For some reason, I cannot true anything on my lathe. A simple test is to true a disk and then mark the rim with chalk. The disk is held by a PSI chuck using a 2 1/8" recess and the live center of the tail stock. When I lay my tool against the rim, the disk rim taps the tool edge to generate a light tak-tak-tak noise. If I try to do a light cut, some areas on the rim will get cut but some area will not. I can make a deep enough cut to get rid of the ink but the same thing will happen if I recoat the rim with chalk.
I do know that the headstock and tail stock are aligned. There is no play at both the front and rear bearings. There is no vibration at the live center. I do feel vibration at the hand wheel. My suspicion is the PSI chuck and the spindle adapter to convert the chuck for 1.25"x8TPI spindle. At this moment, I do not have a larger Forstner bit to make a recess for my Stronghold chuck. I just ordered one so I will be able to try this with ba Stronghold chuck next week.
Run it without the chuck and see if the spindle is running true. Also sometimes the insert can be off because of sawdust. Take the insert out, clean it up and try again.
If you take several light passes until the tool does not bounce it will be round. If not then it could be a problem with your wood, tool usage or both. Summer and winter wood have different hardness. If you push on the bevel with more than light pressure it can make the tool bounce. This will of course make a wavy surface. Make several light cuts. push the tool down on the tool rest and not into the work. Hopefully that will help. It's always hard to trouble shoot when your not at the machine.
Barbara's tip of looking at the chuck to see if it's running true is a good one.
I took your suggestion and I turned a dowel between a steb drive center and live center. I did not have the tool edge bouncing problem when I rest the tool edge against the rounded surface. This leads me to believe that the problem is mostly likely with the PSI chuck and/or the spindle adapter. I just ordered a larger Forstner bit so that I can use my Stronghold chuck to repeat my disk experiment.
Bowls will tend to exhibit this sort of behavior. To reduce the effects of the wood and the tools test with plain kiln dried wood (no figure) freshly sharpened tools and run the lathe at (9000/diameter) rpm.
The most likely cause of the bounce is wood movement.
If the wood is dry the the second most likely cause is cutting at a slow speed where the tool can move in and out as the side grain/end grain spins around.
If you are turning at a reasonable speed then the next most likely cause is a tool that is less than sharp.
The chuck or spindle adapter can't cause the condition you describe.
I use a Forstner bit recess in the top with dove tail jaws (Vickmark) all the time. If you have the jaws bottomed out in the recess, and the face of the chuck is not on the wood, it shouldn't be a problem.
One common problem with turning bowls is that the wood cuts differently when going through end grain and side grain on the sides of the bowl. This can induce a bit of a bounce as you go from the base to the rim (outside of the bowl). Interesting thing is that the more you fight it, the worse it gets. Most of the time, my left hand is just resting on the tool, not holding it down, and I do not keep that hand on the tool rest. This could be the problem. Wood movement is a problem on the inside of the bowl when you start removing the mass, and the walls can flex, but not a problem when turning the outside of the bowl. Trick to getting rid of the bounce is to bring the gouge or scraper back off the wood a bit and take off the high spot till you are round again, then go on down the side.
You should also check your set screws for your chuck jaws as they some times work loose.
I usually just drill a 3/8" hole and use the "woodworm" screw. I attach the piece of wood to my Stronghold, true up the bottom and turn a recess. I then remove the wood from my chuck and the "woodworm" screw and flip the blank.
Run the test with another chuck. I am local to the PSI store and have a number of their tools. You get what you pay for with them, Quality control is a recurring problem with many of their items.
For me, the forstner bit is more efficient. You have to drill a hole either way. With the screw center, you need an almost perfectly flat surface for the chuck that the screw bit is in in order for the blank to seat properly. Most blanks are not that flat without extra prep work. Forstner bit drills a flat spot on any piece, you put your chuck into the recess, expand and turn. Turn a recess or tenon, for reversing, and your chuck never has to come off the lathe, and no screw bit to remove either.
Id suggest its your chuck I have many chucks but have one Ive put aside as it is evident that the internal thread is not drilled and taped properly .
I brought a brand new chuck and sent it back to Tekanatool giving them a real wind up their answer (i felt real foolish )when the chuck came back with a note please fit jaws in sequence 1 2 3 4
Not for the faint hearted but if I get the vibration problems you have I turn up the speed and play around until I find the sweet spot.
Another thing to try is mount work on a face plate and see how it runs .I never turn with recesses as I believe chucks are designed to work in compression not expansion mode.