Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Killed While Turning?...

Posts

Killed While Turning?...

#1

Killed While Turning?...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

There have been a number of posts in recent threads on lathe safety that mention Death as a result of a lathe accident. I know that it's possible. Other than the recent post about a schoolgirl turning on a metal lathe, has anyone ever actually heard of someone being killed while using a wood lathe?

I am in no way making light of the possible dangers while using using a lathe. Especially after the recent posts telling of very serious accidents. One was by an experienced turner.

I have never heard of a way to make woodturning completely safe. Using safe and sane turning methods plus some luck is the only way I know.

In my many years of teaching I have had some problem students who were over aggresive in their turning and refused to adhere to my rules of safety. In a very few instances I've kicked some out of the class because they were a danger to other students as well as themselves. They were a bad accident waiting to happen.

On the other hand, accidents happen to experienced turners who are always cautious. Well, nearly always. A friend called me one day to tell me of an accident that he'd had. He likes to turn big burls and had mounted one on the lathe. He flipped the switch and some time later woke up on the floor in a pool of blood and a smashed face. Results..some new teeth, over 100 stitches, a broken nose. He considers himself lucky it wasn't worse. The cause of the accident? He forgot that he had recently been turning some pens at about 3000 rpm. He didn't check the speed setting when he mounted the 50 or 60 lb. burl.

We should all have a strict routine with safety in mind for everything we do at the lathe. Plus have a little luck.

I've been lucky in my 70 plus years of woodturning. A few accidents but nothing serious. No scars. In fact the only woodworking scar I have is a scar on my thumb where I cut into a knuckle with the bandsaw...after I had turned the saw off!

Re: Killed While Turning?...

#2

Re: Killed While Turning?...

robo hippy

I have heard of people forgetting to turn down the speed first a number of times, including recently at one of our club meetings. Perhaps in the interest of safety, a lathe start up system should always return to zero when switched off. It is habit for me, and whenever I put some thing new on the lathe, speed goes almost to zero unless I am turning a bunch of bowls the same size.

robo hippy

Re: Killed While Turning?...

#3

Re: Killed While Turning?...

Ralph Lindberg

Wally

Two years ago there was a woodturner in Canada, killed when the bowl he was turning "blew up"

Unless you have heard otherwise, all the news reports I saw, stated the the college student was killed working on a wood lathe (not that there is that much difference if one's hair gets tangled in the chuck)

As for the actual death rate, the rule of thumb is typical death rate at any activity is anywhere from 2x to 10x what any person sees reported in the media. This is due to the "local" media not carrying any particular story as it "didn't make the cut" (for that day).

As some examples, when was the last time you heard of anyone dying in a martial arts competition? (average is 2 per year in Judo alone). Being crushed by a Farm Tractor? (8 in Washington State in 2010 alone).

One of the neat things about having a wife that is both a Turner and edits CE classes for EMTs and Paramedics is the odd(ish) facts she retains.

Re: Killed While Turning?...

#4

Re: Killed While Turning?...

Ralph Lindberg

Robo

The Nova DVR resets to 500 rpm, when turned off. That's usually a safe speed with any object.

All I have to do is turn it off, every one (I do forget once in awhile)

Re: Killed While Turning?...

#5

Steven Antonucci

I am surprised it doesn't happen more often?

steven antonucci

When I watch what some people do, I am completely shocked that we aren't hearing a lot more about it. One of the things I am most sensitive to is "the professional". This is typically a successful person who has taken up turning and assumes that he or she (ok, it's ALWAYS a he) is also going to be automatically great at it.

I used to race mountain bikes, and one day at the bike shop, we were introduced to a guy who was a stock broker. He seemed like a nice guy, and we decided to ask him to join us on our next group ride. First time on the trail, he was showing off and had some skills, but shouldn't have been going so fast... because trees win the battle if you run into them. Broken clavicle.

A healthy does of respect at the lathe is certainly a great idea.

S

Only 15 years at a lathe, and nothing to report except a few minor nicks...

Re: Killed While Turning?...

#6

Re: Killed While Turning?...

robo hippy

Our club demo was on a Nova DVR, which was at very high rpm. The turner was able to turn it off the first time after noticing it was at very high rpm. He started it up again, and tried to slow it down like a conventional variable speed lathe, but the Nova ramps down very slowly. The piece flew off. This might be an older model which doesn't reset to lower speeds, or that function was turned off. Always check the speed first, and turn it on without anything on it at all to make sure the speed is where you want it.

robo hippy

Re: Killed While Turning?...

