Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Turning and form

Posts

Turning and form

#1

Steven Antonucci

Turning and form

steven antonucci

I am a strong believer that form can be taught at the same time that you teach sharpening, cutting, and other lathe basics. As a mathematician at heart, I am a huge fan of Golden Mean and Fibonacci numbers. It is the only mention that I make of form in my workshop because I think it's "consumable".

Here is what I explain:

Fibonacci number are a mathematical progression that starts off at the numbers 0,1. The next number in the sequence is the sum of the two prior numbers, hence the third number is also 1.

The sequence expands 2 (1+1), 3 (1+2), 5 (2+3), 8 (3+5). I usually stop giving the numbers and allow the class to progress 13,21,etc for a couple more so that I know that they know how the numbers are generated.

What happens next is I describe the ratio of the Fibonacci series (2:1,3:2, 5:3,8:5,13:8, 21:13...) and I explain that the ratio very quickly mathematically converges to phi (aka, the Golden Mean) We then walk through some of the places that the Golden Mean proportion occurs in nature (flowers, faces, leaves, etc) and how man is "wired" to expect it.

Usually, right after this very brief conversation, I see folks start making better decisions about form.

What other tools do you use to teach form?

S

Re: Turning and form

#2

Re: Turning and form

Galen Vetterick

Steve

I like Rob Wallaces presentation on form to our turners group. He had turned a variety of shapes both good and bad that were all about the same basic height and diameter. Presented two at a time and ask us which form we liked best and WHY. He could also invert the same forms for an addition variation. Made you think about good curves, flat spots, base and mouth diameter to overall piece, and by moving relation of the max. diameter to overall height.

I'm sure he could give a better explanation than what I have done here, but models are good.

Re: Turning and form

#3

Re: Turning and form

Donna Banfield

Galen, I read Steve's explanation, and being math impaired started to get a headache. Not a negative reflection on Steve, he just gets the math explanation, I don't, and never will. However, I finally understood the principles of the Fibonacci/Rule of Three's by simply studying and comparing form, just like Rob Wallace's demo to your group.

In my private woodturning courses, I always cover form and design. I have several shapes of turnings, and ask my students to pick out the ones they like and the ones they don't. We then discuss why certain shapes appeal to them, and I see the lightbulb go off by the end of the discussion.

So, just as in woodturning techniques, there are a number of different ways to accomplish the same thing. Some work, some don't. Find what works for you and go with it.

Re: Turning and form

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: Turning and form

keith tompkins

Steve, I teach various methods. A length of chain, an end held in each hand, shows the effect of a catenary curve, and that moving the hands either in, or out, still results in a pleasing curve.

I urge students to keep a sketch book, writing down ideas, pictures of shapes they like, photos and images of well-proportioned work, whether turning related or not. Use it as a reference, emulating the forms you have recorded.

Self-critique: analyze your work, learn your strong and weak points, strive to improve the shape of the next piece. Make sketches in advance; learn to visualize the outcome in advance, not as the shape develops.

Have a plan when you approach the lathe....don't let the size and shape of the blank dictate what you produce. YOU are in control. Select the piece of wood appropriate for the project you have planned.

One turning leads to new ideas, each influences the next. That way, you never run out of new pieces to turn.

Re: Turning and form

#6

Re: Turning and form

Steve Criscenzo

Keith

As a learner not a teacher, I think your advice for advance planning is a good one. I used to let the size of the blank dictate the ultimate shape of a piece (or sometimes fixing a mistake). I soon learned this was backwards. As my skills developed I learned to plan ahead and turn a designed form rather than a random form. Should a design opportunity present itself midstream (a catch, a void, bark inclusion or great grain) I take a moment to stop and revise the plan before proceeding. I turn for fun. Taking a slower approach prolongs the fun an usually results in better work. (and is safer )

Re: Turning and form

#7

Steven Antonucci

Watch the video

steven antonucci

The math isn't really that daunting. If you can add two numbers and then divide two numbers, you can follow it.

Number 1 Number 2 Ratio(Number 2/Number 1)

1 1 1

1 2 2

2 3 1.5

3 5 1.66

5 8 1.6

8 13 1.625

...

If you continued to do this towards infinity, you would see that the number converged on the golden mean. The implications of this are staggering, because it shows that there is order in the universe as defined by the objects that the universe allows to be built.

Pretty crazy concept, huh?

S

Re: Turning and form

#8

Steve Kubien

Re: Turning and form

Steve Kubien

I don't teach classes but when I discuss form and shape with someone, I go back to Bill Grumbine's DVD and tell folks to look at their fruit bowl and in their fridge at an egg (especially eggs). Take any part of an eggs curve and you are so close to perfect that, well, it is perfect in my mind. Lots simpler than numbers although a diagram of Fib. Would probably work too.

Re: Turning and form

#9

Re: Turning and form

Terry Scott

A bath chain and

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catenary

Re: Turning and form

#10

Joe Fleming

Re: Turning and form

Joe Fleming

Steve,

As some others have suggested, I focus on concrete things that a person can use, instead of abstract concepts. I developed a list of "rules" that I present with examples, and I use the dialog of the class to expand the list when new ideas present themselves. Find the flat spots, do not let the mounting technique dictate the size of the base, relationships of bases to openings, etc. My goal is that the participant can take home usable tools.

Joe Fleming - San Diego

Re: Turning and form

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: Turning and form

keith tompkins

A couple of more things to keep in mind. I think ratios such a the golden mean are good starting place, but there are other factors. For example, a piece may posess perfect proportions, yet contain flat spots, a huge base, poor curves, etc. Connecting the points with a catenary curve helps. I often take a less than perfectly proportioned blank, such as a cube, and see what I can turn from it. That forces me to apply fair curves, and be aware of emphasis points, etc. in order to create a good form. Another thing I do is experiment with small sample pieces.... models or maquettes. I sit them on a shelf, just to look at them for a while. Then, I duplicate the best one in full size.

Re: Turning and form

#12

Thirds & Fifths *LINK*

charlie belden

There is no General Rule for ALL types of turning.

For "hollow forms" (including vases), The Rule of Thirds and The Rule of Fifths work pretty well.

Here's the illustration of the terms used for the next two illustrations (I NEED illustrations)


For Wider Than Tall pieces here's different examples of The Rule of Thirds and Fifths


And here's the illustrations for Taller Than Wide pieces


These are GIF file you can download, print, laminate - and hang on the wall near the lathe.

Russ Fairfield had some pretty good rules - though his all text description of them were difficult for me to visualize.

Having A PLAN often leads to better results than starting with no plan at all.

Taking photos of pieces you really like into a CAD program lets you scale things and work out the proportions. After a while you'll start planning pieces that use what you've discovered. Once you turn enough pieces from A Plan, you won't need A Plan - you'll just see when what you've got on the lathe does or doesn't look right - and figure out what needs changing.

More - with illustrations at the attached link


Design, Proportions

Re: Turning and form

#13

Steven Antonucci

Thirds and fifths are Golden mean numbers ...

steven antonucci

in the Fibonacci series 2,3,5... 2/3, 3/5...

They are approximations on phi... which is why they work. :)

I don't go out to 97 decimal places, but I bet the things that I have made that are better get a few extra decimals closer...

S