All of the recent discussions made me think of the following question: Do you work to be more efficient or more safe? Would you do something that was "less safe" if it was much faster to do it?
When I cut anything in multiples, I try to think through the entire sequence of operations to know what I am going to do when I get to a particular spot for efficiency's sake, but I also think about how to do things safely. It might involve swapping one tool for another, a chucking method, or even speed and stance. I also want to produce the cleanest possible surface to minimize sanding.
What trade-offs do you consider to be "safe enough" that you are willing to take speed over a higher degree of safety? I have a few examples in mind, but let's hear yours first...
I turn a lot at the end of the day. When I make my first STUPID mistake, I am done for the day, even if I miss a deadline. Simple mistakes can be very painful and mess up good wood. When the snow is deep, and aubulances can't get to my mountain top, I get even more safe.
I'm not in much of a thinking mood but I will address the specifics you raise...
If I have something in a chuck or on a faceplate, I use the tailstock as long as I possibly can. I will even use a jamb-chuck between the tailstock and the bottom of a roughed out bowl when I work the outside.
I can't think of a situation where I would part off a piece with the lathe running. Why would anyone want to catch a piece of spinning wood in their hand?
I use a bandsaw as little as possible because mine leaves a lot to be desired. If I need to round a blank, I will often use an axe or a drawknife if it is on the lathe and I discover it won't clear the ways.
Hi Steve, I part off goblets and finials with the lathe running. I do it during demos mostly for effect...looks dangerous, but it's really not. Turn the speed down, grasp the turning loosely, and finish parting off. The piece just stops spinning in your hand, very little inertia. I turn a goblet or finial almost every time I turn as a warmup, so I've done countless pieces. Of course, no long sleeves, no hand between the turning and the tool rest, etc.
I'm in robo hippy's camp. Efficiency should not prempt safety or safe practices.
Each of us probably has a different understanding of what we consider safe, eg. part the item off with the lathe running or saw it off with the lathe stopped, wear a face shield or not. What we consider safe today may change tomorrow. What might change our mind is hearing about others experiences or near misses or we learn from some of the dumb mistakes we make. That's why I think it is important to hear about and discuss those "dumb" mistakes as it calibrates our understanding of what is safe and what is not. By the way there are no dumb mistakes we learn fom all of them.
Steve, thanks for keeping our safety awareness high, that is the only way makes turning safer for all or us.
Perhaps the best example of sacrificing speed for safety that I see as a semi-common turner's practice is the use of a bandsaw on a round log to cut a blank. I think I have bent of broken more blades trying to do this than any other type of cutting. I no longer even think about doing this, and I will get it close enough to mount on the lathe with a chainsaw, and turn it from there.
On the subject of chainsaws, I also see a lot of turners could probably use a quick lesson on some chainsaw basics. I routinely see people cutting without having the anti-kickback pawls engaged and standing directly behind the running saw! If you think the line of fire is important on the lathe, don't get me started about having a running chainsaw coming towards you.
I also have seen quite a few turners who are "in the groove" cutting with those all day edges. They don't sharpen enough, which leads to applying more tool pressure to make the cut, which leads to more vibration, which leads to more tool pressure to steady the cut, which leads to more vibration...you should probably touch up your edge every second time you turn off the lathe. A pocket hone makes a great stocking stuffer...
The chain saw is probably the most dangerous tool we use: sharp teeth, high speed, no blade/cutter guards. In considering what to include when I do my bowl turning DVD, out of liability concerns, it will most likely have to be very short. The unfortunate thing about that is it is an area where most of the woodturners that use them know little about general safety with them. Best piece of advice I got on them was that your left hand which is on the bar over the motor stays locked straight, never bent. If it is bent and you get some kick back, you have NO chance of stopping the blade from coming back into you. If that arm is locked, then at least you have some chance.
