Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Copying or "Sampling"

Posts

Copying or "Sampling"

#1

Copying or "Sampling"

charlie belden

I'm getting back to laser engraving and low relief laser carving with the idea of incorporating lasered patterns in some pieces. So I'm back to scouring the internet for interesting images or parts of images that I might be able to use. Which got me wondering about the difference between Copying and Sampling.

If I take samplings of pieces of music, mix them together so that the results may contain some remnant of the original music sampled - but sounds significantly different - am I "copying' - or - creating?

If I take a shape or form some other turners has created and is known for, and combine some of it with something from another turner's piece - am I copying, sampling or creating?

Since what I'm after will involve using a laser engraver to do a pattern or low relieve "carving" in a piece, and since that pattern might be from "samplings" of images created by others - is it only the end result that matters - or is it how it was arrived at?

Re: Copying or "Sampling"

#2

Re: Copying or "Sampling"

avalon

if it's even vaguely recognizable as the original, it's a violation of copyright..

Re: Copying or "Sampling"

#3

Re: Copying or "Sampling"

Ed Moore in SW VA

If you take the material from one source you are copying. If you take material from multiple sources you are doing research.

Ed

Re: Copying or "Sampling"

#4

Re: Copying or "Sampling"

charlie belden

Ah - but there's the Fair Use thing - with "monetary benefit" criteria. If the user of the idea, creation, concept, uses it/them for personal use or receives no monetary benefit from the use . . .

In my case, the only benefit derived is the satisfaction of the finished piece - the way I envisioned it - albeit perhaps starting with ideas and images created by others.

While Molly Winton's pyrographed horses are obviously taken from similar, but much older, cave paintings, the carved patterns by Gary Fisher are taken from much older Alaskan indigenous peoples' carvings and patterns in David Nittman's basket weave pieces emulate Native American woven basket patterns - each of these artists has"sampled" earllier works by others - and made them their own in their medium.

So is the difference only that the original copyright has expired?

Re: Copying or "Sampling"

#5

Re: Copying or "Sampling"

Keith Newton

Charlie, I would like to hear more about what you have in mind. Could you elaborate more on what you hope to achieve?

Maybe you can get permission to use an image if that is what you would be needing to use for the laser image.

Re: Copying or "Sampling"

#6

Steven Antonucci

If you have to ask...

steven antonucci

Odds are, you will know when you are doing one or the other. Laser engraving Snoopy on a bowl is copying. Laser engraving Snoopy on a dogwood bowl is art (dogwood, satire is protected...)

The difference is in some kind of transformation. You need to use an idea in a new way. Do that, and you're golden.

S

Re: Copying or "Sampling"

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: Copying or "Sampling"

keith tompkins

Charlie, clip-art is available for the purpose you describe. No copyright is involved. We, as woodturners, seem to share freely, but this is not the case in the "real"world. One example: BB King sued the Doobie Brothers, and won, for stealing one of his songs. "The thrill is gone" was morphed into "Long Train Runnin'"....seems like quite a stretch, but nevertheless, King won.

There are books available on copyright laws as they apply to the art world...every aspiring artist/craftsperson should read up on the subject. Eye-opening reading!

Re: Copying or "Sampling"

#8

Re: Copying or "Sampling" *LINK*

charlie belden

The attached link takes you to a couple of web pages I put together on laser engraving on wood that should give you an idea of what can be done with a laser engraver. The second page has examples of Gray Scale to Low Relief 3D "carving". There are, on the second page, actual examples on wood, including a couple on turned walnut pieces.

To complicate things - the images I've been gathering - were generated by computer programs - that are Open Source - the software downloadable. So I COULD generate my "own" images by changing values of variables being used to generate patterns. Which raises another question about Use & Creator Rights. If a computer generates the images, based on an Open Source software application which a User can change variable values in - who or what is the Creator?

Anyway, here are thumbnails of a set of images I got off the internet - all tweeked in PhotoShop to a greater or lesser degree and all selected for "low relief carving" using a laser engraver. To the laser, WHITE means don't burn here at all, BLACK means burn at maximum power - and therefore Depth, with 253 shades of white to black grays in between, resulting in a total of 256 "steps" of depth of cut - over 1/8" of total depth.

These thumbnail images are half to a quarter the size of the actual image so some of the fine lines in the original aren't in the thumbnails.


The laser engraver makes in possible to put designs in pieces that would be nearly impossible to do by hand with any hand held cutting tools, especially the low relief "carving" designs. And some of the results can be extemely subtle and nuanced, visible only with the piece in hand and in the right lighting. If used well, experiencing a piece as it might be presented in a gallery would be that of a normal, un-laser embellished piece could be significantly different than what one could experience with the piece in hand.

If you look at the bottom image of the second page of the linked to web page you may get an idea of just how subtle this "gray scale low relief carving" done with a laser can be with lighting that accentuates the shadows.


