I have a friend who drives to Richmond and back for work. He has found that the gas bought at a local (almost always cheaper than anywhere else) station does not given the same miles/gallon as gas from a different but a little more expensive station. The octane rating at both places is the same as is the % of ethanol.
...corn juice" to be the culprit. There are so many other variables it would be hard to say for sure, such as how much does he use the A/C, ambient temperatures, etc........
If the pumps here say "up to 10% ethanol". I've always figured that could mean less than 10% but not more than 10%. It could be the station with the better mileage is 7 or 8% not the full 10%.
a gas station that was filling their tanks partially with water until they got greedy and someone's car just quit in their parking lot. At least ethanol burns.
It could be along these lines, where they have extra moisture in their pumps and it affects the car slowly before killing it. The guy I knew had his entire engine block replaced because it was rusted inside out.
I was using the cheap stuff (Arco) in my mini van. Got 310 to 320 miles before the 'need gas light' came on. Wasn't near one once when I needed gas, and tried one of the more expensive ones. Miles per tank went to 380 to 410 (Shell) depending on which of the more expensive ones I used.
HI Barbara, This might help..First, where do the off-brand gas stations get their fuel supply from? They certainly haven't invested in their own refineries. They buy their gas at auction....they literally bid on what's left in the "bottom of the barrel" of the major suppliers' tanks. Condensation forms inside metal tanks, which being heavier than gasoline, sinks to the bottom, along with rust, scale, dirt, and other debris. Adding alcohol makes matters worse..alcohol is hygroscopic; in other words, it absorbs water from the atmosphere. (That's why we add "dry gas" er...alcohol to our fuel tank when water is suspected. It freely mixes with water, creating molecules small enough to pass through the vehicle's system, thereby ridding the system of water.) Reputable suppliers regularly test their fuel supply; when it doesn't pass....it's acutioned off. It gets worse. In some states, including New York, the premium fuel offered at the pumps MUST be what's on the label. For example a Sunoco station must sell Sunoco high test, BUT everything else is fair game. They can purchase their regular grade from the "entrepreneur" who just won his fuel at a recent auction. Lucky you!
Alcohol and water mixtures form all kinds of nasty, corrosive, compounds inside your fuel system..that's why you MUST drain your equipment's fuel over the winter months...if not, it's rebuild or replacement time. "Octane" ratings can be confusing...low octane fuel contains as much energy as high-octane fuels; consumer guides almost ALWAYS recommend buying the lowest octane level fuels, because there is no difference in fuel economy tests. The reason for higher octane levels is for use in high-performance, high-compression engines. High-octane fuels burn slower than low-octane stuff, so it ignites at the proper time, not before. Pre-ignition (pinging or detonation), caused by running low-octane fuel in a high-compression engine will destroy it in short order. Modern fuel system designs utilize a computer to detect, and compensate for, engine-damaging detonation. Alcohol does not contain as much energy per gallon as as gasoline, so adding it to the fuel supply will decrease your fuel mileage, even though adding alcohol may (artificially) raise the octane rating, allowing it to be sold as "high-test" by some. Bottom line...better fuel costs more, and will give better mileage.
A few years back, my dad complained that his fuel injected sedan would stall when pausing at the top of the grade at the end of his driveway before entering the busy roadway. I was confused because the fuel injection and electronics of the engine on his fairly new car should not cause any problems. I told him that the additives in the fuel should protect the injectors and keep system clean. He informed me that he wasn't going to pay for that brand of fuel and got his discount gas for $0.05 per gal less. That choice cost him a set of injectors because without the refinery filtering the particles out of the gas and providing fuel additives to keep the injection system clean as the major brands do, the injectors will wear to oval tips and must be replaced. Back then the cost was about $800.00. Using a major brand even at a higher price makes a difference not only in fuel economy but reliability as well.
Because of all the new genetic information and the newest scientific studies about Bladder cancer, which I once had (past tense, I hope), I am trying to compile a health history for my two small great-grandsons. My question for those who may be up-to-date on the latest storage systems: What will be the most survivable storage system for information that will be used 40 - 50 years in the future. I have heard rumors that DVDs and CDs may not hold up for 50 years. I do not want to store something on a system like a Cassette tape that will become obsolete.
