Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

Posts

Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

#1

Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

Ed Moore in SW VA

There was recently a thread about a Japanese school and woodturning. I have been very conscious of the schools we have available in the USA from two perspectives. First, we are lucky to have them, and second the economy is hitting some of them hard.

I am most familiar with Arrowmont in Gatlinburg, Tennessee, and the John C Campbell Folk School in Brasstown, North Carolina. In the last couple of years I have heard of classes by some of the best woodturners/teachers/demonstrators in the USA being cancelled due to low enrollment at these schools. I strongly suspect that other similar schools around the country have had similar problems.

Many of us have had very positive experiences when taking a woodturning class for a week at such schools. I have observed some real growth during the week of instruction. The late Dennis Yoder posted some excellent ornaments on WoodCentral after taking the Ornaments class and that was a source of real pleasure for me to see that.

Starting Sunday I am to teach Ornaments to a small class at JCCFS. One of the assistant directors told me that my particular week is a very low enrollment for the whole school, that it wasn't just my class. She asked if there was anything I could do to recruit a few more for my class. Unfortunately, there is nothing I can do. I am not a "name" turner with a following and I am not comfortable beating my own drum. More to the point, the economy and the timing are at fault. Graduations occur this time of year.

So, what's my point?

What can we do to support these schools and ensure that newbies coming along in the future will have their excellent instruction available to them? How can we encourage others to take classes at these fine institutions?

Ed

Re: Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

#2

Re: Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

Randy Gleckler

Both of the clubs I belong to are hosting raffles through the year to have a drawing at the end of the year for 1 tuition for a club member to one of these Schools. Which I think is a great idea.

Re: Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

#3

Re: Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools *LINK*

John Lucas

Ed The Appalachian Center for crafts had low turnout last year. My class didn't make and several other in other mediums didn't either.

I don't think a big name matters too much at schools like the Folkschool and The Craft Center. Most students are new students and aren't familiar with turners. Arrowmont is a different animal and experienced turners go there to take classes from specific people.

Which brings to a point I meant to post. The Appalachian Center for Crafts has a new chef and man is the food good. I've eaten there 5 times now and each time we have had great meals. That was probably it's weakest point up to now. If the food stays that good it will beat the Folkschool for quality of food. It's a great place to go and they have some good instructors this year. It's just an hours drive from Nashville and 2 hours from Knoxville and Chattanoooga.


http://www.tntech.edu/craftcenter/workshops/

Re: Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

#4

Steven Antonucci

My class is full because of me...

steven antonucci

In this day and time, you will see that you have to be a good "drum beater" to guarantee enrollment in your sessions. I think that at least half of the attendees in my upcoming class enrolled because I recurited them from the two local clubs that I belong to. Whenever I demo at the clubs, I usually attract a crowd much larger than I can get to, so I make sure that the entire club knows that I will have the time to spend with them at Peters Valley.

I don't think that any of the Craft Schools are particularly strong at the social networking aspects of their business. There are so many opportunities for free advertising and referral based marketing that it seems almost impossible to think that a class should cancel. If you cannot get the minimum to run a class, you either didn't do a good job selling it, or it should have never been on the schedule on the first place.

The schools all have a product that people will pay for...if they know it's out there! If you cannot attract nationally because of the added costs of hotel, food and travel... you need to attract the local market.

S

Re: Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

#5

For many folks today ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

$1000 for a week away for a vacation is just not in the budget. While you and I know the value of the time taking the woodturning class, those under economic pressure have higher priorities. I'm glad that you have successfully recruited a full class. I just don't have the star power of a Raffan, Clewes, Stafford, or Antonucci.

Ed

Re: Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

#6

Re: For many folks today ...

Don at Central Illinois

I would love to go to some of these, such as Anderson Ranch, Arrowmont, etc. but with the cost of tuitioin, room and board, etc. just not in the budget. At least not now. I only live 3 hours from Marc Adams and could stay for free with relatives in Indy, but don't have the money for tuition. The only 'classes' I get are at the local clubs where they bring in a 'name' turner. They are always worth while and reasonable enough to allow me to attend.

Re: Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

#7

Steven Antonucci

Star Power?

steven antonucci

The key thing to take away from this is that it has nothing to do with star power. My name isn't any bigger than yours (unless you are counting letters). It has to do with me proactively making people aware that I am teaching at a specific venue. I am not counting on the school to fill my class. We are partnered, with each side taking half of the responsibility.

