AC/DC
Steve Kubien
Simple question for you electrical-savvy folks... All things being equal, will I get more torque out an AC or a DC motor? Are DC motors the ones we see with VFD's?
Thanks!
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
AC/DC
Steve Kubien
Simple question for you electrical-savvy folks... All things being equal, will I get more torque out an AC or a DC motor? Are DC motors the ones we see with VFD's?
Thanks!
Re: AC/DC
Pat Riley
Steve,
That is a fairly loaded question, because there are all types of drive configurations for both types of motors.
I guess the short answer is, given adequate cooling, a DC motor can deliver full torque all the way down to stall. An AC motor's torque curve drops off as speed is reduced below about 30% of max.
In general, DC motors give the highest torque at slow speeds.
Both of these points are assuming constant power input. If lowering the voltage is used to slow a DC motor (as is common in most simple lathe configurations) the torque will drop like crazy.
In the end, it all depends on what kind of drive configuration you choose.
Re: AC/DC
robo hippy
Not really sure here, but the other alternative is the 3 phase motor, which thanks to the converters makes that motor available to the common house hold shop. I have found the 3 phase motors superior to the DC motors for more torque, and holding torque down in the lower speed ranges.
robo hippy
Re: AC/DC
John Lucas
A 3 phase AC motor with a variable frequency Drive has much more power or torque or whatever the proper term is, than a DC motor with a speed controller. I have turned extensively on both. when you turn the speed down on a DC motor it really loses power. The AC 3phase motors with VFD still have huge amounts of power at the low settings.
The Variable Frequency drives convert 110 or 220 single phase AC to 3phase to power the motor so you can run these on standard house hold outlets.
I'm certainly not an electronics expert by any means but I have installed both DC motors and controllers and AC 3 phase motors with Variable Frequency Drives on lathes and if they were even close in price I would go with the AC.
Re: AC/DC -- The Money is not equal
Ken Vaughan
The assumption is that you are interested in Variable Speed --
For constant speed motors, AC/DC choice is one of power systems, controls etc and similar torques are expected for similar power loads -- and higher voltages have a strong correlation with bigger control panels and smaller motor size,
Variable Speed --
There are two primary flavors --
DC motors using a rectifier and variable voltage to contorol speed. These are common on small midi lathes and treadmills. Low cost and lose torque pretty fast at low motor speeds. The three pully system is there on my Jet 1014VS to give the motor more speed (and torque) for low RPMS -- low cost systems and generally low HP go together here.
Variable Frequency Drive (VFD)-- which changes single phase to three phase and uses electronics to change motor speeds. Bigger bucks and bigger motors go together here. This is the power system on higher end lathes
Generally, the VFD is the most costly and most flexible.
If money is no object -- VFD is the way to go.
Re: AC/DC
robo hippy
Although both predate my turning days, VFD phase converters are the greatest things to happen to turning along with HSS tools and scroll chucks.
robo hippy
Thanks everyone
Steve Kubien
So it looks like 3 phase AC is the wash to go (with the controller of course).
The reason I ask came from my shop this morning... I turn on a Nova 1624 which has a single phase AC motor (1.5 hp) and it is astounding how easily I stall it with wet maple on the low speed pulley. This has always been the case but it really bothered me this morning.
Thanks for the info.
Re: Thanks everyone
John Lucas
Have you checked the belt tension. I had a Nova 3000 with a 1.5 hp motor and when set on the slow speed pulley it pulled pretty hard. It could be just a matter of the belt slipping.
That lathe is what got me started on the search for variable speed. I put a DC motor on with the controller. At low speeds I could stall it very easily so I still spent a lot of time changing gears to be able to get in the proper power band for the DC controller.
then I learned about the AC variable Frequency Drives and bought one used. Same size motor but man what a difference in power especially at the lower speeds. I rarely changed the belt position on the pulleys after that.
You can get VFD on smaller lathes now. The new Delta midi has a VFD. That is a sweet lathe for the money.
Re: Thanks everyone *LINK*
Stuart Johnson
I bought my VS for my Nova 3K from Dealers Electric. You can get a motor and converter package that suits you needs. One thing I found out is call them don't try using email. That might have changed. They did have a good price and very fast delivery.
http://www.dealerselectric.com/
Re: Thanks everyone
Steve Kubien
John, I am not thinking of changing up my Nova. I am still mulling over building my own from scratch. Actually, I am mulling over a pile of things!m time and funds will tell.