Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

What does your 2436 sound like?

Posts

What does your 2436 sound like?

#1

What does your 2436 sound like?

Bill Luce

Does anyone have a vid of their newer 2436 at various rpms (including 1800 rpm and up) that they would share? I only have an older 2436 (as well as do a few friends) to compare to and they are all the same as eachother - quiet.

Without going into the bloody details, I have a second 2436 that I bought new as a backup that I for 5 months have been unsuccessfully trying to get resolved. Don't really want to get into details as it's been btd elsewhere.

But I don't want this to turn into a bashing thread or a which lathe is better thread (although in a different thread the lathe comparison thread would be interesting as it's been a few years since it's been the subject of a big thread).

Thanks, Bill Luce

In case anyone is curious, here's a vid of my second 2436 with it's second headstock and third spindle. Ran it awhile to try to give an idea of what it would be like to turn on that a while (and why I haven't put it to work yet).

http://www.youtube.com/user/VesselMaker#p/a/u/0/Dqb2KPsNoIY

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

#2

Steven Antonucci

Did you swap belts?

steven antonucci

Definite difference in the noise on the video. Did you move the belts with the headstock? How about the pulleys? I get a knocking noise in my Nova if the grub screw works loose..

S

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

#3

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

Dale Bright

Bill, I have followed your thread on the AAW site and listened too all of your videos. My 2436, #1924, is not as loud as you new one but maybe a little louder than your old lathe. I have turned on three other 2436 lathes and all are older than mine and none are as loud as your new one. A friend of mine has a 2436 that is of the same vintage as your original but has had the new style bearings installed and his is not as loud as your new one.

Dale

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

#4

Re: Did you swap belts?

Bill Luce

I've tried all three belt combinations, no difference. And when I first started struggling with the noise problem, I search the web exhaustively for ideas. Including posts on grub screws.

I've had three different new spindles in that machine, and with the OW they each come with new upper pulleys. All sound about the same.

All very confusing.

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

#5

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

Bill Luce

Dale, that is very interesting. I've been hearing from folks that the newer ones have a much louder, harsher sound at rpm than the old ones. One guy that compared his older 2436 to his newer 2436 called the sound of the newer 2436 the "dry bearing sound." I've gotten to the point I have even wondered if that is why OW has been so reticent to respond to me from the start. Maybe they realized they couldn't send me a quiet headstock and hoped I'd go away?

Can't really imagine that, but for whatever reason they just haven't engaged on my problem.

What is the most interesting is that your friend's old one that got the new double bearing does not sound as loud as my new one. I was hoping going back to the old style bearings would be a magic bullet, although OW told me they thought the new style were if anything quieter.

All the older one's I've personally heard compare well to my older one. Is my second one the new norm or is a newer 2436 a crapshoot? It's sure confusing,and I am stumped how to proceed from here.

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

#6

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

Galen Vetterick

If you send you video to Oneway wonder what they will say.

I see the manual says not to exceed 2000 rpm for the first 30 hours. They say due to the preload on the bearings it will run very hot. Odd point is they say they are sealed bearings but say the EXCESS grease in the bearing is allowed to escape and the seals seat. From the mechanical drives and bearings I have dealt with sealed bearings did not have excess grease nor do you want it to escape. They say units are run at the factory but wonder if the bearings get so hot right off they lose all grease if you run at high speed for any time. I have heard similar sounds if the shaft is slipping on the inner race or the outer race spins on the housing seat. It produces a varying speed to the bearing balls and creates a similar chatter even loaded with grease.

Not sure why they do not use factory installed dowl pins on the spindle cap to insure everything is in alignment rather than using the tail stock to help align when you put in the new spindle. Sure don't imagine that is factory way to align. Sounds like a lot could happen when the owner does install. Did the new spindle come with new factory bearing or did you use the same old?

Just throwing out ideas as you sure have a valid concern and not sure why the factory may not give the answer you need.

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

#7

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

Bill Luce

Oneway spindles come with all bearings and pulleys installed, and the inboard headstock nose bolted on (new nose).

I've sent them links to the vids over the months, but they still won't say there is a problem with my lathe. I am not sure what to make of that.

