Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Sanding grits

Posts

Sanding grits

#1

Sanding grits

robo hippy

Well, with all the different abrasives out there, there is one thing I have seen that is a bit different. That is instead of the 220 grit, it is 260 or 280. While those grit numbers fall into the 1/2 the grit before, plus that grit for the next higher grit, I find that I don't like the higher grit number. Mostly I guess it is because when I go from 220 to 180, there always seems to be some 120 scratches show up, and I can get them out with 220 fairly easily, but with the 260 or 280, it is very difficult.

Any one else have this problem?

robo hippy

Re: Sanding grits

#2

Dick Hines

Re: Sanding grits

Dick Hines

I think the grit number on different sand paper is not the same. I only use one knid of sheet paper and only one kind of disk. Although they are from two different suppliers if I don't interchange them they should be the same. That way ,to my thinking, the grits should be same all the time.

Re: Sanding grits

#3

Steven Antonucci

(this is the answer!)

steven antonucci

I am 100% sure that he's got the answer.

If you start to mix and match suppliers, they may not use the same particle sizes. I use a brand that goes 120,180,240,320,400,600. I used to use Norton which was 100, 150,220,320.

If you co-mingle, the skip sometimes gets too large.

S

Re: Sanding grits

#4

Re: Sanding grits

robo hippy

I know there are two standards of measuring grits. That isn't it. Different abrasives will be different. I have found this with Vince's blue discs, and he has 220 and 280 in it.

I tried his new pink stuff, which has 280. The 120 pink is comparable to the blue, the 180 is pretty close, though maybe a tiny bit finer, but the 280 is much finer than the 220 blue, and similar to the 280 blue.

The 280 just won't pull the 120 grit scratches out, at least not without a lot more sanding.

robo hippy

Re: Sanding grits

#5

Re: Sanding grits

john lucas

I don't know about you but I've been having trouble lately with sanding lines. I don't know if it's my eye sight, the lighting, not cleaning the sawdust out of the grit marks or what. I am using the same sandpaper for all grits, (Vinces) It all started when I move to this house which is why I think it's a combination of lighting and not cleaning the sawdust out after each grit well enough.

I've thought about using a different light source, and then using Naptha or some other solvent on a rag to wipe between grits to hopefull show up the scratches better. I also plan to use my air compressor. I think what's happening is the sawdust is filling the scratches and I can't see them. I sand very carefully. and dust between each grit. It absolutely looks perfect until I get to about 320 grit and then they show up. Bummer, back to the starting grit or one above and sand again.

To make matters worse it's almost on bowls or pllatters. Rarely on boxes, spindles, hollow vessels, ornaments or mirrors.

Re: Sanding grits

#6

Re: Sanding grits

steve worcester

Johns problem sounds like it may be not lingering long enough in a certain grit, what grit that is I don'T know.

The interesting thing is the grit numbers are usually the same from P grit to P (Euro) or ANSI to ANSI (US) as theoretically those are standards for grain size, but between different product lines in the same manufacturer they will leave a different scratch pattern. I see it in my own product line (Mirka) between the every day Royal product and then if you switch from a 320 to a 360 Abralon (and Siasoft in Vince's product) you will see a difference.

I don't know why if they are the same type of abrasive but a different bonding or substrate, you see the difference, but you do. Use it to your advantage. Sand with the one up to a certain grit and then switch to the other to reveal the evil scratches left behind.

Re: Sanding grits

#7

Steve Kubien

Re: Sanding grits

Steve Kubien

I am using Vince's blue disc's as well. The grits I have are 80, 120, 180, 280, 400 and 600. I have no issue removing the scratches left by the 120 by using the 180 and the same goes from 180-280). Are you using the 180?

Re: Sanding grits

#8

Re: Sanding grits

Jorge Casta�eda

Yes, I have the same problem

Re: Sanding grits

#9

Sanding under a diffused light source....

JamieDonaldson

...such as fluorescent doesn't show distinct surface scratches as well as directional lighting. And of course O'Tool's Law dictates that the scratches don't become visible until the finish is applied, and then has to be removed for further sanding!