I don't know if I know enough to fill a week. I also don't know if I could keep up the manic pace that I go at for mare than 2 days. I will find out in two weeks. I teach a weekend class that was extended to a third day over Memorial Day weekend this year. A lot of turning schools could probably take an instructor week and split it into a 3/2 schedule to attract more people to the school, and lower the cost. 50% option means you can teach half of the time instead of 100% or 0%.

Perhaps a discount for a "Bring a buddy" program would make sense?

Maybe onsite camping to lower costs (that the school isn't getting a piece of like hotel rooms...)

All I am saying is that schools that go get big names to fill their schedules have higher costs and instructors that may not be as big of a draw as they think they are. There is a reason that the local guys fill the rooms at Peters Valley first every year- because we make it happen.

S

Re: Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

#8

Re: Star Power?

Ed Moore in SW VA

Steve, it would seem that you and some others have created an atmosphere where it is the "thing to do" to take a turning class at Peters Valley if you are a turner. New Jersey is a big state with several clubs and just one school (PV), so the culture that has been created along with supply and demand makes filling classes feasible.

As to star power, Arrowmont had more trouble last year than did JCCFS. Some names at Arrowmont had classes that didn't make. I had seven/ten last year and have less than half that this year. While PV fills with lots of local students, JCCFS and Arrowmont draw from a national pool. Gas prices are screaming "Stay Home!" this year, and folks are listening.

Ed

Re: Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

#9

Steven Antonucci

New ideas

steven antonucci

Peters Valley is drawing from a local market only for woodturning. I am amazed that the potters and blacksmiths come from everywhere to take the curricula. We are only drawing about 1/2 of MY class from local clubs. I have no idea where the other folks come from, but I know that I recruit to Peters Valley and my own class.

As far as "names" go, don't you think that if I can get people to come to PV, that you could get people to go to your school? How about a brand name turner getting people to attend their class wherever it is? It's really not that hard? I made an announcement at a club meeting in January, and three people signed up. I did a demo and mentioned it again, and a fourth person signed up. My topic isn't sexy- it's learning the basics- and I didn't have to push that hard.

How connected to the local turning clubs is your school? One of my clubs (Water Gap Woodturners) is partnered with Peters Valley. We demo at their events. They let us use the wood studio. We sponsor their talks. I give talks at their open houses. It's a lot of "work", but we are truly partners. I have a key to the shop.

All tha I am suggesting is that if the schools are doing the same things and they are having difficulty filling their classes, perhaps it is time to do something different. Gas is $4/Gal here, but many of the people attending the class will only drive 20 miles to do it...

Steve

Re: Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

#10

Re: New ideas

Ed Moore in SW VA

Steve,

I live six hours from Brasstown, North Carolina. There is a club in Brasstown and I met a member once. It was mentioned that they might like to have me demo sometime. One of the students lives locally, but I don't know if they are a member of that club. Partnering is fine, but not from six hours away.

Ed

Re: Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

#11

Steven Antonucci

It doesn't have to be you, Ed.

steven antonucci

Ed-

My situation with Peters Valley is quite accidental. I joined a new club a few years back, and was going with the flow. One day, the studio head asked me if I wanted to teach there. I was flattered, and I assumed that everything was well thought out and planned. It wasn't.

A lot of the craft schools are run by well meaning folks doing things to the best of their abilities. Peters Valley was in danger of disappearing altogether until they made some changes. The new ED is a miracle worker, and we have a good working relationship. I offer her my professional advice at no charge, and volunteer my turning skills whenever they need someone to demo for a day. Every craft school in the US has the same issues, and they should all be knowledge sharing to keep the industry alive.

One of her first changes was to stop trying to run classes with only the biggest names. It's nice to say that you have the talent coming, but in a pressing economy, people aren't travelling. A lot of these big names don't really help to fill the classes, and many of them have additional expenses to cover- so you need to put more people in the class just to break even. Guys like you and I are far more profitable than the big name turners, and I doubt that we are any less valuable to our students.

Secondly, if there is a club in Brasstown, and 5 other clubs between you and there, the JCCFS should have an advocate in all of them. If just one person from each club signs up for each turning class, the class is half full before they advertise! If that advocate stands up at the beginning of the year and says to his or her peers that "Ed's going to be turning boxes at JCCFS", it should make a difference. I know that it does at my club.

Lastly, it has to be mutual. If the club is doing something for JCCFS, then JCCFS should be doing something in return. Scholarships, discounts, whatever... both sides win! Long term means that everything that both sides ever do is paying it forward...

