Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

another safety alternative *LINK*

Posts

another safety alternative *LINK*

#1

another safety alternative *LINK*

john lucas

I know some of you are like me and hate face shields. I have tried several and just find them too irritating to use. I purchased a lee Valley face shield that has a screen with plastic where the eyes are. That's better but obviously not as safe. I'm now thinking about a chainsaw helmut (probably without the earmuffs). I always wear eye protection anyway. I don't think the screen will be a huge help but has to be better than nothing and the helmut would certainly help.


http://www.amickssuperstore.com/Husqvarna_Pro_Forest_Helmet_p/husqvarna%20pro%20forest%20helmet.htm

Re: another safety alternative *LINK*

#2

I also don't like turning with a "shield"...

JamieDonaldson

..covering my face, and found this wire mesh was not very sturdy. It is made more for deflecting wood chips from a chainsaw, and nowhere near strong enough to protect the wearer from a serious chunk of flying wood. A baseball catchers mask is the only example that I know of a mask sturdy enough to do that job, and it doesn't shield the smaller chips. I do wear a faceshield when obviously needed, and ALWAYS wear protective glasses, but mostly pay attention to not placing myself in a free fire zone.

Re: another safety alternative *LINK*

#3

Re: another safety alternative

Jeff Willaford

3M makes a forestry helment that accepts a variety of shields including impact resistent polycarbonate shields. Not affiliated with their business. Just posting information.

Re: another safety alternative *LINK*

#4

Re: another safety alternative

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

John,

Look for an "Airstream" rig with includes a hardhat, polycarb face shield, and filtered air supply. Bill Grumbine uses one most of the time. Not real pretty (the helmet not Bill), but it works, except for the burrito effect.

Re: another safety alternative *LINK*

#5

Richard Allen

Re: another safety alternative *LINK*

Richard Allen

There are helmets and face shields designed for protection from ballistic forces. The face shields are rated for deflecting multiple 9 mm rounds. I know a 9 mm round isn't a lot of force but that is a LOT more force than what would destroy the face shields most woodturners wear.

I do not wear or own one of these. I have never seen one used. I don't know how effective this would be.


example of ballistic face shield

Re: another safety alternative *LINK*

#6

JL

I use this with my chainsaw

JL

also when I'm weed-whacking.

It actually is reasonably comfortable.

Re: another safety alternative *LINK*

#7

Keep the ear muffs John!!

Jorge Casta�eda

I was thinking the same John. I had one years ago and it does help, once cutting a spruce bow, it sprang back and hit me on the right earmuff, I was glad I had that protection, and for me that work in a non heated shop, it will not fog which is a welcome thing.

So keep the earmuffs, your ears will be protected from flying projectiles and as a bonus they keep warm...:o))

Re: another safety alternative *LINK*

#8

Re: Keep the ear muffs John!!

John Lucas

Jorge You didn't hear about my latest fiasco. I had 5 trees go down in my yard. I was cutting them up. I use the hearing protection and safety glass all the time when using the chainsaw. However I had them off and was moving limbs. One of them popped back and hit me in the ear. I heard this crunching sound and My ear was extremely soar for a week. It's been 2 weeks now and it's mostly healed but still kind of tender to the touch. Can you actually break your ear? Sure felt like it.

Re: another safety alternative *LINK*

#9

Brad Vietje

Hmmm... Some Sorta Combo?

Brad Vietje

I thought I'd try the screen type face shield, so I'm glad to learn of its pros and cons. What if we took a heavy wire mask like a catcher or umpire would wear, and add the wire mesh to it for a combined effect?

I like the no-fog feature of the mesh, and if we added the safety of a rugged face mask or football helmet, we might be onto something here....

Would it work?

Would you wear it?

I'd give it a try, and will try to find just such a thing. If we have to fabricate these, then heck, maybe I'll set up a little side line business and sell them...

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: another safety alternative *LINK*

#10

Re: Hmmm... Some Sorta Combo?

Richard Jones

Would the chips/dust collect on the mesh due to force and/or dampness from your exhalations? (not to be confused with exultations........) Or is it far enough away from your face for the breath thing not to matter?

Rich

Re: another safety alternative *LINK*

#11

Betty Scarpino

hockey helmet

Betty Scarpino

Try a hockey helmet/mask, the kind youth wear (not the ones the pros wear). My youngest son played ice hockey from gradeschool through highschool. A hockey mask will protect an entire head from the hardest slapshot of a frozen puck, as well as a crash into the boards or metal goalpost (might break your neck or a collarbone, though). Be sure to wear a mouth guard, just in case ... it'll keep your teeth safe.

Re: another safety alternative *LINK*

#12

Re: hockey helmet

Don Orr

Isn't that what David Lancaster uses after his well publicized injury? Seems like a good idea. Maybe a modified version designed for turners and woodworkers specifically. I like ear protection as well-my DC is noisy.

Hmmm, did I just give away my million dollar idea???