Re: Sanding grits

#10

Re: Sanding grits

Stuart Johnson

Someone posted about scratches popping out if you jump from say 180 to 320 or maybe they went to 400 or higher. You see the scratches and then go back down to the proper sequence of 220 and move on up the chain. I haven't tried it but the way it was explained it made sense.

Re: Sanding grits

#11

Re: Sanding grits

john lucas

Steve I take lots of time with each grit and look closely and carefully. I dust the bowl off between grits and look again. If I see uneven scratches I touch these up before going on to the next grit.

I've even taken pieces outside to look at them. It's almost always light woods that give me troubles. I have re-turned 10 cherry bowls and 2 walnut bowls and didn't see the problems in them. When I turned the latest Bradford pear pieces I had scratches in both and had to touch them up.

Re: Sanding grits

#12

Re: Sanding grits

Stephen Mushinski

Ditto what John says! I often take the turning outside with better light as way too often I have gone back to say 220 when I thought I was done and ready for finish. I have also been guilty of case hardening the wood by sanding too fast with finer grits. Then you have just about screwed yourself as it sure is a pain to try and fix it, it you can. :)

Re: Sanding grits

#13

Re: Sanding under a diffused light source....

bill Crommett

O'Toole has his hammock permanently hung next to my lathe.

Re: Sanding grits

#14

Re: Sanding grits

Vince Welch

Robo Reed,

Communication is a delicate thing... especially writing over the internet. I am not exactly sure what you were saying but I am going to take a shot at understanding what you meant and reply.

If I understand correctly what I beleive you are saying is 120 grit scratches sand out easier when using 220 grit but if you try to sand out scratches using 280 grit instead of 220 grit your success rate decreases dramatically? Maybe I have this understanding right and maybe not. I'll wait for your reply.

However, as most of us know the standard progression is usually something close too 80,120,180,220,320,400,600 etc. The idea being we do not progress more then 2x the grit number last used. As I have spoke to many of you over the course of time you know I offer extensive grit progressions such as 80,100,120,150,180,220,280,320,400,600 etc and I suggestion taking smaller steps if your budget allows. The reason is if you were to walk up or down a flight of stairs if you misstepped the closer the steps are together the less likely you would hurt your angle/foot! The farther apart the steps are the harder it might be to catch your mistake. So, if you sand 80,120,180 and you should have swapped your 120 you may or may not get away with the error. But if you sand 80,100,120,150,180 chances are... even though you should have swapped the 120 grit you will still have success because you sanded with the 100 before and 150 and 180 after the 120 grit. Robo, I know you and I have spoke about this and are in aggreement concerning this. So, partaining to your situation, I beleive your 120 grit marks should be removed with the 150 and 180 grit discs. 280 grit can be used to remove 220 and at most 180 grit. 150 and above is considered fine sanding. Most of us as turners do not think of 150 as "fine sanding" because we sand much higher such as 400 and above. When I get to 280 grit MOST of my visible scratches (domestic woods) are gone and I finish out by sanding lightly with 320, 400 etc. Hopefully this helps, Vince

Re: Sanding grits

#15

Re: Sanding grits

robo hippy

I guess that what I am saying that jumping from 180 to 280 is too big of a jump, at least for me. Hate it when I am done sanding and notice scratch marks from lower grits. I don't blow out my pieces, but generally wipe with my hand. Finer saw dust from a higher grit will pack into coarser grit scratches and high lite them. Usually works for me. I have noticed a lot more of them if I jump to the 280, and have been wondering if it was just me. Usual grit sequence for me is 80 some times, 120 usual start, then 180, 220, 320, and 400. I used to use 100, and 150 in the mix as well, but generally found out that it didn't make much difference. The hardest scratches to get rid of are the 80 grit scratches.