Steve

Re: Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

keith tompkins

Hi Ed, I teach on a regular basis at Brookfield Craft Center in Connecticut. I think the course description is KEY to getting people interested in considering a class. Some of my classes had titles such as: "Turn a Masterpiece",or " The Art of the Finial". My next class is "The Art of the Bowl". The idea behind the "masterpiece" class was to encourage those taking the class to focus on JUST THIS ONE piece, and turn the best bowl ever. Not speed, not quantity, just the very best they were capable of....and HOW to accomplish it. The "finial" class description stated that students would bring home examples of finials far better than they ever thought possible. The proposed bowl class caters to those who already can turn bowls; I'm challenging students to bring their work to a higher level. Does it work? I had 13 people sign up for a 6 person finial class, so this fall I'll probably repeat that one. I had a student from my "masterpiece" class confide after the class that he had turned countless bowls, but hadn't been happy with any of them. During the class, he finally turned a piece he was thrilled with. So, the idea is to not just turn a bowl, turn a better bowl. Turn a better finial. Challenge yourself to bring your work to new, higher levels.

Re: Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

#13

Re: Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

Chris Hoehle

Ed, I've been thinking a lot about this very same topic. I live in Colorado and Anderson Ranch is therefore the major school that is closest to me. I got a chance to go for the first time last year and I learned so much during my class. The instruction was top notch, the facility is amazing both in terms of an inspiring setting, and top-shelf equipment, and the on-site dorms and cafeteria had great food and provided more than reasonable prices on lodging given the area (Aspen, CO). I'm headed up there again this summer & can hardly wait!

However, some of the other woodturning classes up there got cancelled last year for low enrollment and this year, they only offered 7 weeks of woodturning vs. 13 weeks last year, so I'm concerned too. I'm fairly young for a woodturner and I want all these schools to be around for a long time to come! I talk Anderson Ranch up every chance I get with fellow woodturners at my club meetings. Maybe I need to post more on the forums I visit about what a great time I had? I know that part of it is of course due to the state of the economy, but it is still sad to see outstanding classes getting cancelled.

I'm planning on seeing if I can give a slide presentation of my time up there at one of my upcoming club meetings to encourage more people to go. Hopefully this can be timed with the beginning of the club's EOG review period for next year & it will encourage people to apply for a grant & go to class!

I'd love to be able to make it out to JCCFS and take a class with you or Mike Stafford sometime but getting to NC from CO adds a lot of travel $$ to the equation...

Re: Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

#14

Hi Chris!  Mike Stafford and I ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

would be delighted to have you in our classes. And I think you would enjoy both. You are right that travel expenses have added an ugly factor in the $$ equation.

You are exactly the person I was talking about and I too want these schools around after us old codgers are gone. I hope that you enjoy your course this summer and that you get a lot out of it.

Ed

Re: Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

#15

Re: Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

Carol Reed, Strawberry, AZ

Last summer I traveled from Arizona to North Carolina to take a class with Mike. It was a trip of a life time! But it WAS pricey and likely will not be repeated. In fact I have a 50 year high school reunion this summer in Minnesota. I had planned to go but got to pushing the pencil. It is just too expensive. I drive lottsa miles each month with my church work. My monthly gas bill is higher than my mortgage was in California! So I need to stay closer to home.

This year I plan to take a class with Cindy Drozda. It will be in California. Short drive relatively speaking and I have friends that I can stay with to further reduce the cost.

Not to get political but when one segment of the economy raises its prices so far that all the other sectors are negatively impacted, times are indeed tough. Such is the cost of travel. Travel for work can hardly be avoided, but travel for pleasure sure gets the short stick!

Re: Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

#16

Thanks Ed!

Chris Hoehle

I'm really looking forward to it. I'm taking "Design & Form" with Jacques Vesery. Jason Schneider, the studio coordinator for woodworking at Anderson Ranch, sounded really excited about it too. He said that when Jacques is at the Ranch, he usually teaches something more along the lines of his detailed carving style or coloring and patinas but that he'd been wanting to teach a design & form class for a while.

Re: Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: Thanks Ed!

keith tompkins

Chris, Jacque's class is exactly what I was trying to say in my post...That would be a topic I would find irresistable! I think sometimes a turner has a lot of interest in taking a class, but instead buys a DVD just to save some money. I think in this economy, there has to be an emotional connection, the turner just HAS to go to the class...there has to be a hook. An odd analogy..I'm restoring an old motorcycle, and saw a set of new-old stock handlebars on ebay. Impossible to find, no longer being produced, and the first set I've ever seen for sale in the last three years. I don't have the money. I gotta have them, and they will certainly go for more than I want to spend anyway. They would be the finishing touch, but, but. Yep, I got them, I paid WAY too much, and they're perfect.