As to cutting circles on the bandsaw, it is a time saver over the octagonal blanks from the chainsaw. Bent blades on the bandsaw will come mostly from blanks that are not flat. Once the blank rocks on your table, the blade binds. A hand axe can help flatten things out. You can get really good at cutting a flat surface with practice. Rocking the saw up and down while cutting seems to me to leave a very uneven surface. Have a vertical line on the face, dig the dogs in, and push the far end down in the cut as far as you can go (ends up being 45 degrees or so, then follow the line down the front, while keeping an eye on the kerf to keep the cut from wandering. I cheat. I have a Laguna 16HD bandsaw that cuts 16 inches high. It has an 1 1/4 inch blade with teeth about 3/4 inches apart, and a 4.5 hp Baldor motor. This is not set up for cutting veneers. Square up the ends, stand it on end,, use a 6 inch strip of plywood to mark lines, and it is simple to cut 2 parallel surfaces that are simple to put on the small bandsaw and cut circles out of. This is a HUGE time saver. Having the proper blade, with a wide tooth set helps, and a thicker 1/2 inch blade is good as well. Some times you just have to learn to make do with what you have. If a chain saw is it, and you can't cut good flat surfaces, then start with it between centers, or on a face plate, octagonal shape, and slower starting speeds is what you have to make do with.
Kind of embarrassed that I didn't think of that when I had that situation recently. Oh, well, live and learn. Thanks for the idea, though -- I'll do it right next time 'round.
My point was that from the data I have seen here, more turners are actually injured by the bandsaw than at the lathe. I can't recall ever seeing a posted chainsaw accident on this forum?
I've never had an accident with a the chainsaw (knocking wood as I type...) Perhaps it's because I take extra care to make sure that I am cautious, or perhaps it's because I read everythign I could before ever touching one.
I have had one small bandsaw accident, but it didn't involve touching that sharp spinny thing! It was on a round log that rolled and I actually got slammed in the finger with the wood. Hurt but not as much as the bent $40 blade did.
don't neglect the chainsaw's cutting chain. With the right file, sharpening the chain is quick and easy, and makes the cutting that much safer (and easier on the saw).
I don't have a band saw, so I cut bowl blanks to octagons with the chainsaw. Chainsaws are as potentially dangerous as anything I can think of, but maybe things are more predictable than when the blank is spinning away on the lathe. Either one can be a show-stopper.
Hey Steve, There is an upcoming article on bandsaw safety in the AAW magazine sometime this summer. Some posts on WC, as well as classes I've taught, showed there is a big need for bandsaw safety instruction. Reed is correct, there must be a flat surface to saw blanks safely. There are safe ways to bandsaw round stock as well; an aggressive blade will pull a round piece out of your hands. I went over the bandsaws at PV with Jim, who is ordering a few pieces....they need a bit of work to cut blanks well. BUT, compared with some of the bandsaws I've seen they were well above average.
The saws at most schools are top notch equipment with bottom notch maintenance plans. After a heavy few days of use, I am sure that everything in the shop probably needs somekinds of help. I'll spend Friday night fixing the gouges for Saturday AM.
And we'll chainsaw a bunch of blanks for the season if I get my wood delivery tomorrow...flat on two sides, so we can run them "round enough" on the bandsaw...
We did make several hundred balusters using stebcenters both in the head and tailstock, start the day marking the centers and making a center dot with and ice pick in all of them, once we did start the lathe, we never stopped it, present the stock to the head, bring the tail to it and start turning, we did it in several sections, one section at a time, in a couple fast passes it was brought very close to final shape and then a very slow pass to finish that section, we used the skew only and the finish was like glass, no sanding, so that was very efficient, I did made a 34" baluster in about 12 minutes, my boss made them in 7. We never had a dismount and we had shop glasses, but no face mask, always on the line of fire, but the method was good and if we took a little too big a bite the spindle just stops.
I part with a saw with the lathe stopped.
I prefer to use a saw, in my case a chainsaw to bring the blank closer to round. I wish I had a band saw. And if bark is present, I peel it wit a hatchet before turning.