Unbelievable!!! All the conversation on all wood turning forums about safety, face shields, and Joan's accident, etc. I have been turning bottle stoppers for our guild festival sale. Some of them are spaulted Maple and fairly punky. As you may have read my posts before saying that I don't even turn the lathe on without my face shield on and down!!! Well, I had sanded the stopper and cranked the lathe up to 880 rpm to apply the high speed friction polish. Wham!!!! The punky stopper came off the dowel and hit me right between the eyes. It didn't crack the face shield and didn't hurt..........but........what if I had not had the face shield on??????
Especially for something as germane as applying friction polish? Stand off the end, it still shines...even if you aren't looking at it!
It's like asking me if I want to try wearing a bullet proof vest and take a gunshot to the chest. I'm sure it works, but I don't want to test the theory anyhow...
No Steve, I was directly in front of the bottle stopper applying the finish with a paper towel under the turning which forced the stopper up when it cut loose. I think I will be applying force from the top from now on
and apply your friction while pushing gently towards the headstock. I also recommend a threaded stopper mandrel and that you tap your hole to make it sit better. The threaded hole is nice because you can unthread the top to wash the bottom.
I do stand in the line of fire or very near on wine stoppers. You an see the shape so much better and I've never had one come back at me. I've broken a few off when I use dowels instead of my pin chuck.
I m glad you were not hurt. Good thing you had your face shield on.
I have never been struck in the face shield. I have been turning for 12+ years putting in 500 to 3000 hours each year turning wood. I have never been hit in the face and I have never been hit in the torso. My hands and arms have been hit a few times. Bowls have blown up on me. Unexpected dismounts have occurred and pieces have been unexpectedly expelled while turning.
So I have to wonder what you folks are doing that results in flying pieces of wood. Or more to the point, what am I doing that is different from you that results in you being hit in the face shield and me watching wood fly. If a face shield is insurance then the best insurance is that which is never tested.
work safer. I just posted above expressing my opinion of the benifits of reporting near misses or dumb mistakes. Thanks for confirming my thoughts. Allso thanks for all of you who outlined different and safer methods to accomplish the same task.
Richard If wood is fling off your lathe and you have not been hit it luck pure and simple. If big wood is fling off your lathe and you have not been hit it is dumb luck.
It�s not that you standing clear of the line of fire. If you can see the shape of your work you are in the line of fire. If you are holding the tool and it is cutting wood you are in the line of fire. If you can�t see that you are deluding yourself.
There are only 2 places where you are out of the line of fire, 1 is when your belly is pointed at the head stocks hand wheel, the second is at the other end of the lathe. Even those are not safe if you conceder the bank shots off the walls, ceiling and tool rest.
That's about the minimum speed I usually run at... I would have to crank down to 880. For something bottle stopper sized, I would be at least 2x that...
Don�t let it be about luck very many times. If something comes off the lathe you need to stop until you understand why it happened and not repeat that mistake.
Is this wood to rotten?
Is that bark inclusion to deep?
Did I turn away the wood supporting that bark inclusion?
Did I get a big catch and why?
Is there a flaw in the chucking tenon?
Is the tenon to small for the blank?
Etcetera
I am all for pushing our limits but if you cross the line learn your lesson the first time. If you want to take a chances use small wood ever time your projects weight doubles the damage potential is 4 times.
Let�s all understand the risks and keep then under our control.