Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

thoughts on shop safety...?

Posts

thoughts on shop safety...?

#1

thoughts on shop safety...?

Jon Garcia

Hi everyone, after hearing the tragic news about one of our fellow turners I posted this up on WoW. I and I think others would like to hear from anyone who wants to comment on the subject of safety. Joan, our thoughts are with you, your family and friends�

I was thinking about face shields. I wear one when I�m roughing out a piece on the lathe, but then I take it off to get a better view for the rest of the work. I know they can be cumbersome and looked at as a burden. I have a feeling I �should� be wearing one all the time, and I know danger is inherent with the type of work we all do. But, I am curious to hear other thoughts about the subject of face shields and safety in general in the shop and the practices we all take and don�t take. I think it may be good for some healthy reminders and thought...

Re: thoughts on shop safety...?

#2

Dale Jablonski

Re: thoughts on shop safety...?

Dale Jablonski

I personally attempt to be safe in anything I do, that includes religiosly wearing my face shield and respirator. Ironically, yesterday I was working in the shop attempting to resaw a board to make a platter holder and I was nicked by the table saw. >( I'm still angry at myself!

Re: thoughts on shop safety...?

#3

Steven Antonucci

based upon the recent incident...

steven antonucci

I wonder if the faceshield could have saved the woman. It's not clear exactly what happened in this case, but I think it bears some investigation.

From what has been posted, I cannot tell if the person was wearing a faceshield and it failed to protect her. The information describes cuts, but also a fractured skull as the major problem. It is somewhat critical to reiterate the possible causes of injuries to avoid the possibility of it occurring again:

1.) It is probable that she was in the line of fire when the bowl came apart.

2.) It is possible that the wood had inherent defects that lead to the failure.

3.) It is possible that the lathe speed was set much higher than she thought it was and accidentally started it.

4.) It is possible that the mass of the piece would have cause the injury even with a faceshield on.

5.) It is possible that her injuries from the lathe were minor and she was injured in the fall.

It is a tragic reminder to us to think safety every time that we are in the shop AND to make sure that you ACT safely. I hope that the AAW can piece together a safety briefing for turners at the National Symposium. It's a topic that should cover basic tree work, using a chainsaw, standing at the lathe, use of a bandsaw, dust and probably another dozen ideas to keep the new turners safe and the old turners from forgetting...

Steve

Re: thoughts on shop safety...?

#4

Re: based upon the recent incident...

Jon Garcia

�There but for the grace of god, go I� was one of my first thoughts. I did not mean to imply at all that this was preventable, I am simply curious to what extent my fellow woodturners are practicing safety measures, in hopes to reflect on shop safety. But like u said Steven, the more information the better�

Re: thoughts on shop safety...?

#5

Re: I am profoundly saddened...(long)

Donna Banfield

by the news of her death. But it will have a lasting impact on me.

I wear prescription safety glasses. I wear a faceshield, the Bioshield by Uvex, when I turn. ALL THE TIME. I've taken hits to the faceshield by flying pieces of wood or bark, but small enough to barely put a scratch or dent in the plastic. But therein lies the problem. I'm smart enough to know that the thin, flexible plastic would not stop a larger piece of wood. It's been suggested by someone that even if she was wearing a faceshield (and she probably was), it wouldn't have been of much help based on the description of her injuries.

I turn everything from small to very large blanks. I am frequently alone when I am turning. My husband and I were talking about this when I shared the news of her accident last weekend. He expressed concern that because I am alone all day, and he frequently travels overnight, I could be knocked out without any help for a long period of time. I pointed out that if he could not reach me by phone (we talk every night he's away), he would call someone to check on me. In addition, I have woodturning friends and students dropping by on a regular basis. But the best way to stop a tragedy from happening is to take precautionary steps.

How many of us have top of the line lathes and tools? I turn on a Oneway, I use HannesTools and Thompson Lathe Tools. Before that, I had several Glaser gouges, and Crown Pro-PM, if I had to buy 'off the rack'. I used to wear the Trend Airshield until it rolled off my bench one too many times, and finally had too many cracks and breaks to repair. I had shared emails with Bill Grumbine about his AirStream Helmet, but I just never got around to purchasing it, in part because of the cost. That's a tough nut to swallow all at once. But seriously, so is losing an eye, or your life. Shame on me, that I'm willing to spend money on my tools, but am reluctant to spend it on my safety. It's time to put my health first.

I am so sorry that Joan lost her life. I did not know her, but she will have a lasting impact on my woodturning for the rest of mine.

Rest in peace.

Re: thoughts on shop safety...?

#6

Steven Antonucci

Nor did I

steven antonucci

I am merely attempting to point out that this tragic event's only possible silver lining is in education.

I think a lot of turners believe that wearing a face mask at the lathe protects you from a variety of situations. I think it's a good idea, but a false sense of security. I know that I will use this event and others at the beginning of my class as a teaching point to stress a recipe for safety at the lathe.

