Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Can someone confirm this?

Posts

Can someone confirm this?

#1

Steven Antonucci

Can someone confirm this?

steven antonucci

At the NJ Woodturners meeting on Monday night, I mentioned the tragic accident that we had discussed to the group to remind them of working safely. Graeme Priddle was our demostrator for the evening, and he mentioned that there was another accident at reported at the Capital Area Woodturners club.

He mentioned that the turner had broken his jaw and lost a few teeth. Graeme actually had a broken jaw too, but he mentioned that his was not turning related (which is how the whole topic came up in the first place...)

Does anyone know the circumstances?

Steven

Re: Can someone confirm this?

#2

Re: Can someone confirm this?

Mark Wollschlager

Yes, it was reported at our meeting last month.

This was in a school shop where we have skill enhancement sessions twice a month.

Turner placed a large, somewhat out of balance blank on a 3250b.

Turned on lathe without checking speed or clearance of the tool rest.

Speed was set too high. Blank hit the toolrest and unmounted.

The blank hit the turner in the face. The turner was wearing a face shield.

The turner was knocked down, lost several teeth and received facial lacerations and concussion.

There was an EMT and a doctor there for the skill enhancement session who cared for the turner before the Paramedics arrived.

That's the summary we received at our meeting.

There may be some more details, but someone else may have to fill those in later.

Mark

Re: Can someone confirm this?

#3

Another one

Harvey Meyer in Atlanta

I can confirm that a turner in Atlanta was injured in a turning accident. He is a novice and was turning a large 18" hickory bowl on a Powermatic 3520B. I don't know what stage of the bowl he was up to, but he said he was trying to get a better surface quality so he sped the lathe up to 2050 RPM. The bowl flew apart and struck him in his unprotected face. He broke his jaw in several places and now has assorted screws and other metal components holding his wired jaws together. He will recover. We estimate that bowl was turning about 4-5 times the maximum speed that would be safe for a bowl of that size. He said the tenon was still in the chuck.

Turn safely.

Harvey

Re: Can someone confirm this?

#4

Dick Hines

Re: Can someone confirm this?

Dick Hines

I am begening to think i need to take up a safer hobby. Like rideing mororcycles or bulls.

Re: Can someone confirm this?

#5

Re: Can someone confirm this?

Carole Valentine

Heck, Dick...simply LIVING these in this world is hazardous to your health! Just try and do it all as safely as you can and enjoy the ride while it lasts. But motorcycling and bull riding might be a bit higher up on the hazardous scale than turning. The first because not only are you dependent on the sanity and judgement of other drivers as well as your own skill, and the second because....well, because you probably just have to be nuts to get on the back of a two ton animal who very well may just like to kill you! :D

Re: Can someone confirm this?

#6

Re: Can someone confirm this?

Mark Paulley

Hi all,

While out in Sturgis for the big motorcylce rally the company I worked for sponsors the PBR (Professional Bull Riders). A young kid who we sponsored was there and we asked if he wanted to go with us to see Mt Rushmoor if we could find an extra motorcycle to borrow. He kindly told us that he thinks riding bikes is too DANGEROUS and declined the offer. I looked at him and asked how he could think riding a 1800+ pound bull that wants to stomp the crap out him was less dangerous. He advised he had being riding his whole life (21 yrs old) and knew his capabiities on the bull but with not so much experience on the bike. Plus he added his mother would kill him if she found out he had been riding a motorcycle.

So I gues its all in your perspective as what is dangerous!

Go figure!

Mark

Re: Can someone confirm this?

#7

Re: Can someone confirm this?

John Lucas

Lets see, I ride a bicycle about 1500 miles a year on the road. I ride a motorcycle to work everyday. One of my hobbies is rock climbing and I love to shoot any kind of gun. Now I'm finding out that turning wood may be up there on the danger scale with my other hobbies. :)

Re: Can someone confirm this?

#8

Steven Antonucci

Something in the water?

steven antonucci

I wonder if accidents are like mice (you never know how many you have)? It seems that the stories come out of the woodwork once you get one out in public.

Thanks for sharing

S

Re: Can someone confirm this?

#9

Steve Kubien

Speed kills

Steve Kubien

Or at least seriously injures. So, these were accidents. I get that. But, the common element here is speed and yet there are some instructors preaching the advantages of higher speeds.