Re: Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

#18

Re: Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

Stuart Johnson

Not to get political but when one segment of the economy raises its prices so far that all the other sectors are negatively impacted, times are indeed tough. Such is the cost of travel. Travel for work can hardly be avoided, but travel for pleasure sure gets the short stick!

While it is by no means trivial I think the price of gasoline might be just a part of the issue. For example in Oct. 2012 the Segmented Woodturners symposium will probably be held at Tahoe, NV. For my wife and I that will be a 1700 (3400 round trip) drive with at least 9 if not more motel nights plus meals and registration. I won't even count the probable casino losses in Las Vegas and Tahoe. Anyway, the F150 gets around 17 mpg so the difference between $4 and $3 gasoline is $200. In my mind if that $200 is sufficient for us to think twice about making the trip then we shouldn't be making it in any event. My point is I think it is easy to pick one aspect of all the price increases and saying this is the total issue. And yes, it would be very easy for this thread to turn into a pitchfork and torches march.

Re: Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

#19

Re: Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

Carol Reed, Strawberry, AZ

I am sorry my comment came off as a 'one segment' issue. It truly is not. Been in the grocery store lately? :)

The problem is that there seem to be fewer areas in my economic sphere in which I have some choices. And groceries happens to be one of them. If the gas tank needs more gallons, then there will be fewer groceries on the shelf. If the house needs more btu's to stay warm, and each btu costs more that it did a year ago, then the thermostat comes down. - and it still costs me more and I am colder. Not happy or healthy.

The cost of this one commodity ripples through all my other costs, escalating to the point of having to do without or less of something else.

As an example, I traded the cost of having TV reception for the occasional wood turning tool. Its more fun. I kept the cost of connecting to the Internet, but dropped the newspaper subscription. And I am well aware that whatever I drop, may well affect someone else's job down the line. You get the idea.

So, my friend, my trip isn't just gas. It is also the costs of a room to sleep in and food to eat- and the fixed costs of maintaining my home. I am one of those 'living on a fixed income' seniors who still works and tries to make a few extra dollars as the opportunity arises. While $200 extra may not be a lot of money, it is a deal breaker for some of us, especially when there are more increased costs to consider as well.

Please, no one take this as a political issue. It isn't. It is a personal one for me.

Re: Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

#20

Steven Antonucci

Wouldn't it be cheaper to fly?

steven antonucci

Not even factoring in the time spent, if you compare the cost of driving to flying, it might be cheaper to just fly there? 200 gallons @ $4+ vs 2 plane tickets has to be a wash, plus you don't end up driving 20-30 hours each way(which would be what sold me!)

Unless you just like driving? @ .50/mi (IRS deduction), they are suggesting it's a $1700 trip...

S

Re: Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

#21

Re: Wouldn't it be cheaper to fly?

Stuart Johnson

I've refused to fly since I was retired. Not out of fear but I will not put up with the hassle. For that matter there is very little I will do if it involves hassles.

Re: Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

#22

Steven Antonucci

Spend 30 hours in the car with my wife :-)

steven antonucci

and you'll redefine the word "hassle".

S

Re: Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

#23

Re: Wouldn't it be cheaper to fly?

Carol Reed, Strawberry, AZ

Not only the hassle, but also the unknown expense up front. With all the 'fees' you really know the entire cost until you get your credit card bill. A dishonorable way of doing business, and I refrain from playing that game!

Re: Arts & Crafts/Woodturning schools

#24

Steven Antonucci

Huh?  I fly all of the time and I don't know what

steven antonucci

you mean?

When you buy a ticket, the price is the price. If you pay $300, it's $300. The only fees are for check baggage, which is $25 each way per bag. I don't check bags unless I am travelling with family, and then I pack one with a ton of stuff (up to 50 pounds, which is the limit, or you get another fee)

If I have to drive from point A to point B, I have tolls, unexpected delays from traffic, accidents, etc. I can hit weather delays. I can have an accident or mechanical breakdown. I can have my car stolen or broken into. It costs more.

At some point, you might get an economy of scale. I fly the wife and 4 kids to Disney every year because it's marginally more expensive than driving when you factor in all of the costs. Time is also money. If I had nowhere to be on any given day, I would enjoy the ride and see the sights.

But I would pay for it...

S