Re: another safety alternative *LINK*

#13

This looks informative  *LINK*

John Lucas


http://www.elvex.com/face-protection-start.htm

Re: another safety alternative *LINK*

#14

Brad Vietje

Re: Hmmm... Some Sorta Combo?

Brad Vietje

Well, that gives me an idea... how about a blower that circulates fresh air out the front...? Keeps fresh air near the nose and mouth, and blows away the moisture and the chips. Would it work?

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: another safety alternative *LINK*

#15

Re: Airstream?

Steve Criscenzo

I am not sure of the specs but I think the Airstream helmet and face mask combo is quite stout and would stand up to quite an impact. Of those I have looked at, it appears the strongest. Plus it protects your lungs as well...

Re: another safety alternative *LINK*

#16

Betty Scarpino

Re: hockey helmet

Betty Scarpino

Yes, I believe that's what Dave wears (or did, I don't know if he still wears one). Anyone seeing the photo of his face after the accident would be a believer in safety gear for your face.

Re: another safety alternative *LINK*

#17

Mike Mills

Re: another safety alternative

Mike Mills

Richard Allen said..

�There are helmets and face shields designed for protection from ballistic forces. The face shields are rated for deflecting multiple 9 mm rounds. I know a 9 mm round isn't a lot of force but that is a LOT more force than what would destroy the face shields most woodturners wear.

I do not wear or own one of these. I have never seen one used. I don't know how effective this would be. �

OK, I�m weird.

I have been wearing one for over a year. I have another which I modified for the summer; cut out most of the top for air flow. About $20 each with shipping and ballistics rated. Ex-riot/bomb squard helmelt.

Better to be a dork than a dead dork.

Yes I had cut off the ear and neck protection also.


img

Re: another safety alternative *LINK*

#18

Richard Allen

Re: hockey helmet

Richard Allen

The David Lancaster accident was in "American Woodturner" volume 1 of 2001. I saw a demo by Dave at the KC symposium in 2005. He was not wearing a face protection. He was asked during the demo about his wearing a hockey helmet. He grinned and said he didn't wear that any more. We asked why (that particular rotation was sparsely attended, there were maybe 10 folks attending) he didn't wear face protection. David's answer was basically "I don't think my reason has any bearing on your choice". That was a long time ago so it is quite possible that David is wearing some sort of face protection now.

Re: another safety alternative *LINK*

#19

Re: hockey helmet

Jorge Casta�eda

Don, Dave uses an airstream and pumps air from the outside, not from the shop.

Re: another safety alternative *LINK*

#20

Keith Tompkins

Re: Hmmm... Some Sorta Combo?

keith tompkins

Hey Brad, the mask is the other idea I'm tinkering with..add a polycarbonate shield to something resembling a catcher's mask. That might be the way to go. Mesh would work too.

Re: another safety alternative *LINK*

#21

Re: use care when adapting equipment

Steve Criscenzo

One needs to be very careful when adapting equipment for one use to be used as protection in another application.

Hockey helmets, chainsaw helmets, catchers masks ... are all designed for a specific hazard. Hazards that may or may not be the same as wooturning. It could be very dangerous to get a false sense of security with the wrong gear.

Re: another safety alternative *LINK*

#22

Bottom Line: We need to use PPE

Ed Larson

To me the bottom line of this discussion is that you are all aware of the need to use personal protective equipment (PPE). The type of PPE will depend upon the task, pen turners reqirements are much different than those turning 50-100 lb bowl blanks. My recently purchased Uvex will probably give me 100 % protection from flying chips and small projectiles but only limited or no protection from the 50 lb bowl blank. I need to know realize this. PPE should not preempt save turning practices but it should always be used.

Re: another safety alternative *LINK*

#23

Re: another safety alternative

Philip Duffy

When dealing with very unstable pieces, green wood usually, I have and use a welders helmet. That little glass plate, when fitted with clear glass, is more than enough to show where the tool goes and it sturdy enough to withstand a 3g. impact. Saved me more than once. Hock shops have them for very little money. Phil

Re: another safety alternative *LINK*

#24

Betty Scarpino

dust protection

Betty Scarpino

Even though Dave got smacked in the face with a chunk of wood, it's actually the dust from woodturning that is more likely to make his life miserable (or kill him slowly), so good for him for wearing a dust-protection helmet.

The part I dislike about teaching workshops is breathing the sawdust in the room. Most local-chapter meeting spaces have no dust control and it's not really feasible to wear the proper head gear to eliminate dust when teaching.

(I like Dave's response: that his reasons should have no bearing on someone else's decision to wear --or not wear-- protective headgear.)

Re: another safety alternative *LINK*

#25

+1 on Airstream

Jim H

I got it mainly for lung protection, but the helmet + polycarb face shield are fairly stout.

I mainly turn small stuff, but turning from a chair, its hard to stay out of the line of fire. I probably could not have afforded it if I didn�t find it used, but even at full price its cheaper then my ER co-pay, and probably about 1/1000th of a lung transplant. :D

I was very surprised at the comfort, and nice cooling effect.