Also all the spindles were rackety from the start, and I did not run higher rpms until I had cycled them quite a bit a slower rpms. They were never allowed to get very hot. Interestingly, the spindles sets have gotten noisier over time.

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

#8

Richard Allen

Take up your complaint with Oneway

Richard Allen

Maybe Oneway should replace the spindle cartridge?

What did you say they have done that TWICE.

Maybe Oneway should replace the headstock?

What did you say, they have replaced the headstock.

Make your case with Oneway and leave us out of it.

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

#9

Richard Allen

Re: Did you swap belts?

Richard Allen

What is really confusing is why are you making your complaints here? Haven't you made enough noise on the AAW forum?

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

#10

Richard Allen

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

Richard Allen

Bill Oneway has provided you with replacement spindle cartridges and even a new headstock. To say that Oneway has not been engaged in the issue make you sound delusional.

Leave the hearsay out of your comments. I could share how other folks have said that you like to pick a fight even when there isn't a fight. But you have never done that with me and to bring up something like that which someone else told me would be unfair.

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

#11

Re: Take up your complaint with Oneway

Stuart Johnson

Richard, it sounds like Bill is trying everything he can to resolve his problem. If OW isn't helping and it sounds like he tried that route prior to saying anything then I see nothing wrong with his postings here. If his posts bother you then your best option is to ignore them not try to pick an online fight.

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

#12

Re: Take up your complaint with Oneway

Bill Luce

Richard,

Yes OW did replace my headstock once with spindle and due to defective spindle (missthreaded) they sent me another spindle (also machining defects with threads). The latest components I received are those in the vid I posted here.

I can tell you I am sparing the forum a whole lot of details about the last 5 months, as I spared the AAW forum as that level of details would be inappropriate here..

I am part of a world wide community of woodturners am reaching out to that community for information. OW says the lathe sounds normal. I only have access to older 2436's (mine and friends), and me hearing vids of other newer 2436's might help me better understand what the best next step is. My original post was simply a call for info.

It is not my intent to involve you in a struggle with OW. In my later posts, I simply answered a couple questions from folks trying to help in good faith. To not do so would have me as rude as your posts, and I would rather not be that way.

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

#13

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

Bill Luce

Dear Richard,

You have no idea of what has transpired in the last 5 months, and if I were to go into it I would be involving you which I am not.

You seem very offended that I have a 2436 that has problems. I assure you I have spend many tens of thousand happy hours on my first 2436 which I still use daily. In fact there are few turners in the world that have spent more time working on a 2436.

I have no idea what you are talking about in terms of hearsay and picking a fight? Do you mean the emails I have received recently telling me their experience?

If so, they don't post themselves to avoid such unpleasant exchanges such as this.

Come to think of it, I'll avoid it, too.

All the best, Bill

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

#14

Steve Kubien

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

Steve Kubien

I've read another thread on this "lathe". The audio/video you've posted is simply awful! I would expect more for that kind of $$$.

Simple question... Can you return it? I know I would and then I would look at other options.

Wish I could offer some real help Bill. Good luck.

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

#15

Keith Tompkins

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

keith tompkins

Hey Bill, I went to the AAW site to review your posts. Probably the quickest way to resolve your problem is to have a qualified machinist take a look at the machine in operation. That may require paying him to make a "house call". There are only so many things that can cause the noise you're experiencing. Bad bearings: spinning the spindle by hand with the belt loostened, you should notice NO roughness. You can FEEL a bad bearing; roughness, or a tight spot every revolution. Preload? probably not too tight, as the headstock would be so hot after a few minutes you could fry an egg on it. Too loose? Can you move the shaft in and out horizontally? Put a dial-indicator out-board against the spindle, zero it, and then bring up the tailstock, tighten. Any movement? Last thing I can think of off the top of my head. If you can see the bearings while installed, mark each bearing in relation to where it is located in the headstock...after running, ensure the marks still line up. The bearings may be loose in the headstock, causing them to rattle, and possibly rotate. If loose enough, that would cause the noise you encounter. ( That same problem haunted AUDI for years...the front wheel bearings had excessive clearance between the bearing housing and the exterior of the bearing shell, which should have been a press-fit. The looseness allowed the bearing to slide in its housing on turns and while braking..much worse when hot) Hope this helps.

