Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Interesting analogy

Posts

Interesting analogy

#1

Keith Tompkins

Interesting analogy

keith tompkins

I was just reading a new issue of a motorcycle magazine which features a monthly column written by Keith Code. A former champion racer, Keith operates a high-performance motorcycle school in California. After just ONE day at the school, one of his students told him "I came to the school with 17 years of riding experience. I now realize I only had one year of experience 17 times". I think that applies to woodturners as well; when we learn something, we tend to repeat it until it becomes a habit....whether it works well or not.

I've had quite a few turning students who seemed to be "stuck"; they had reached a certain level, and discovered they couldn't get beyond that point. Like the motorcyclist, they had one year's experience, repeated "X" number of times. I think the trick is to get the best turner you can find, and learn from them. Practice new, improved technique every day until it replaces old habbits.

By the way, any bikers out there....Keith Code's book "A Twist of the Wrist" is a must read. It will absolultely change the way you ride.

Re: Interesting analogy

#2

Re: That's a very good point

Donna Banfield

Even if you don't plan to 'pierce and airbrush your work', or to turn a 'Range Rider Cowboy Hat', spending time with the turners who can took my work to another level.

There are points in my woodturning that, if they were on a graph, would have sharp spikes upward. The demo/workshop with Hannes Michelsen, which lead to my spending 3 days with him in his studio in Vermont in 2007. Can I turn a cowboy hat? Sure, but I don't. I have no interest in trying to compete with the original. But that 3-day 'white knuckle weekend' taught me how to turn scary thin walls, that I COULD turn scary thin walls. But more important I learned tool control, how to grind Hannes' free-hand grind on my gouges, which are the grind I use on all my bowl gouges, and the end grain vessels that I carve and texture.

In 2010 I hosted Binh Pho in my studio for a two day demo and workshop for my Massachusetts turning club. I already knew how to turn thin walls from Hannes; I learned new techniques from Binh using the NSK Presto air tool. Yes, everyone in the workshop created a piece that mimicked a signature Binh Pho, but that's how you learn the techniques. Can I pierce a thin walled vessel? Yes, but I am still working on how I can incorporate what I learned from Binh into a body of work that is all me. (I remember our conversation, Keith, where you said, "Everyone is piercing work.") The texturing that I used on the end grain vessel that received a 3rd place in the Turn and Burn Contest last fall was based on the skills that I learned in Binh's workshop. I'm still a year or two away in my opinion, from getting my airbrushing skills to a satisfactory level, and that my work doesn't like Binh's.

For me, that time and money was well spent. But I look at it as the summer cap for adults, or the wild summer vacation. I have plans next year to attend one of the schools for a weekend or week long workshop to add to my skills. To do that I will need to forgo the AAW Symposium in California, but I think it's a good trade-off for me.

Re: Interesting analogy

#3

I still need to learn how to turn......

Dave Belser

Great analogy Keith. I always find spending time with other creative people to be a big inspiration. As for still needing to learn to turn - there are plenty of times that I come up with an idea and then realize that I'd need to spend a couple of weeks learning how to do X first (thin wall turning or end grain hollowing for example). A weekend with an experienced turner can be well worth the effort.

Re: Interesting analogy

#4

Steven Antonucci

Open to learning

steven antonucci

I can say that I think I've seen a tremendous growth in people's willingness and acceptance to relearn woodturning. When I first attended a club meeting about 10 years ago, the first question that someone asked me was how long I had been turning.

It was kind of funny, because I found out that they equated duration with skill. If that is the case, then I am a better basketball player than Lebron James because I was on the courts before he was even born.

What I have seen in the past few years is that a lot of those "age=skill" barriers have been broken down because there isn't a 20 year skill curve. People can get really, really good in 2 years if they put themselves into it.

S

Re: Interesting analogy

#5

Re: Interesting analogy

robo hippy

I think that I seldom use the exact same technique twice in a row, even on bowls. I am still experimenting. The thing about mentoring is that you can help a turner over the hurdle that took you years to figure out. Helpful hints are very important.

robo hippy

Re: Interesting analogy

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: Interesting analogy

keith tompkins

Donna, You have produced some remarkable pieces of late....the instruction must be paying off! Yes, I have several designs that could benefit from piercing a few details, but I don't want just another "cliche" piece of work. If I can pierce something that's recognizable as mine, I'll do it. We can find inspiration outside of turning as well...I watched a blacksmithing demo recently that really was inspiring.

David...I have no doubt, if you want to produce something, you'll find a way!

Re: Interesting analogy

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: Open to learning

keith tompkins

Steve, You're right. There is also the aptitude factor. Some people make good accountants, or engineers. Whatever. Some have an aptitude for things like turning.

Re: Interesting analogy

#8

Stuck - by technique - or - lack of ideas?

charliel belden

Interesting question.

I think there are at least two types of STUCK.

The one most often discussed is about technique and is the easiest to get passed

- the I KNOW how to do "A" and DON'T KNOW How to do "B", so I'll keep doing "A" Stuck.

This one can be overcome through watching and studying one of the many DVDs or online

video tutorials available, a live demonstration that includes Q&A or some hands on mentoring

by a better turner, who is also a good teacher - followed by Practice, Practice, Practice. It

may be that the acquisition of a new turning tool, or a modification to a tool already owned,

that can UnStuck you.

Then there's the "I'm stuck - for ideas" (aka "I'm just not very creative.") Stuck.

Stuck For Ideas isn't discussed - or admitted - as often as Technique Stuck. That could be

because it's easy to use other peoples' ideas but not as easy to come up with your own

ideas. WC, WOW and a host of other web sites have tons of photos of other turners' pieces

to copy - or do variatons of.

Unlike information on Technique, for which there's plenty of info, How To Come Up With Original

Ideas (actually New To YOU Ideas That You Come Up With On Your Own) information is far

more difficult to find. And if you do find some of that info it may be difficult to understand

and/or apply to your turnings.

One of the ways I use to get around Stuck For Ideas is to semi-regularly NOT do things I've

done before and already know how to do. Of late that's been Movement - what types of

pieces lend themselves to, or BEG to have, movement. For others it may be starting to

play with color, or multi-axis or multi-centers, or doing very small turnings. Anything that

gets you away from the familiar CAN get you thinking of new ideas for a piece or two.

Re: Interesting analogy

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: Stuck - by technique - or - lack of ideas?

keith tompkins

Hi Charlie, I think you're right. There are two kinds of "stuck". Classes and demos, etc. are a good way to learn better technique, but learning to be "creative" is more difficult, I believe. Too many times people take a class, and end up making exactly the kind of work the instructor is known for. It's not just a wood turning phenomenon...You can spot a student of Tage Frid or James Krenov immediately. Many flat woodworkers work in certain styles: Federal, Chippendale, Shaker, etc...without any personal creative input whatsoever. In fact, they are often scolded if they do. I outlined in my article "Sketch for Success" ways to expand one's creativity. Sketch ideas in advance. Use each turning as inspiration for the next...make things in a series, exploring how far you can carry a concept or theme. Take a class totally unrelated to turning...pottery, metal working, painting, etc, just to expand your horizons. Best...learn to incorporate life experiences in your work...not easy to do, but with effort, anyone can do it.