Lots of good info given already. I must agree with Jamie on the "Corn Juice" If the government didn't mandate it inclusion in our gas and subsidize it's production they couldn't sell the stuff. I've found that my mileage is better by 10% or more with non ethanol fuels. A local farm supply store used to sell the 87 octane without ethanol but now only the 89 octane is available without it so when the price is 10% or less difference that's what I buy. Also, with purchases in the store one gets a coupon worth 4 cents per gallon off. Like Keith states, they likely buy their fuels from other suppliers but be sure that farmers will not put up with bad fuel products.
Another local problem we have here is that most of the local stations, including multiple brands, are owed by one owner and he sets the price so in our town gas is typically 5 cents a gallon higher than neighboring towns. I've noticed it as much as 20 cents different. I routinely drive north to care for my Mom so I try to fuel up there. And, the same farm supply has a store there so that's an additional discount.
Always buy your gas in the morning. Cooler gas weighs more per gallon. Weight(mass)is what actually matters in the chemical reaction in your engine. Has your friend been buying his gas at different times of day due to convenience of location of the stations?
The back-flow cut-off sensors at the different stations may have more/less sensitivity to the fullness of the vehicle's tank. Perhaps a full tank is not really full. Speed of delivery(pump pressure) can greatly affect the amount of blow-back that these sensors see.
Funny...I last filled up at Valero station (which is also a major brand and never cheaper) instead of my usual Exxon station and have noticed what seems to be a fairly significant drop in mpg. I will check the actual numbers when I next fill...at Exxon. That last fill was the first of the summer when there have been big temp changes and huge humidity changes so maybe it's the water. And don't they increase the amount of ethanol in gas during the peak (summer) driving months or is it the same year round now? And I hear they are now going to go to 15%! All in the name of the corn industry!
BTW...anyone who wants to see what's behind the corn industry (and industrialized agriculture in general, including the government's manipulation) should read Michael Pollan's "The Omnivore's Dilemma: A Natural History of Four Meals" It sure opened my eyes!
For what it's worth, I run only Shell Premium in my motorcycle, a high-compression 4 cylinder bike built in the early '70's. It won't tolerate anything else...4 carburetors, no computer feedback system. Last I knew, Shell is the only company that doesn't add alcohol to its' premium gas. I started using the stuff in all my lawn equipment, even though it costs more....I haven't had to overhaul any carburetors since.
I am quoting a petroleum engineer's response to the myth about purchasing gasoline in the morning.
This has to be one of the goofiest things I�ve heard of. The gasoline is buried in underground tanks, surrounded by tons of dirt, therefore the temperature of the tanks will only minimally fluctuate.
If there are gasoline temperature variations, it is seasonal (winter vs. summer) not daily.
What I can tell you, NEVER buy gas while the tanker is filling the station's underground tanks...all the sediment on the bottom of the tank is stirred up, just waiting for you to fill up.
I've tracked my fuel economy tank by tank for the past 11 years. There is so much scatter in the data that I think it's impossible to figure out that one station is better than the next.
It could be that the pump at the cheap station "clicks-off" earlier when filling up than the pump at the expensive station, so your tank isn't as full at the cheap station (maybe due to less anti-foaming additives?)
Anyway, when I used to work at a refinery (many moons ago; before ethanol became big), only one retailer put a different additive in their fuel. All other retailers drove their trucks up to our refinery, filled them the with the same gas as the next guy, and sold the same gas to everyone but claimed "their" gas was better than everyone elses. :-) If you live in an area with multiple refineries then maybe you can get different blends, but otherwise everyone is probably getting the same gas.
My uncle ran a station for forty years or more and bought his gas where it was cheapest or from whoever had it. He swore there was no difference.
About the flour thing, I did a home inspection for a guy who packaged butter. He said butter was butter. They ran these packaging machines 24/7 and they almost never stopped. To change brands all they did was change the boxes they loaded into the machines. Absolutely no difference in the product.
I have not checked my mileage in years. I need gas to do the things I want to do so I just fill up and drive off. I use regular in my pickup and high test in my motorcycle.
I get it at the same station all the time. They pump the gas for me. That makes me happy and the owner happy too. His gas is the same price as the station down the road that I have to get out of the truck and pump.
I don't like gas prices but I sure as crap am not going to start walking 15 miles to the grocery store.
You are part right, However the temperature of the above ground or near surface changes throughout the day. All the near piping, pumps, the dispenser, hose and nozzle warm up. I recently purchased gas during the afternoon. The first fifteen seconds of flow were much warmer until the colder below ground fuel got there. There was at least a 10� sudden difference as I was holding the nozzle.