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

keith tompkins

One last dumb thing to do...with the machine running, spray the belt with a solution of soapy water. Just a mist with a spray bottle. If the noise stops.....

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

#17

Re: Did you swap belts?

Bill Luce

Richard,

I realize anything I say will only ruffle you further.

But the reason I posted my "call" to hear another newer 2436 here is that I believed this might be a more active forum with a broader base.

But rest assured I will avoid your displeasure going forward.

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

#18

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

Don Evans

Keith

After listening to the vid's my first thought was the outside of the bearing was moving inside the head. In other words "spinning" around.

It would be interesting Bill if you have an idea of how snug the fit was with the bearings and their housing in the head, did you say you changed the spindle with new bearings etc if so you would know the answer to that?

My 2436 is quiet as a mouse, can hardly hear it running.

Don

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

#19

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

Bill Luce

Richard,

I did share that OW sold me a new headstock with spindle, even if that spindle and the next one had unrelated machining issues.

What is bothering me a bit is your alusion to your hearing I "like to pick a fight?" I have been very limited in my postings over the years in relation to turning, and for the life of me I cannot begin to imagine what you might be referring to.

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

#20

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

pete labelle

A few things to check out to narrow the source:

1) Run your noise test with a tight, then looser belt. Does the noise change?

2) Put a dial indicator on the motor shaft. Is it true?

3) Put a dial indicator on the motor pulley. Is it true?

4) Put a dial indicator on the spindle pulley...all levels. Are they true?

If any of these are not true, the belt will go from slightly loose to tight, each revolution and create noise.

5) Run the motor only. Is it quiet?

6) With all belts off, how easily & smoothly does the spindle turn?

7) A short broom stick pressed up to your ear, then to each bearing, will allow you to hear each bearing easily (old engine trick). Might be able to narrow the source.

8) Make a cone adapter for a fast drill motor, or die grinder. Push it into the end of the spindle. Remove the belt. Spin it up. Is the noise still there?

9) Is the noise once every revolution, or multiple times? Once every revolution would point to a bent shaft, flat spot on belt, flat spot on pulley, loose pulley, gap between the pulley & shaft too large and tension on belt causes pulley to wobble, etc.). Noise multiple times per revolution kinda points to a flat spot on a bearing or bad ball.

It's a basic machine. You've replaced many components, and the noise is still there. Look closely at the components that have been consistent thru the trial & error process. It appears to still be lurking.

Good luck.

Pete

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

#21

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

Peter Rand

I am very grateful to have read and learned about this critical issue, both here and at the AAW forum. I now live in fear of having my old quiet OW lathe needing new bearings or spindle, now apparently no longer made by OW. It surely is critical for OW too, as I see a very serious growing problem for their business. Has it reached the stage where concerted effort or appeal by the community is needed to get OW to recognize a real solution is necessary? Are all new OW lathes noisy? I'm worried.

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

#22

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

Galen Vetterick

Bill

I know this kind of problem can just about drive a man to the edge.

Still just look'n to see what it could be. The parts drawing makes it look like the bolt on indexing ring can run very close to the outboard bearing housing. When you have had this apart could you see any signs of this rubbing the housing? Maybe even if the mounting bolts are not set deep enough they may not clear? Do you use the same indexing ring over each time as I would not expect them to give you a new one each time?

I know I still wonder if those bearing races are turning in the housing. Does the unit need much force to seat them back in? They say the tailstock is used to help as a press and then the bolts. If it goes in too easy then it sure could need loctite on the races to stop them from spinning.

On some large replacement bearings of a tractor or cat they give you a cleaner and loctite to insure they do not spin.

Again just throwing out ideas from left field.

Re: What does your 2436 sound like?

#23

current status?

John Byron

Hi Bill:

I've been following your noise tests on the new Oneway. I agree with you that I couldn't tolerate working next to that rattle. Do you notice any vibration while turning? How about when you apply pressure into the headstock as if hollowing a bowl?

I WAS ready to purchase the 2436 but am waiting to hear what's happening with your machine, and whether there has been a loss of quality on key components.

From what I've heard for years, Oneway has alway stood behind their product and won't let you get stuck with a bad headstock.

So please keep us posted on what happens.

JB