Lighting is a key factor here. I am using a Blue Max light that has a full spectrum type of bulb in it, and if you know some one who does fine sewing, they all have an Ott or Blue Max type of lamp. Almost as good as sun light.

robo hippy

Re: Sanding grits

#16

Re: Sanding grits

john lucas

Based on the size of the scratches that show I agree that it's probably the first grit used, in my case usually 120 if I have to remove tool marks. I'm going to switch back to a hand held light with a clear bulb for my initial inspection. I find these produce harder shadows which show up scratches better and being able to change the angle of the light easily will also help. I'll let you know how it goes. I"ll be turning another pear piece early next week.

Re: Sanding grits

#17

Re: Sanding grits

Stuart Johnson

Lighting is a key factor here. I am using a Blue Max light that has a full spectrum type of bulb in it, and if you know some one who does fine sewing, they all have an Ott or Blue Max type of lamp. Almost as good as sun light.

If I took my wife's Ott light out to the shop I wouldn't have to ever worry about scratches again.

Re: Sanding grits

#18

Re: Sanding grits

John Lucas

I'm not sure those are the best lights to use. They have a nice color and they are bright but the actual light source is kind of large. What I think we need is a smaller point light source. these produce stronger shadows than large lights and are more likely to show up scratches. That is what I used to use and it wound up missing after my move. I think small LED lights with a single bulb might work. What I used to use is a clean incandescent light bulb. The filament than becomes the light source and it's fairly small.

My mother has one of the OTT lights. They are bright but don't try to photograph with one. Even though they claim to be daylight I could not balance the color correctly with any setting on my camera.

Re: Sanding grits

#19

Steve Kubien

Re: Sanding grits

Steve Kubien

In my limited experience, a small LED light is great on the outside of a bowl/form. Takes a bit of work to maneuver it to really see the scratches on the inside. I use one of those IKEA lamps that were all rage a few months ago.

Re: Sanding grits

#20

Re: Sanding grits

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

I use a modified lapidary technique for sanding, In sanding rocks into gems (there is no grain) you sand the finer grit perpendicular to the coarser grit. The finer scratches leave a fog over the coarse scratches. When no coarse scratches are visible, sand by hand with the finer grit parallel to the spindle. Now change to the next finer grit. Repeat the tic-tac-toe procedure. At each change of paper always blow off turning, your hands, and the next grit paper. It takes only ONE stray grain of a larger grit to screw things up.

The T-T-T procedure is a little hard to do with the grain in wood. Use it as much as possible.

I think that skipping grits is false economy. After the expense of tools, lathe, time, wood, etc, what is the value of a little sandpaper? If properly sanded, exotic hardwoods start to shine, with no finish,between 400 to 600. I would buy 500 grit if I could find some.

Re: Sanding grits

#21

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Sanding grits

Lyle Jamieson

You are not the only one struggling with sanding, many end up with less then satisfactory finish, when its not the finish that failed but the tool control and sanding. You have some great help already, good light and grit progression are important. I like vinces use of extra grits, closer progression for the coarse grits, and no bigger jump then 1.5 for the finer grits. (80 to 120 is too big a jump) (120 to 220 is too big a jump)

I think an even more important issue is sanding with sharp sandpaper. When sandpaper gets even a little dull it heats up, bruses, burnishes, bends over the wood fibers instead of cutting them cleanly. Most of the time when this kind of damage is done the error is not visable until a finish is applied. I sand very aggressively, with considerable pressure, for a very short time on one spot of the sandpaper and move my fingers down to a sharp grit area and dont go back...throw it away. I never use a drill and sanding disks for anything finer then 220 grit. Fine grits on disks will be dull in a heart beat and damage the surface more then sand it.

Re: Sanding grits

#22

Re: Sanding grits

robo hippy

That would be a worse offence than using her microwave to dry some wood.

robo hippy

Re: Sanding grits

#23

Re: Sanding grits

robo hippy

When I first started power sanding, I had the whole range of grits, and used them. Still had scratches left over. I started going back to hand sanding every second or third grit because it left a different scratch pattern, and the curved scratch lines would show through. That is more difficult to do with power sanding. Sigh! Might have to switch to magnifying lenses. No really simple answer here, just pay more attention.

Thanks for all the input.

robo hippy

Re: Sanding grits

#24

we need younger eyes.   

John Lucas