Idea & Early Experiments

Re: Copying or "Sampling"

#9

Re: Copying or "Sampling"

charlie belden

I'll have to ask Pat about that law suit. (He played dulcimer at my first wedding and used to play acoustic guitar in my living room before or after playing at a folk music club acrossed the street). I suspect that it wasn't BB KIng's idea to suit the Doobie Bros. More likely it was his manager's or lawyer's idea,

Legal issues aren't a concern to me since I'm not selling anything, thus not depriving any artist of revenue by my use.

But the question remains regarding the use of "sampling". Is a "mash up" of existing ideas "copying". If what we call "creativity" is more accurately "synthesis" - combining existing things and ideas in a new way - are all artists "sampling" and "creating" Mash Ups?

Re: Copying or "Sampling"

#10

Richard Allen

Re: Copying or "Sampling"

Richard Allen

Diminished value. You don't have to sell or make money from a copy for there to be money involved. The owner of the copyright may sue you for diminished value of original because of your use of their intellectual property.

Re: Copying or "Sampling"

#11

Re: Copying or "Sampling"

charlie belden

In the Open Source community / culture, a core value is that knowledge and the use of it should be freely shared, thus increasing the probability that more knowledge will be created - and shared. Kind of like this Turning Community. By freely sharing, everyone in the community benefits, as do others not in the community.

If you go back to the early days of computer networking there were Command Line Only - Dial Up Accessible forums where information was freely shared. The Well, set up by Stewart Brandt, the guy who did The Whole Earth Catalogue, was one of the early places for info and ideas exchanges. Later, UseNet expanded on that idea and SIGs (special interest groups ) proliferated. Later, forums websites sprang up, adding more capabilities to share knowledge and info easier. And all that was done FOR FREE - at least to the users / participants - just like this site.

Only when The Profit Motive entered the picture did Pay To Participate- and all the exclusionary things that go with that enter the picture.

If Intellectual Property Rights were enforced - there'd probably be no MicroSoft. It was Excel, that ripped of Visicalc's spreadsheet idea - and made it easier to use, thus becoming one of the earliest Killer Apps, that realy got MicroSoft on the map - Not MSDOS - or the ripped off GUI clone of Apple's idea - "borrowed" from Xerox PARC . . .

Knowledge and the growth of knowledge always escapes attempts to constrain it. And not even the threat of Eternal Damnation can stop it. It was the exchange of knowledge that brought the light to The Dark Ages.

Re: Copying or "Sampling"

#12

Re: Copying or "Sampling"

Ron Sardo

Infringement is in the eyes of the copyright holder. There are people and companies that make more money suing people on copyright infringement than they will make selling the image or product.

They may not always win, but it will always cost you if you have to defend yourself in court.

The best rule of thumb is... When in doubt, don't...

Re: Copying or "Sampling"

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: Copying or "Sampling"

keith tompkins

Charlie, we share freely on this site, but as far as I'm concerned, only up to a point. Some people get the idea that anything in woodturning is fair game, but that's just not so. I think as the field matures, you will discover less and less such a sharing atmosphere.

Re: Copying or "Sampling"

#14

Re: Copying or "Sampling"

charlie belden

Keith:

Like other well known turners with Signature Pieces / Styles, not only evolve tehcniques but also new ideas - that remain recognizable as done by you - at a glance. Thus, you avoid getting trapped by one Signature Piece idea. The advantage to developing a recognizable style is that by the time others start doing Knock Offs - you've moved on - and ahead of those folks who lag behind you as they learn a specific technique - and often misuse it.

I'm not sure people who jump around, as I do with my Wild Hare ideas, can ever get a following since there's no common technique or look and each foray into the Wilderness results in completely different techniques and applications.

I sincerely hope that the Sharing which has taken turning so far so fast and in so many directions - continues.

Re: Copying or "Sampling"

#15

I was out in Southern Cal back in 1978,

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

When the first wood cutting lasers were still being developed, and wanted to get my hands on one for some ideas that I had working in my head.

The place making them was in Santa Rosa, so when I left LaJolla, to head back to AR, I drove up to visit them. None of the people working at the place were woodworkers, nor artist. They were all engineers.

Do you own one, or are they affordable now? I was wondering how large they can handle, even flat work.

I have been getting encouraged to do a book, of my photos, and have been working on it. I would like,,,,,,, well my goal is to finish it by next April for the literary festival here, and would like to have some of my woodwork along with the book. If I sent you some photos, could you advise me as to what might work.

I think I have gotten an email from you before, so drop me an email if you are interested, and I will send you some photos.

Re: Copying or "Sampling"

#16

Re: I was out in Southern Cal back in 1978,

John Jordan

I had high hopes for that "eternal damnation" thing, too. Shoot.......... :)

John