Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

As Big as a Platter

Posts

As Big as a Platter

#1

As Big as a Platter 

ronnyeelen

A poplar burl platter, 12 inches wide. Poplar, as you all know, is easy to turn, and even easier to sand. The burl wood gives this sometimes plane wood a very nice touch.


When my wife bought some very unstable candle holders, I told her I would make her a more stable one. This is it. 12 inches high, turned from spalted beech. The hole in the top, holding the t-light cup, is about 4 inches deep, to remove some more of the weight from the top side.

Now I still need to convince my wife to replace the other ones with this... no luck so far...

All kind of comments welcome...

Ronny

Re: As Big as a Platter

#2

beauty

GaryG in MD

Re: As Big as a Platter

#3

Re: thanks

ronnyeelen

Re: As Big as a Platter

#4

Steven Antonucci

The platter is better than the candlestick

steven antonucci

Drilling the candlestick to remove some weight only solved the physical issue of lowering the center of gravity a little. Visually, I think it also needs to go a bit lower. I think your transition area could be lower by about an inch.

In addition, it appears from the photo that the top is slightly larger than the base in diameter, which adds visual weight up higher. I would want the top diameter to be much smaller, perhaps by an inch in diameter (1/2" of cutting!).

Even if the base was filled with magnets and it stuck to a metal table, I think this looks like it would be top heavy and about to fall over. I think you can probably remount it and make a few small adjustments to greatly improve it and have the wife accept the swap!

S

P.S. Platter does look great!

Re: As Big as a Platter

#5

Re: The platter is better than the candlestick

ronnyeelen

Now I have to think back...

When I was turning this, I think this design was intended, the top a little wider than the base, not too much of a slope and the narrow part high up. 'No Rude Osolnik' was one of the the main criteria. Reading your comments now, and looking at it longer, you might be right. I will have another look at the real object this evening. And make another one, keeping your remarks in mind.

thanks for your comments!

Ronny

Re: As Big as a Platter

#6

And an excellent photo as well!

JamieDonaldson

:D :D

Re: As Big as a Platter

#7

Re: And an excellent photo as well! ...heh heh...

ronnyeelen

:D

Indeed it is!

If only I could remember how I came to have such an excellent photo...

In all fairness, I should have mentioned that this version of the photo is an improved version of the 'underexposed and thus lacking of colour saturation and contrast' original which I posted on another forum.

Thanks Jamie for modifying it for me.

Ronny

(will be installing my copy of Fotoshop Elements this evening...)

Re: As Big as a Platter

#8

Ssuuhhhh- only volunteer info when asked!

JamieDonaldson

Re: As Big as a Platter

#9

Wait! Wait!

David Walser

"...I should have mentioned that this version of the photo is an improved version of the 'underexposed and thus lacking of colour saturation and contrast' original which I posted on another forum."

There are other woodturning forums(fora?)? I was sure WoodCentral was the be all and end all.

Re: As Big as a Platter

#10

Re: Ask Jamie! He was there first!

ronnyeelen

Re: As Big as a Platter

#11

All you'll get from me is....

JamieDonaldson

...name, rank, and serial number! And my serial number was before the Green Machine switched to Social Security numbers, so that info won't do you a bit of good! :D