Anyone else think we may be seeing more fo these incidents in the future? I hope I am wrong.

Re: Can someone confirm this?

#10

Steven Antonucci

No, it's not the speed that kills

steven antonucci

That's just plain wrong.

If I set up the blank on a lathe with a remote control, and start it from the other end of the room, it may fail because the speed is set incorrectly, but it won't kill me.

It's standing in the wrong place that will get you every time. It's forgetting to run down your speed every time you stop the lathe (or check the belts). It's not making sure that the banjo or tool rest is locked. It's not having the tailstock for support (and to potentially arrest a piece of wayward wood)

To suggest that you can just slow the lathe down and protect yourself is a disservice to the turning world. To create a false sense of security by putting on a thin plastic face shield isn't much better. Turning teachers need to stress the importance of stance and making sure that their students are educated on the number one cause of accidents: standing in the line of fire.

Tell me what speed I can set the lathe on to hit you in the face with a 40# block of wood and I'll concede to you...

Steve

P.S. Right after the structure of the tree and sharpening, my class will go into stance lessons. All before we turn on the lathes on Saturday...

Re: Can someone confirm this?

#11

I'm a big believer in Safety Awarness

Ed Larson

Safety Awarness can mean many things: Hearing about other accidents so we can learn from them and prevent future accidents; Setting good examples of safe pratices when demonstrating; Wearing proper personal protective equipment; Knowing where the danger zones (line of fire) are; Making safety the top priority; Having a safety discussion at be the first topic of every meeting, etc.

Safety was a major topic at our meeting yesterday. I have been asked to come up with safe turning practices for our club. My guess is other clubs are also doing this. Steve, I appriciate all your thoughts on this subject as well as all who have made comments on Wood Central. Let's keep the dialog going.

Re: Can someone confirm this?

#12

Re: Bring it back to the basics on safety

Steve Criscenzo

As I have posted on previous threads, safety is a process. There is no single factor that we can point to as a culprit. For every single activity we do, we need to take a moment to identify the hazards, prepare a plan to mitigate the hazards, execute the plan, and evaluate the plan when finished.

It is wrong to identify speed, line of fire, stance, bad wood, dull tools, no PPE or any other single action as the major factor in turning injuries. Doing so gives a false sense of security in that if we eliminate the one risk we are now "safe". It comes back to process and culture.

Last month a series of tornadoes came through central North Carolina. One of them tore apart a Lowes Home Improvement center. There were over 100 people in the store at the time and there were no serious injuries. The store manger stated that the store had a severe weather plan, staff was trained to it, and when the warning came in, they executed it. (They assembled in an area with the strongest walls, away from potentially flying materials.)

I have a post above of a bowl turned from a blank that had some punky areas. I was concerned about finishing this bowl safely and had to decide if I wanted to toss it or proceed. Before starting I made mental list of all the things that could go wrong from the bowl coming out of the chuck, to it flying apart, to dealing with the fumes from the CA glue. I evaluated if I could safely mitigate these risks and only then decided to proceed.

It is basic folks but it works. Learn the process, and use it. Create a safety culture that evaluates the risk of your current activity. In our work we call it the two minute drill. It needs to be part of your routine each and every time you enter the shop. Do not get comfortable in the fact that you have done it 1000 times before.

I vowed I was going to stop preaching about this here but I see these threads pointing to single issues and I think we are missing an opportunity to truly make enhance to safety of our craft.

OK, now I am done

Be safe everyone.

Steve

Re: Can someone confirm this?

#13

Re: Can someone confirm this?

Bob Macgregor

Maybe its time to switch to, say, ultralight pilot, just to be on the safe side!

BOB

Re: Can someone confirm this?

#14

Steven Antonucci

Number one cause of flying wood:

steven antonucci

is operator error!

I'm not a Six Sigma expert, but the unlying concept of Six Sigma is to make something 99.999999% repeatable and reliable. If I was to guess why wood came off of the lathe, I'd bet that this was close.

50% of the time, it is caused by a catch, which can be avoided with practice of proper technique. I would bet that 80% of all catches are caused by someone doing something fundamentally incorrect and not just some minor adjustment in form. (i.e. cutting uphill, against the grain with the flute open)

30% of the time, it is caused by having a poor mounting technique. Improperly shaped tenons (too deep to seat in the chuck, too large for the jaws to grip, not square or flush) will cause the other 20% of catches to send wood flying.