#7

Re: Killed While Turning?...

Stuart Johnson

I recently posted about what an idiot I am but with that said when I go to the lathe I follow these rules:

1. Put on the face mask hanging from the tail stock.

2. Check the lathe speed setting

3. Check that the on off switch is set to off.

4. Plug in the lathe.

5. Turn on the lathe.

6. Start the lathe on the lowest setting.

I never vary from this routine regardless what if anything is on the lathe. It probably doesn't take more than 10 seconds longer than just walking up an starting it. If I can't take this time then I don't have time to be in the shop.

Re: Killed While Turning?...

#8

Re: Killed While Turning?...

Thad Parker

My lathe has this feature. The on/off switch is built into the speed control lever. In order to be turned off, it must be returned to the slowest position. This prevents it from being at high speed when turned on.

It's a 1939 J.A. Faye & Egan model 400

I turn on my FIL's pm 3520b a few times a year, and returning to my lathe, the only thing I miss from the pm is the digital speed readout. I don't feel inconvenienced by this safety feature.

~ Thad

Re: Killed While Turning?...

#9

Re: Killed While Turning?...

Stephen Mushinski

Wally - The Ontario, Canada death was real it did happen a couple of years ago.

I am not so sure you are lucky. I suspect you are very safety orientated when it comes to your shop and turning. We met once and you strike me as being very serious when it comes to woodturning and turning that switch to the on position. Mistakes happen but I will guess in 70 years you have made very few.

Re: Killed While Turning?...

#10

Right Start

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

I've introduced 15-20 people to woodturning, mostly scouts from local troops that I assist. My introduction to the machine starts with:

"This is a wood lathe. It is used to spin a piece of wood so that it can be cut into various rounded forms. There are a number of ways it can and will kill you before you know what happened if you don't respect its ability to cause harm. While this is a rare occurrence, if you think it can't happen to you, you will be the one who proves what I just said is true."

And then we count the ways.

No injuries so far :)

Re: Killed While Turning?...

#11

Re: Killed While Turning?...Yes!!

Jorge Casta�eda


It just happened, it raised its ugly head and a few seconds later it splat in the faceshield...

Jorge,

Running and ducking...

Re: Killed While Turning?...

#12

M-m-m-m-m Cherry flavor, too!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

You do sushi or stir-fry?

Re: Killed While Turning?...

#13

Betty Scarpino

Heavily chocolate coated is the only way .....

Betty Scarpino

Re: Killed While Turning?...

#14

Re: Killed While Turning?...

Ralph Lindberg

Robo, did he turn it OFF (power) or just push the STOP button?

Every DVR I have seen powers up at 500 rpm

Re: Killed While Turning?...

#15

Re: Killed While Turning?...

robo hippy

He started it up twice. The first time, he hit the off button, and it stopped. The second time, he hit the ramp down button, and it moves so slowly that the piece came off, spinning fast, but didn't go high or far. It was a piece of crotch wood that was pressed inbetween the tailstock and the chuck. I have never liked the speed control on the DVR. I got used to the knob on a PM and my Robust. Much more efficient.

robo hippy

Re: Killed While Turning?...

#16

Re: Killed While Turning?...

Andi Wolfe

It has just been reported over on WoW that Joan Kelly succumbed to her injury this morning. My thoughts and prayers are with her family and friends as they deal with their grief.

Re: Killed While Turning?...

#17

Re: Killed While Turning?...

Carole Valentine

Just wondering why, when he he hit the stop button the first time, he didn't lower the speed before turning it back on????

Re: Killed While Turning?...

#18

Re: Killed While Turning?...

robo hippy

Most likely, he was not familiar with this lathe, and figured that the ramp up and down was like a standard variable speed lathe. I do that a lot, knowing that the lathe is at higher speeds, start it then adjust the knob/speed down right away, to proper levels. A lot of other times, I will lower the speed first, then turn it on and adjust it up to desired levels.

I guess it just goes to show you that when you are on an unfamiliar lathe, turn it on and play with the speeds with nothing on the lathe. Then mount what you are going to turn.

robo hippy