Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Keepsake Chalice 1 of 2

Posts

Keepsake Chalice 1 of 2

#1

Keepsake Chalice 1 of 2

Steve Criscenzo

Each year for the past several years I have been asked to make a chalice as a gift for the outgoing president of our church Board. I consider it an honor to be asked to provide this gift and I try to make each one special and unique.

This year I was asked to make two chalices. The challenge was to make two items similar enough that one did not outshine the other but yet make them unique.

The results are below. Each is about 10" in diameter and 4-5 inches high. Tops are ambrosia maple and bottoms are mahogany (I think).

Comments welcome.

Steve


Re: Keepsake Chalice 1 of 2

#2

Nicely Done.

Greg Haugen

That's a unique commission idea that you've executed beautifully. Well Done.

Re: Keepsake Chalice 1 of 2

#3

Steven Antonucci

Good finishes

steven antonucci

Like all of the elements in both, but I think I'd like the cove bottom better on the rounded one, and the angular bottom on the straighter one. Kind of like to like elements...

I'd also agree that the wood is ambrosia maple...

S

Re: Keepsake Chalice 1 of 2

#4

Re Like elements

Steve Criscenzo

Steve

It is interesting that you commented on the bases. They were interchangeable so I tried them both ways several times and spent way to much time staring at them trying to decide which way to go. Turns out I liked the cove base on both better. I ultimately put it on the straight one because I liked how the top of the cove flowed into to bottom of the bowl.

I knew that the bowls were ambrosia maple but the bases came from a scrap bin at a lumber yard so I am only guessing they are mahogany. They have a beautiful glow as they are rotated in the light.

Thanks for your comments.

Re: Keepsake Chalice 1 of 2

#5

Steven Antonucci

I have a thing about "pointy beads" :-)

steven antonucci

If I liked the cove better on both of them, why not return the pointy bead into a cove? Form follows function- and if these are mean to be held by the handle, then that pointy bead one probably needs to be changed.

S

Re: Keepsake Chalice 1 of 2

#6

Re: I have a thing about "pointy beads" :-)

Steve Criscenzo

Yea, I know but I was up against a deadline and I did not want to ruin a workable solution. (with my luck I would have had a nasty catch and sent it flying. )

The chalices are meant to sit on a table so the base does not get much attention. Likely, only I will be critical.

Good comments though.

Re: Keepsake Chalice 1 of 2

#7

Steven Antonucci

Good enough is the enemy of great

steven antonucci

I try to discourage people from accepting their own medicority. If I know that something isn't right with a piece, I won't put it out there even if I know that no one else will see it. I will always see it.

In the end, you learn more from failing than you do from succeeding. If it comes off the lathe, you make another one. If it is a little bit off you fix it. Never settle for good enough, because the truth is that good enough isn't.

S

Re: Keepsake Chalice 1 of 2

#8

Keith Tompkins

Re: I have a thing about "pointy beads" :-)

keith tompkins

Steve, A suggestion...the thought of getting a catch should never come into play. Like Steve A. says, alway do your best. I have a theory..."fear" prevents us from advancing as turners. It could be fear of a catch. Fear of trying something new. Fear of relying on our own sense of style. If we don't push beyond our comfort zone, our work becomes "static", we become frustrated at the lack of progress. It's also good to understand WHY one base looks better than the other. One base contains flowing curves, which compliments the flowing curve of the bowl form. The other does not; the base doesn't have much in common with the bowl. Hope this helps.