Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

segmented demented question

Posts

segmented demented question

#1

segmented demented question

avalon

new to segmented turning and i have a math question...

If length of segment is x= diameter of piece x 3.14159 / number of segments

and angle is 360 / # of segments / 2

can you put different lenghts of segments on the same ring?

ie can i do a 3 inch lenght of maple, a small sheet of veneer, a 2 inch piece of purpleheart, a small sheet of veneer, a 1 inch piece of walnut, a small sheet of veneer, a 2 inch piece of purpleheart, a small sheet of veneer, and a 3 inch piece of maple... then repeat... or do you just take your largest piece and cut it up into bits as long as the bits equal 3 inches?

Re: segmented demented question

#2

Re: segmented demented question

bill Crommett

Your question is not clear to me, but : The more segments that you put together before attaching to the piece, the more error you will tend to introduce.

I always attach and true each succeeding segment before gluing on the next layer.

Does that statement fall within the boundary of your question ?

Re: segmented demented question

#3

JL

Re: segmented demented question

JL

Yes, you can put different lengths of segments on the same ring. You just have to calculate everything very carefully before you cut.

I would suggest you ready one of the many excellent books on the subject of segmented turning design. The books can explain things much more thoroughly ( and better) than could be done in an on-line format.

Re: segmented demented question

#4

Re: segmented demented question

john lucas

It all depends on 1 thing. What do you want. The only time the actual dimensions matter is if you have aligning features in other rings that this ring has to align with. Other wise you could make any number of odd size ring segments as long as the last one fits whatever opening is left. Kind of like building a stone arch. All the pieces are different but it works if the last one fits and wedges them in place.

An easy way to calculate what you are trying to do is to simple make 2 rings. One long segments and one with short segments. (Say one ring is 8 sided and one 16) Then take 2 of the short segments out and replace it with one of the long segments. This method leaves you with 2 rings both with an mixed lengths but they stack together to make a nice looking pattern.

Re: segmented demented question

#5

Steven Antonucci

Think of your sub-assemblies as segments

steven antonucci

Re: segmented demented question

#6

OUCH!!

Molly Winton

My eyes crossed, and I got a headache just reading your question. I SO do not do segmented work, and this is just one of the reasons.

I am, however, a great appreciator.

Re: segmented demented question

#7

Re: segmented demented question

Lan Brady

You actually answered your own question.

The ring has 360 degrees.

As long as all the angles of the pieces add up to 360 you have a circle.

As long as total length/3.14159= needed diameter, it fits.

Disclaimer- I am not a segmented turner.

Lan

Re: segmented demented question

#8

I was told there would be no math in turning!

JamieDonaldson

Re: segmented demented question

#9

Steve Kubien

There isn't in my shop!

Steve Kubien

In my shop, segmented turning is called a design opportunity. For others, it is a shattered piece and firewood.

Re: segmented demented question

#10

Ken Vaughan

Re: segmented demented question

Ken Vaughan

I read your quesiton several times and the answers are two fold -- there is the theoretical answer and a practical one --

the theoretical question is kind of answered -- the math is straight forward presuming a diameter and pi for a given number

In reality it is a matter of precision needed to accomplish the outcome you desire. the process is to take linear shapes and cut them into trapazoids and then to transform the trapazoids into two curved surfaces separated by an even thickness.

As you add veneer, you increase the length/diameter by 1 inch for every 42 or so pieces you add (using commercial veneers) and perhaps by an inch for every 16 pieces if you cut your own veneer to 1/16 inch. Not much, but enough to change the pattern and outcome on some rings.

If you double the length of a section, the trapazoid that contains that length will be a different size with differrent angles than had it been two single pieces. to avoid the fabrication issues, most will use two ajacent pieces of the same wood to make a double length -- but it can be done either way.

To save the math -- there are a couple of computer programs for sale, several spreadsheets available for free, and a few books that have tables. Not much math if you want to avoiid it --- but lots of precision if you want patterns that are consistent.

Re: segmented demented question

#11

Re: segmented demented question/calculator

Rob Cohen

Something from someone named Joe Fisher

http://www.fisherwoodcraft.com/tips.php?TIP=calc

Don't know him/haven't tried it, but it looks impressive

Cheers

Rob

Re: segmented demented question

#12

Mine either.

john lucas

But it's simply because I have some sort of mental block when it comes to math. I figure things out in really strange ways. I design my segmented pieces on paper using simply drawing tools.

Re: segmented demented question

#13

Re: segmented demented question

Don at Central Illinois

When I first got into turning, my son gave me a Ray Key book on segmented turning. I thought it really looked neat but after reading how precise everything HAD to be, I decided segmented turning would have to wait until retirement, or not at all. I appreciated the people who have the patience and skill, but it is beyond me.

Re: segmented demented question

#14

Ken Vaughan

As precise as you want it to look

Ken Vaughan

Each turner who does segmented work has to decide how precise it needs to be -- and that can vary depending on the effects being desired. I am a learner and find that with high contrasts, lack of precision becomes very apparent to me -- but I am my worst critic.

Ray Allen set a high standard that few achieve. I suggest you look at starting easy and working up

Dennis has a nice segmented bowl pattern at

http://www.woodturningonline.com/Turning/segmented_turning/index.html#beginner

It is a great example and a good piece of work to look at when considering starting --

The tibbets book and the articles on his web site are worth reading too. He is on the Ray Allen end of the spectrum, but his bowl from pen blanks is a variant on bowls from a board that have been discussed here on Wood Central -- see posts from John Lucas.

I cannot do Ray Allen work -- but can make an acceptable bowl from a board.

Try it!!