Mike Foster's post got me to thinking... I have the older style McNaughton coring set-up and a Powermatic 3520-B. There must be a lot of people who have the same. What has everyone done about the short post on the McNaughton, or rather, the short tool rest banjo on the Powermatic?
Should I ask a machine shop to make a longer post, or get a different banjo for coring?
Call Craft Supplies and ask for a "powermatic" post. They're not too much, that you know you have the right shaft, made from the right steel.
I have the McNaughton, but not a Powermatic. But I got an extra post (the longer "powermatic" length) since I do run into the Powermatics when I travel and demonstrate. This way I'm all set no matter the lathe.
Some times when you order the system, you have to specify which lathe you have, and they don't always ask you.
By the older system, if you have the spear point blades, they are good. If you have the original blades with the cutter all on one side, recycle them, and get the spear points. Big difference.
I have the older ones with a wider cutting edge, and a single skewed angle. I have a friend who re-ground his to have a central "point", like the newer style, and they have worked well for him.
I'm only aware of two generations of cutter geometry -- the skewed cutting angle like I have, and those with the central spear point.... Is there an even newer design?
In his McNaughton coring system DVD, Mike Mahoney shows how to re-grind the tips to achieve the newer 'pointed' cutting edge. No need to recycle the older version of the cutters which can be re-shaped to the newer, better-performing pointed cutting edge shape.
The difference between the two blades isn't tip geometry. That actually has little or no effect on how the tool cuts and tracks through the cut. The difference is that the spear points are centered on the blade, and a bit wide of the blade on both sides. This opens up the cut on both sides of the blade, not just one. Some times you need to correct your cut to the inside, and this is impossible with the old blades. The spear point is a Mike Mahoney idea. For him, it works better if you are going to cut the blank totally off the main bowl, rather than cut it most of the way and then break off the tenon/stub. When you are coring end grain, crotch, or burl, if you try to break off the stub, you can rip right through the bottom of the bowl blank. Been there, done that. Me, I just grind the tips off square. Less cutting surface that way.
Mike Hunter will retip them with carbide cutters if you want. At least I think he still does. I'll have to ask him. I really like mine but haven't done enough testing with it to see how long it holds up.
Mike retipped mine for me after I loaned them to someone who ground away the top surface and ALL of the harder steel. Thanks to Mike mine are serviceable again and better than new. I do wish he had put slightly wider cutters so they would clear a wider path. You might ask.