S

Re: thoughts on shop safety...?

#7

Re: I am profoundly saddened...(long)

Nick Tuzzolino

Donna:

I see there are many Bioshield models. Which one do you prefer for woodturning?

Re: thoughts on shop safety...?

#8

Re: I am profoundly saddened...(long)

Bernie Weishapl

Donna I did buy the AS 400 Airstream after talking to Bill which is after 3 bronchial infections. My Doc says it could over time turn into emphysema. That got my attention real quick and ordered on after talking to Bill. It has been 3 yrs now and no more infections. Bill told me the price of the AS is a lot cheaper than a lung transplant.

My question is which Unex do you use? They have the 8510 which is anti fog and hardcoated. Wonder if it worth $10 more dollars. After hearing this story I don't have much faith left in my ACE Hardware $8.95 faceshield.

Thanks Wally for the checks reminder. I went to turn a lidded box today and forgot I had the lathe set for pen turning at 3000. Scared me to death. It may be overkill but I made up a check list and it is hanging by my lathe.

Re: thoughts on shop safety...?

#9

Re: I am profoundly saddened...(long)

Donna Banfield

Nick, I'm using the Uvex Bionic Shield, carried by Woodcraft. But that plastic would not protect me from an impact. It is flexible, not hard plastic.

http://www.woodcraft.com/Product/2020118/19388/Bionic-Face-Shield.aspx

And after that tragic accident, I do not prefer it any longer. I don't turn fast, but things happen. Early in my turning, I had a large piece (3 ft) box elder fly apart. It had a bark inclusion that was hidden. The turning speed was less than 300 rpm. I didn't get hit, but an 8 ft shop light was shattered, and one of my Crown scrapers took a hit at the tang while it was sitting on the tool rack, and snapped in half.

Re: thoughts on shop safety...?

#10

Re: I am profoundly saddened...(long)

Donna Banfield

Bernie, it's the Uvex Bionic Shield (http://www.woodcraft.com/Product/2020118/19388/Bionic-Face-Shield.aspx) and is the anti-fog coated shield.

It has deflected small things, like bark. But it's still a flexible plastic, unlike the Airstream hard plastic shield, and would offer little impact protection from a larger or more substantial piece of wood.

Re: thoughts on shop safety...?

#11

Re: thoughts on shop safety...?

Jorge Casta�eda

Jon, I think a frequently ignored check is for soundness of the wood; if punky or bark inclusions or visible cracks, we should stay away from attempting turning it.

Another one is, are we in top shape to turn? or are we already tired and should not?

I am guilty of this, for several years as a pro carpenter I was turning after dinner, now as a farmer same thing, after learning the death of the young student girl, working along on the wee hours, I changed my routine, I turn early in the morn even before breakfast, what used to be my prime reading time is now my prime turning time.

Let's keep thinking...

Re: thoughts on shop safety...?

#12

Re: thoughts on shop safety...?

Jon Garcia

Those are great points Jorge, I was reading a flyer for a Craftsman school and under one of the descriptions it says 24-7 shop access, and I thought of one of the points made about that student�s death which was shop hours. I think her University was considering limiting shop time to reasonable hours. I know that�s going to put more pressure on for the students when it comes to deadlines, but safety should be #1 priority�

Re: thoughts on shop safety...?

#13

Re: I am profoundly saddened...(long)

Jon Garcia

I own a Trend Airshield, I wonder how well that is going to hold up to impact..? I suppose a catcher�s mask may be one of the only real impact resistant things out there�

Re: thoughts on shop safety...?

#15

Re: thoughts on shop safety...?

Nick Tuzzolino

Right on! The worst accident (near severed index finger on bandsaw) was later in the day, when tired, cut some blanks for a friend against my better judgement, using all the safety cautions. I'm still not sure how it happened, but it did. Never again! If I'm tired, my machines go off and stay off. Period.

Re: thoughts on shop safety...?

#16

Re: I am profoundly saddened...(long)

Donna Banfield

It certainly appears to be the same one. But already owning one, and having doubts that it offers real serious protection, I'll be getting the Airstream AS400

Re: thoughts on shop safety...?

#17

Re: I am profoundly saddened...(long)

Bernie Weishapl

Thanks Donna. I appreciate it.

I have to agree with Jorge that I was guilty in the beginning of turning every piece of wood I found. I couldn't throw any wood out. I had been hit mostly in the chest and arms. About 3 yrs ago I was turning a vase out of maple 7 X 7 X 10 and it was fairly punky. I had just finished the outside which didn't look to bad and was starting to hollow it. There was no catch but it just exploded. Thankfully I was on the end of it and only caught some small pieces on my arms. In the last 2 or 3 yrs if the wood has a crack, punky or I don't feel safe about it, it goes in the firewood pile.