10% of the time, it is procedural. Checking speed, making sure that the blank clears the tool rest, or that everything is locked down. We can all get in a hurry sometimes, but you need to develop a protocol and follow it every time (e.g. I poured bar lube oil in my chainsaw gas tank the other night because I didn't close it immediately like I always do after putting in the gas.)

10% of the time, it is the wood failing. I'd bet that half of the wood that failed should not have been mounted on the lathe BY THAT TURNER. As Clint Eastwood said, "A man's got to know his limitations". Every so often, the wood itself will fail for no apparent reason, but that is rare. I have had tenons shear off of bowls, or hidden cracks in vessels, but I think that I am usually responsible for those things failing anyway. A lighter cut... a sharper tool, slower speed.

So if you want to eliminate flying wood, your biggest source of error is yourself. Develop your skills and working methods to the point where wood only comes off the lathe 0.000001% of the time, or at least strive to move it one more 9 to the right.

S

Re: Can someone confirm this?

#15

Steve Kubien

Re: No, it's not the speed that kills

Steve Kubien

You are very correct however, I do believe speed matters in accidents. There are a lot of ways we can make ourselves safer and running a little slower CAN be one of them. When you are 100% solid on things like line of fire, stance, and mounting methods, fine. When you are 100% certain that the piece you are turning has no hidden faults or defects, fine. As we have recently seen, you are literally betting your life on it so you better be sure.

Now, when we have a mixture of experienced turners who have bad habits they may not know of but are comfortable with and/or newer turners who do not know any better, AND we are taught to ramp up the speed, well, I stand by my earlier statement.

Re: Can someone confirm this?

#16

Richard Allen

Re: I'm a big believer in Safety Awarness

Richard Allen

Safety is the most important thing? If you want to be safe then don't turn wood. Fun is the most important thing!!! All this talk about getting bonked in the head has folks forgetting the most critical part of woodturning. That is having fun! Maximize the fun! When you maximize the fun of woodturning the nuts and bolts parts are easier to take.

The idea that safety comes first makes safety the most forgettable part of woodturning. Make safety an integral part of having FUN.

Cover the basics of safety, no more than a couple of minutes. Then get to the fun part. Make safety a natural part of turning, not something that you talk about at the start and then forget about while you are having fun.

Each time you change the fun part explain the options as well as mention the safety concerns which should be considered.

Re: Can someone confirm this?

#17

Re: Number one cause of flying wood:

Steve Criscenzo

Steve

What you have done is a hazard analysis for one of the hazards of turning, flying wood. You have suggested some mitigation but stopped short of PPE.

There are other hazards however. There is dust, fumes, entanglement of hair or clothing, back strain, repetitive motion ...

My point is that to do this safely, we must evaluate all hazards.

Steve

Re: Can someone confirm this?

#18

Steven Antonucci

One problem at a time

steven antonucci

Agreed that there are far more hazards than flying wood.

Unlike "bladed tools", where the main hazard is touching the sharp spinning thing, the lathe presents other unique opportunities to hurt yourself. Just like I would never push a board through the tablesaw while standing behind it for fear of a kickback or put my hand into a running bandsaw blade, my goal it to reduce the most common accidents first.

Will it catch all of them? Probably not, but if I can get 2 or three more nines, I'll work on the 4th and 5th later...

S

Re: Can someone confirm this?

#19

Steven Antonucci

Please post your "Survivable Speed/Impact Chart"

steven antonucci

I'm interested in knowing how you'll determine how fast is safe?

Until then, I'll be on the big belt at 200RPMs for my safety.

Steve

Re: Can someone confirm this?

#20

Keith Tompkins

Re: Another one

keith tompkins

HI Harvey, You mentioned the tenon was still in the chuck. If the turner had been using a faceplate with appropriate screws (not drywall screws) he may have avoided being injured. A faceplate is stronger than a chuck, especially with big, heavy turnings, and may provide a bigger safety margin. How many here routinely use a faceplate for large, heavy turnings?

Re: Can someone confirm this?

#21

Re: Another one

John Jordan

Me. :)

John