antonucci

Gotta dig a lot of dirt to justify a backhoe

steven antonucci

But I probably would if I had one.

S

Re: Tool Zealots

#19

Re: Glad you fixed the typo at the bottom

Randy Gleckler

Raise of hands here... who would NOT have been surprised if Steven said he built his own car. :-D

Re: Tool Zealots

#20

Steven Antonucci

The thought has crossed my mind

steven antonucci

Wanted to build an AC Cobra kit many years ago. Turns out that you could put together a street legal rocket for about $35K that would have left every Porsche, Lamborghini, and Ferrari quaking in its Pirellis.

I have friends who do this instead of turning. They have lots of money and no kids. Wonder if there is a correlation?

S

Re: Tool Zealots

#21

Re: Tool Zealots

Barry L Elder

My first set of turning tools was a $10 set from China. Then, after wasting a few trees in practice, I bought a set of 2030 turning tools from *********. And then, after the hurricanes of 2004 left me with several tons of wood, I piecemeal purchased some exotic steel tools from a new business. It was truly amazing that all of these tools exactly matched my "skill level" as long as they were sharp! :b

Re: Tool Zealots

#22

Re: Gotta dig a lot of dirt to justify a backhoe :

Bart Leetch

Steve

I have an antique 1962 Bobcat that I just received from my Dad along with 2 buckets a backhoe, forks & a trailer. It has no roll-cage the seat sets on top of the hydraulic tanks. It lifts about 1000# but for the most part I will keep the loads light & the turns in shallow increments to preserve it as long as possible for home use only. It has been my Dad's third hand since 1972 & only has 50 hours on a motor overhaul with a new speed changer Reeves dive system, the last known new reeves system for this Bobcat.

Re: Tool Zealots

#23

Now THAT's a Toy

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

To be proud of! Enjoy, but don't overdo it.

Re: Tool Zealots

#24

Steven Antonucci

Sounds like a party?

steven antonucci

Bobcat drag racing.

Bobcat tractor pulls.

Bobcat lifting.

I got your slogan ready to print "Bart's Bobcat Bash" (imagine B's all capitalized and flaming- flames make everything cooler!)

I'd buy that t-shirt!

S

Re: Tool Zealots

#25

Re: Tool Zealots

Barry Irby

There's a guy that lives down the street from me. He is truly a TOOL ZEALOT and wood worker extraordinaire. I've known him for about fifteen years. He knows EXACTLY which version of each tool he wants. Not just a Unisaw, but the 19XX BR549 model because we all know that's the best one ever made and they only made four of them. He searches yard sales and classifieds and attends funerals in hopes of meeting the widow to get first dibs on the late husband's tools. He lovingly restores them and sells the excess through a local store. He gets the official paint and parts from the manufacturers right down to the decals.

He believes he is doing the finest woodworking because he collects the finest tools and lavishes such attention on them. Did I mention he is a woodworker? In his own mind. There is no dust in his shop. Not that its cleaned so thoroughly. There's just never been any wood cut there. He will cut some if he ever gets the complete list of tools he wants. At least that's the dream.